Stephanie St. Clair: Harlem’s Numbers Queen

A Harlem street around 1930, the Harlem of Stephanie St. Clair's numbers empire — children playing leapfrog with a period car and brownstones behind them (no free portrait of St. Clair exists; her Wikipedia portrait is fair use)

Reading Time: 4 minutes · A Caribbean immigrant built Harlem’s numbers bank from $10,000 into an empire, employing dozens of runners — then went to war with Dutch Schultz, the most violent gangster in New York, and outlived him. She died wealthy in 1969, largely forgotten. Who was the Queen of Harlem, and why did history lose her?

Jack McGurn: ‘Machine Gun Jack’ and the St. Valentine’s Day Massacre

The Green Mill Cocktail Lounge on Broadway, Chicago, at night — the speakeasy jazz club McGurn part-owned (no free portrait of McGurn exists; his Wikipedia portrait is fair use)

Reading Time: 4 minutes · Capone’s chief gunman is widely believed to have planned the St. Valentine’s Day Massacre — seven men lined against a garage wall — yet he was never charged, and his ‘blonde alibi’ was never disproved. Seven years later, on the massacre’s anniversary, he was shot dead in a bowling alley with a mocking Valentine’s note left behind. Who killed Machine Gun Jack?

Vincent ‘Mad Dog’ Coll: The Baby-Faced Killer of Prohibition New York

Vincent Coll leaving court, handcuffed and wiping his face with a handkerchief, flanked by detectives and a police officer

Reading Time: 4 minutes · At twenty-three, Vincent ‘Mad Dog’ Coll had made himself the most hated man in New York’s underworld — at war with Dutch Schultz, Owney Madden and every major gangster in the city at once. He died in a drugstore phone booth, cut down by a Thompson gun while demanding $50,000 from Madden. No one was ever charged. Who ordered the hit on the Mad Dog?

Trevor Hardy, the Beast of Manchester

Lock 65 on the Rochdale Canal at Failsworth, where Sharon Mosoph's body was found

Reading Time: 4 minutes · Three teenage girls were murdered in north Manchester in fifteen months, and one lay undiscovered in a shallow grave for almost two years. Hardy confessed to all three — yet a fourth case, Dorothy Leyden in 1971, was never charged, and the file leaves it open.

The Assassination of James Garfield: A Disappointed Office-Seeker and a Dying President

President James A. Garfield, in a painted portrait by G. F. Gilman

Reading Time: 4 minutes · A disappointed office-seeker shot President Garfield in a railway station in July 1881 — and the president lingered for eleven weeks while his doctors probed the wound with unsterilised hands. Historians say the bullet might not have killed him; the treatment did. Was Garfield murdered by his assassin, or by his doctors?

Owney Madden

A profile portrait of a young Owney Madden in a suit and tie, from a 1926 book on New York's gangs

Reading Time: 4 minutes · Shot eleven times and left for dead at twenty, Owney Madden went on to run the Cotton Club and rule Harlem’s underworld — then walked away from it all and died peacefully in Arkansas at seventy-three. He was one of the few gangsters of his generation to die in bed. How did ‘The Killer’ get out alive?