Vincent ‘Mad Dog’ Coll: The Baby-Faced Killer of Prohibition New York

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

Vincent Coll was twenty-three years old when he died, and in the four years of his criminal career he had managed to make himself the most hated man in New York’s underworld. He had been Dutch Schultz’s enforcer, then Schultz’s enemy. He had kidnapped children for ransom, been blamed for the death of a five-year-old boy, and gone to war with every major gangster in the city at once. When he was finally killed, in a drugstore phone booth in Manhattan in the early hours of 8 February 1932, there was hardly a gangster in New York who mourned him — and one of his enemies is reported to have sent flowers to his funeral.

Coll was born Uinseann Ó Colla on 20 July 1908 in Bunbeg, in the Irish-speaking district of Gweedore, County Donegal, Ireland, the seventh child of a small farmer. His family emigrated to the United States a year later, and he was raised in the Bronx by an elderly woman who took him in as her own. He was expelled from a succession of Catholic reform schools and joined the Gophers, a street gang of the Bronx and Hell’s Kitchen, where he came to the attention of Dutch Schultz — born Arthur Flegenheimer — who controlled the bootleg liquor trade in the Bronx. Schultz took the boy on as an armed guard for his beer trucks, and then as an assassin. Coll was young, handsome and baby-faced, and he was utterly ruthless.

Breaking with Schultz

Coll’s ruthlessness made him valuable to Schultz at first, but it also made him uncontrollable. He began operating on his own, defying Schultz’s orders, and he recruited his own gang from within Schultz’s organisation. The break became open war. In May 1931 Schultz’s men killed Coll’s brother Peter, and Coll answered by gunning down four of Schultz’s men in the following three weeks, according to contemporary accounts. By the end of 1931 both Schultz and the Irish gang leader Owney Madden were said to have put a fifty-thousand-dollar price on Coll’s head.

The episode that gave Coll his nickname — and his reputation — came on 28 July 1931. Coll and his men attempted to kidnap Joseph Rao, a bootlegger who worked for Schultz, outside a social club in Harlem. In the shooting that followed, a young child was killed. Coll was tried for the child’s murder in December 1931 and acquitted, but the damage to his name was permanent. The newspapers called him “Mad Dog,” and the name stuck. He was twenty-three, and he was now at war with Schultz, with Madden, and with every other major gangster in New York, who had come to see him as a danger to them all.

The Phone Booth

On 1 February 1932, four or five gunmen invaded a Bronx apartment that Coll was rumoured to frequent and opened fire with pistols and submachine guns. Coll was not there. A week later, in the early hours of 8 February, he walked into the London Chemists drugstore at 314 West 23rd Street, at Eighth Avenue in Manhattan, and stepped into a glass phone booth. He was reportedly calling Owney Madden, demanding fifty thousand dollars and threatening to kidnap Madden’s brother-in-law. Madden, according to the standard account, kept him talking on the line while the call was traced.

Three men arrived in a dark limousine. One waited in the car while the other two stepped out; one of them waited outside while the other walked into the store, told the cashier to “Keep cool, now,” drew a Thompson submachine gun from under his overcoat and opened fire on Coll in the booth. Fifteen bullets were dug out of Coll’s body at the morgue, and more may have passed through him. He died instantly. He was twenty-three years old.

Coll was buried beside his brother Peter at St. Raymond’s Cemetery in the Bronx. Dutch Schultz is reported to have sent a floral wreath to the funeral — a final insult, or a final tribute, depending on who tells the story. Schultz himself was murdered three years later, in October 1935, on the orders of the National Crime Syndicate. Coll’s killers were never identified, and no one was ever charged with his murder. He had lived fast, killed without hesitation, and died as he had lived — in the middle of a war he had started himself, against men who were older, richer and better connected than he was, and who had finally decided that he had to go.

What Is Documented — and What Is Not

Documented: Vincent Coll was born Uinseann Ó Colla on 20 July 1908 in Bunbeg, Gweedore, County Donegal, Ireland; his family emigrated to the United States a year later, and he was raised in the Bronx. He joined the Gophers street gang and became an enforcer and assassin for Dutch Schultz. He broke with Schultz and formed his own gang; his brother Peter was killed by Schultz’s men in May 1931. On 28 July 1931 Coll took part in a kidnapping attempt on the bootlegger Joseph Rao in which a young child was killed; Coll was tried for the child’s murder in December 1931 and acquitted. By early 1932 both Schultz and Owney Madden were said to have put a $50,000 price on his head. In the early hours of 8 February 1932 Coll was shot dead in a glass phone booth at the London Chemists drugstore, 314 West 23rd Street at Eighth Avenue, Manhattan, by a gunman with a Thompson submachine gun; fifteen bullets were recovered from his body. He was 23. He is buried beside his brother Peter at St. Raymond’s Cemetery in the Bronx. No one was ever charged with his murder.

Not documented / unverified: The claim that Madden kept Coll talking on the telephone while the call was traced is the standard account, but it rests on second-hand reports. The identity of the gunman is not established; one frequently repeated account names Bo Weinberg, a Schultz gunman, but this has never been proven. The details of Schultz’s wreath at Coll’s funeral are reported but the wording on it varies between accounts. The number of Schultz’s men Coll killed in revenge for his brother’s death is given as four in some accounts and is not independently confirmed.

Sources

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mad_Dog_Coll
https://www.dib.ie/index.php/biography/coll-vincent-mad-dog-a1839
https://historycollection.com/5-gangsters-public-enemies-1920s-1930s-probably-havent-heard/2/
https://en-academic.com/dic.nsf/enwiki/1535026http:/en.academic.ru/dic.nsf/enwiki/323312

Leave a Comment