Vincent ‘Mad Dog’ Coll: The Baby-Faced Killer of Prohibition New York

Vincent Coll leaving court, handcuffed and wiping his face with a handkerchief, flanked by detectives and a police officer

Reading Time: 4 minutes · At twenty-three, Vincent ‘Mad Dog’ Coll had made himself the most hated man in New York’s underworld — at war with Dutch Schultz, Owney Madden and every major gangster in the city at once. He died in a drugstore phone booth, cut down by a Thompson gun while demanding $50,000 from Madden. No one was ever charged. Who ordered the hit on the Mad Dog?

Owney Madden

A profile portrait of a young Owney Madden in a suit and tie, from a 1926 book on New York's gangs

Reading Time: 4 minutes · Shot eleven times and left for dead at twenty, Owney Madden went on to run the Cotton Club and rule Harlem’s underworld — then walked away from it all and died peacefully in Arkansas at seventy-three. He was one of the few gangsters of his generation to die in bed. How did ‘The Killer’ get out alive?

Frank Nitti: The Enforcer Who Ran the Outfit

The grave of Frank Nitti at Mount Carmel Cemetery, Hillside, Illinois — a large stone cross headstone (no free portrait of Nitti exists; his Wikipedia portrait is fair use)

Reading Time: 4 minutes · Frank Nitti was Capone’s quiet money man, the Enforcer who ran the Chicago Outfit for twelve years after Capone went to prison — until a Hollywood extortion indictment in March 1943 left him facing a return to the prison he dreaded, and he took his own life beside a railway line in North Riverside.

Arnold Rothstein

A black-and-white portrait of Arnold Rothstein in a suit and tie, looking slightly to one side

Reading Time: 4 minutes · They called him ‘The Brain’ — the gambler who, it was said, could fix anything except the weather. Arnold Rothstein was never convicted of fixing the 1919 World Series, but his name has been tied to it ever since. He was shot dead in 1928, and his murder was never solved.

Johnny Torrio: The Man Who Built the Chicago Outfit

Portrait of Johnny Torrio in a fedora and overcoat, 1939

Reading Time: 4 minutes · Johnny Torrio never fired the shots that made him famous. He was the organiser who turned Chicago’s street rackets into a business empire, handed it to Al Capone, and walked away — then died quietly of a heart attack in a Brooklyn barber’s chair in 1957.

George ‘Bugs’ Moran: The Last of the North Side Gang

Portrait of George 'Bugs' Moran in a pinstripe suit, c. 1930

Reading Time: 4 minutes · George ‘Bugs’ Moran survived the St. Valentine’s Day Massacre only because he arrived late — then watched his gang, his money and his power drain away, ending his life as a forgotten bank robber who died of lung cancer in Leavenworth prison in 1957.

Hymie Weiss: The Man Who Declared War on Capone

Portrait of Hymie Weiss, Chicago Tribune photograph

Reading Time: 4 minutes · Hymie Weiss took over the North Side Gang after his best friend Dean O’Banion was murdered in 1924 and turned the Chicago gang war into a personal vendetta — until Capone’s gunmen cut him down outside Holy Name Cathedral on 11 October 1926. He was 28.

Dean O’Banion: The Florist of the North Side

Portrait of Dean O'Banion, 1921

Reading Time: 4 minutes · Dean O’Banion ran Chicago’s North Side Gang from a flower shop across the street from Holy Name Cathedral — and was shot dead in that same shop on 10 November 1924, opening a five-year gang war that ended in the St. Valentine’s Day Massacre.

Legs Diamond

Jack 'Legs' Diamond in an overcoat and fedora, photographed before 1931.

Reading Time: 5 minutes · Jack “Legs” Diamond was shot at, stabbed at, and hunted for more than a decade — and he kept surviving, until the morning of 18 December 1931, when he was found shot dead in a boarding house in Albany. He was a Prohibition bootlegger, an enforcer and a killer; who ordered his murder has never been proved, and even his birth name is disputed.