Arnold Rothstein

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

Arnold Rothstein was the most famous gambler in America, and the most feared. He was known as “The Brain”, “The Fixer” and “The Big Bankroll”, and his name was attached to the greatest scandal in the history of American sport: the fixing of the 1919 World Series. Rothstein always denied that he had organised it. He was indicted, investigated and questioned, but he was never convicted of anything. He died as he had lived — over a gambling debt. On 4 November 1928, he was shot in a Manhattan hotel, and he died two days later without naming his killer. His murder has never been solved.

The Brain

Rothstein was born in Manhattan on 17 January 1882, the son of a successful businessman. He was a poor student and a brilliant gambler, and by his twenties he was running poolrooms and bookmaking operations across New York. He understood odds better than anyone in the city, and he understood people better still. He bet on horses, on cards, on elections — on anything that could be wagered on — and he usually won, because he bet with information and with discipline, and because he was willing to pay for both.

He built his fortune during Prohibition, when he moved into bootlegging, rum-running and illegal casinos. He also built something else: the model for modern organised crime in America. Rothstein was the first to see that the city’s gangs, which had fought each other for street corners, could be organised into a national business. He mentored the men who would run that business after him — Lucky Luciano, Meyer Lansky and Frank Costello among them. F. Scott Fitzgerald is widely said to have modelled the gangster Meyer Wolfsheim in “The Great Gatsby” on Rothstein.

The 1919 World Series

In the autumn of 1919, the Chicago White Sox, the best team in baseball, met the Cincinnati Reds in the World Series. The White Sox were heavy favourites, and they lost. Eight of their players, including the great hitter Shoeless Joe Jackson and the pitcher Eddie Cicotte, were later accused of accepting money from gamblers to throw the series. The scandal became known as the Black Sox Scandal, and it nearly destroyed professional baseball.

Rothstein’s name was at the centre of it from the start. The story, as it was told at the time, was that his agents had paid the players, and that Rothstein himself had bet heavily on Cincinnati and made a large profit — estimates of his winnings range from $250,000 to $350,000. But the evidence for and against his involvement has been argued ever since. Rothstein was called before a grand jury in Chicago in 1920, where he testified that he was an innocent businessman, that he had made money by betting on the result, and that others, perhaps using his name, had corrupted the players. He was never charged. The players were acquitted at trial in 1921, but the first Commissioner of Baseball, Judge Kenesaw Mountain Landis, banned all eight from the game for life.

What is certain is that the fix was organised by gamblers, and that the players were paid — though less than they had been promised, which is one reason some of them later played to win. Whether Rothstein financed the scheme or merely profited from it is a question historians still debate. David Pietrusza, his biographer, argues that the idea came from the players themselves, and that Rothstein’s role was to put up the money. Others have always believed he was the mastermind.

The poker game

By 1928, Rothstein was one of the richest and most powerful men in New York’s underworld. That autumn, he sat down to a high-stakes poker game that lasted three days. When it ended, he owed $320,000 — a fortune at the time, worth roughly $6 million today. Rothstein refused to pay. He claimed the game had been fixed against him, by the gambler Titanic Thompson and his associate Nate Raymond, and that a fixed debt was no debt at all.

On the evening of 4 November 1928, Rothstein went to a meeting at the Park Central Hotel on Seventh Avenue near 55th Street, after receiving a telephone call. An hour later, he staggered out of the hotel, shot in the abdomen with a .38 calibre revolver. He was taken to the Polyclinic Hospital, where he died two days later, on 6 November 1928, aged 46. He refused to tell the police who had shot him, keeping the underworld’s code of silence to the end.

The police arrested George “Hump” McManus, the gambler who had organised the poker game, for the murder. He was acquitted for lack of evidence, and no one was ever convicted of killing Arnold Rothstein. Some have blamed the unpaid debt; others have suggested that Dutch Schultz, a rival gangster, ordered the killing to expand his own empire. The murder remains unsolved.

What is documented — and what is not

Documented: Arnold Rothstein was born in Manhattan on 17 January 1882 and became one of New York’s leading gamblers and bootleggers. In 1919, eight Chicago White Sox players were accused of throwing the World Series to the Cincinnati Reds; Rothstein testified before a grand jury in 1920 and was never charged. The eight players were acquitted in 1921 but banned from baseball for life. On 4 November 1928, Rothstein was shot at the Park Central Hotel in Manhattan and died on 6 November 1928, aged 46. George McManus was tried for the murder and acquitted; no one was ever convicted.

Unverified or unproven: That Rothstein organised the 1919 World Series fix — the evidence is mixed, he denied it, and he was never charged; historians disagree. How much he profited from the series — estimates range from $250,000 to $350,000. That the poker game was fixed against him — Rothstein claimed it was, and the gambler Titanic Thompson is said by some to have rigged it, but this was never proven. Who ordered or carried out his murder — the debt is the usual explanation, but the case was never solved.

Sources

Leave a Comment