The Zodiac Killer: The Letters, the Codes, and the Case That Never Closed

Reading Time: 20 minutes ·

Between December 1968 and October 1969, an unidentified killer attacked seven people in Northern California, then wrote to the newspapers about it. More than fifty years later, his name is still unknown.

CASE FILE No. 62 · 1968

Case File

  • What happened: An unidentified killer attacked seven people in four incidents across Northern California, killing five and wounding two, then wrote letters to Bay Area newspapers claiming the crimes, enclosing ciphers, and threatening more killings.
  • When: December 20, 1968 to October 11, 1969, with letters continuing until January 1974.
  • Where: Benicia, Vallejo, Lake Berryessa and San Francisco — Solano, Napa and San Francisco counties.
  • Status: Cold
  • Verdict: No verdict — case open. No one has ever been charged

Exhibit

The 408-character cipher arrived with the three letters of July 31, 1969, split in three parts across the San Francisco Chronicle, the San Francisco Examiner and the Vallejo Times-Herald. Within about a week, Donald Harden — a high school teacher in Salinas — and his wife Bettye worked out the solution: a statement of motive that named no one. The cipher is the exhibit because it is the document that turned a murder case into a puzzle the whole country tried to solve — and because its answer, when it came, told the police nothing at all.

Timeline

  • 20 December 1968 — David Faraday and Betty Lou Jensen are shot on Lake Herman Road, Benicia.
  • 4 July 1969 — Darlene Ferrin is killed and Michael Mageau wounded at Blue Rock Springs, Vallejo.
  • 31 July 1969 — The first letters arrive at three Bay Area newspapers, each carrying a third of the 408-character cipher.
  • 4 August 1969 — A letter opens with the words ‘this is the Zodiac speaking.’ The killer names himself.
  • 27 September 1969 — Bryan Hartnell is wounded and Cecelia Shepard killed at Lake Berryessa.
  • 11 October 1969 — Paul Stine is shot in Presidio Heights, San Francisco; the last confirmed killing.
  • 8 November 1969 — The 340-character cipher is mailed to the Chronicle.
  • January 1974 — The last confirmed letter arrives, claiming thirty-seven victims.
  • May 2018 — Vallejo police announce they will try genetic genealogy on the stamps and envelopes.
  • 5 December 2020 — The 340 cipher is solved by David Oranchak, Sam Blake and Jarl Van Eycke; the FBI confirms it.

On the night of December 20, 1968, two teenagers parked on a gravel turnout off Lake Herman Road, a quiet country road outside Benicia, California. David Arthur Faraday was seventeen. Betty Lou Jensen was sixteen. It was, by every account that survived them, their first date. They had gone to a Christmas concert at their high school that evening, and then driven out to the turnout to talk, the way teenagers did on a Friday night in a small town. A little after eleven, a car pulled in behind them. What happened next took only minutes.

Nobody who found them that night knew what they were looking at. The local police had no motive to work with, no robbery, no argument, no witness who had seen a face. Two young people had been shot on a dark road for no reason anyone could name, and the case file, opened that night in Solano County, had almost nothing in it. It would sit that way for more than six months, a local tragedy with no thread to pull. Then, in the summer of 1969, the thread arrived, and it arrived in the mail.

The case that grew out of that night is the most famous unsolved murder case in American history, and it is famous for the wrong reasons. The killer gave himself a name, drew himself a symbol, and wrote letters to the newspapers claiming his crimes and enclosing codes he said would reveal his identity. The letters made him a celebrity. The codes made him a puzzle. And underneath all of that there are five people who were killed and two who survived, and families who have waited more than half a century for an answer that has never come.

The First Night

Lake Herman Road runs through open country east of Benicia, in Solano County, about thirty miles northeast of San Francisco. In 1968 it was a lonely stretch even by the standards of the time, a place where young people went to be alone and where a car parked after dark drew no attention at all. David Faraday drove a Rambler station wagon that night. He and Betty Lou Jensen had been at the high school concert, and the plan, as far as anyone later reconstructed it, was simple: a drive, a talk, home by midnight.

The first person to reach them was a woman driving past the turnout who saw the two bodies on the ground and stopped. Help came quickly, but it came too late. Faraday had been shot in the head. Jensen had been shot several times as she tried to run. Both were dead before they reached a hospital. The deputies who worked the scene found spent cartridge cases and little else. There were no signs of a struggle inside the car, no valuables taken, no note, no message. The killer had come out of the dark, fired, and gone.

The investigation that followed was thorough and, for months, fruitless. Detectives interviewed the teenagers’ friends and families and everyone who had been at the concert, looking for enemies, for jealous boyfriends, for anyone with a reason to harm two teenagers on a first date. There was no one. The case was going nowhere.

A Second Attack, and a Voice on the Phone

On the night of July 4, 1969, Darlene Ferrin, twenty-two, and Michael Mageau, nineteen, were parked in Mageau’s car in the lot at Blue Rock Springs Park, on the edge of Vallejo. It was just after midnight, the early minutes of July 5. A man approached the car carrying a flashlight. He fired through the open window, again and again, then walked away into the dark. Ferrin died at Kaiser Foundation Hospital. Mageau survived, badly wounded, and lived to describe what he had seen.

Minutes after the shooting, a man telephoned the Vallejo police department. He reported a double murder, gave the location of the park, and said he was the one who had done it. The call was calm and brief. It was the first time the killer had spoken to the police, and it told detectives the shooting was not a random act.

Mageau’s survival mattered for another reason. He gave police a description of the man he had seen, a man in his late twenties or thirties, heavy-set, with a round face. It was the first description of the killer anyone had, and it would be compared, for years, against every man who came under suspicion. Two attacks, months apart, on young people parked in cars at night, now looked like the work of one man, and the case stopped being two local tragedies and became something larger.

The Letters Begin

On July 31, 1969, three letters arrived at three Bay Area newspapers: the San Francisco Chronicle, the San Francisco Examiner, and the Vallejo Times-Herald. They were nearly identical. Each claimed responsibility for the shootings at Lake Herman Road and at Blue Rock Springs, giving details of the crimes that had not been published, and each contained one third of a cipher, a block of symbols 408 characters long in total. The writer demanded that the newspapers print the cipher on their front pages, and threatened to go on killing if they did not. The newspapers printed their portions.

Four days later, on August 4, another letter arrived at the Examiner, opening with the words that gave the case its name: this is the Zodiac speaking. From that day on, the killer had a name of his own invention, and he signed his letters with a symbol he had also invented, a circle with a cross inside it, like the crosshairs of a gunsight.

The cipher itself was solved faster than anyone expected. Within about a week, Donald Harden, a high school teacher in Salinas, and his wife Bettye, who shared his interest in codes, worked out the solution. It was a substitution cipher, and the message it contained was not a name or a location. It was a statement of motive, written by a man who said he killed because he enjoyed it, and who claimed his victims would serve him in the afterlife. The Hardens’ solution was checked and authenticated, and it was published. It told the police nothing about who the writer was, and that was the pattern the case would follow for the next fifty years: every clue the killer offered turned out to be a dead end, and every dead end made him more famous.

The letters kept coming, and they are the reason the case is remembered the way it is. A killer who writes to the newspapers is a killer who is performing, and the performance worked. The Zodiac became a character in the public imagination, a figure in films and books and Halloween costumes, and the performance has never really stopped. But it is worth remembering what the letters actually were: evidence, handled by detectives and examined by the FBI laboratory, and the only direct contact anyone ever had with the man who killed five people. What he said, across dozens of letters and cards over five years, was mostly threats, complaints, and claims. He claimed far more victims than the police could ever confirm. He threatened schoolchildren, and buses, and bombs that were never found. The letters are not the record of a criminal mastermind. They are the record of a man who wanted to be feared and famous, and who found a way to be both.

Lake Berryessa

On the afternoon of September 27, 1969, Bryan Hartnell, twenty, and Cecelia Shepard, twenty-two, were picnicking on a remote stretch of shore at Lake Berryessa, in Napa County. It was a Saturday, warm and clear, and the shore was empty except for the two of them. A man appeared, wearing a dark hooded costume with the crossed-circle symbol stitched on the chest, and carrying a gun. He told them he had escaped from prison and needed their car and their money to get to Mexico. Then he bound their hands with lengths of plastic clothesline he had brought with him, and attacked them with a knife.

Hartnell survived. Shepard died two days later, on September 29, at Queen of the Valley Hospital in Napa. The attack at Lake Berryessa was different from the first two in almost every way: different weapon, different setting, daylight instead of darkness, a costume instead of a shadow. It was the only one of the four attacks in which the killer showed his symbol worn openly. The killer stopped on his way out and wrote on the door of Hartnell’s car, in black felt pen, the dates and places of the earlier attacks, the date of this one, the time, and the words by knife.

Before the sun had set that evening, a man telephoned the Napa County sheriff’s office from a pay phone and reported a double murder at the lake, giving directions to the scene and saying he was the one who had done it. The call was traced to a phone booth not far from the sheriff’s office itself, a detail that detectives would turn over for years. It was the third time he had announced himself, and by now the pattern was unmistakable: he killed, and then he made sure everyone knew.

Shepard’s death hit the case differently from the others. She was a student, twenty-two years old, and her family and friends spoke about her publicly in the days after the attack. Hartnell, recovering in hospital, gave police the most detailed description anyone had yet provided of the man in the hood. The costume, the symbol, the binding, the writing on the car door: all of it was now part of the record, and all of it pointed to a killer who was not only violent but theatrical.

Presidio Heights

On the night of October 11, 1969, Paul Stine, twenty-nine, a graduate student who drove a cab at night to support his studies, picked up a fare downtown who asked to be taken to the Presidio Heights neighbourhood, a quiet district of large houses near the Presidio. A few blocks from the destination, the passenger shot him. Three teenagers in a house across the street saw what happened and called the police.

The response was fast, and it produced the closest the case ever came to an arrest. A patrolman named Donald Fouke, responding to the call, saw a man walking away from the scene on a nearby street. The radioed description of the suspect, however, described a Black man, and the man Fouke saw was white, so Fouke let him pass and continued toward the cab. By the time the error was corrected, the man was gone. Fouke later worked with a police artist to produce a composite sketch, and the teenagers worked with the artist as well, producing a second sketch. The two drawings became the public face of the Zodiac: a man in his late thirties or early forties, heavy-set, with short hair and glasses.

Two days later, on October 13, a letter arrived at the Chronicle claiming responsibility for Stine’s murder. It enclosed a piece of Stine’s shirt, torn from the garment he had been wearing, as proof. A second piece arrived the next day, with a letter that threatened schoolchildren. The shirt pieces settled any doubt that the cab driver’s murder belonged to the same series as the attacks on the couples. The killer had now struck in four places, in three counties and one city, and he had killed five people and wounded two more, all in less than ten months. And then, after October 1969, the confirmed killings stopped.

Stine’s murder changed the case in another way. He was not a young couple parked on a dark road. He was a working man, killed in the city, in a neighbourhood where people watched from their windows. The Zodiac had come out of the countryside and into San Francisco, and he had done it in front of witnesses. Detectives Bill Armstrong and Dave Toschi were assigned to the San Francisco investigation, and Toschi, in particular, would become the public face of the hunt. The search would go on for decades, and it would eventually take in an estimated 2,500 suspects. None of them was ever charged.

The Ciphers

The Zodiac sent four ciphers in total, and they have become the most durable part of the case. The first, the 408-character cipher split across the three newspapers in July 1969, was solved by the Hardens within about a week, and its solution contained no name. The second, a 340-character cipher mailed to the Chronicle on November 8, 1969, resisted every attempt to solve it for fifty-one years. It was finally decoded on December 5, 2020, by a team of three private researchers: David Oranchak, a software developer from Virginia; Sam Blake, a mathematician from Australia; and Jarl Van Eycke, a programmer from Belgium. They had treated the cipher as a transposition puzzle, testing hundreds of thousands of possible reading patterns by computer. The FBI confirmed the solution the same month.

The message in the 340 cipher contained no name and no new fact about the crimes. It was more taunting, more of the same voice that had filled the letters, and it included a denial that the writer was the man who had telephoned a live television talk show in October 1969 claiming to be the Zodiac. That was all. Fifty-one years of work by professionals and amateurs, including cryptographers at the National Security Agency and the Navy, had ended in a paragraph that told the police nothing they did not already know. The disappointment was the point, in a way. The ciphers were never a map to the killer. They were a performance, like the letters, and the performance was the whole of it.

The last two ciphers have never been solved. One is thirteen characters long, mailed on April 20, 1970, and introduced by the writer as the place where he had put his name. The other is thirty-two characters long, mailed on June 26, 1970, alongside a map of the Bay Area with a crossed-circle drawn on the peak of Mount Diablo and instructions that supposedly led to a bomb. The bomb was never found. Both ciphers are so short that experts have said any proposed solution may be impossible to prove, because too many different readings can fit so few characters. They remain unsolved, and they probably will stay that way.

The ciphers are not the heart of the case. The heart of the case is five dead people and two survivors, and the ciphers did nothing for any of them. They did not save a life, and they did not name a killer. What they did was give the world a puzzle to solve, and the world solved it, twice, and found nothing inside.

The Long Correspondence

The killings stopped in October 1969, but the letters did not. For the next five years, the Zodiac wrote on, and the letters from 1970 show a man whose threats were growing larger even as his crimes had stopped. In April 1970 he sent a thirteen-character cipher and a diagram of a bomb he said was designed to kill children on a school bus. Later that month he sent a greeting card demanding that the people of the Bay Area wear buttons bearing his crossed-circle symbol. In June he sent the map of Mount Diablo and the thirty-two-character cipher, claiming the code would lead to a bomb buried somewhere in the hills. No bomb was ever found, and no school bus was ever attacked.

In July 1970, the writer claimed credit for an abduction that had happened four months earlier. On March 22, 1970, Kathleen Johns, twenty-two years old and seven months pregnant, had been driving on Highway 132 near Modesto with her ten-month-old daughter when a man flagged her down, told her a wheel on her car was loose, and then loosened the wheel himself so that it came off as she drove away. He offered her a ride to a gas station, and she got into his car with her baby. He drove past station after station without stopping, for hours, and Johns eventually grabbed her daughter and jumped from the moving car. She reached a police station and identified the man from a police sketch of the Zodiac. In his July 24 letter, the writer described a ride with a woman and her baby, and claimed it as his own. Whether Johns was truly a Zodiac victim has been argued ever since. Her own accounts of the night changed in details over the years, and the police report and her later retellings do not match in every particular. What is not in dispute is that she survived, and that her escape is the only time anyone is known to have got away from the man after being taken by him, if it was him at all.

The last confirmed letter arrived in January 1974. In it, the writer claimed a total of thirty-seven victims, a number the police have never been able to support. Five people were confirmed killed. Two survived. The rest of the thirty-seven, if they existed at all, have never been found, and no crime scene has ever been linked to the claim. The number was almost certainly a boast, the final flourish of a correspondence that had always been as much about the writer’s image as about his crimes. After 1974, the letters stopped. No new attack was ever confirmed.

The silence is part of what makes the case so hard to let go of. Most killers who stop are caught, or die, or are identified by some other means. The Zodiac simply disappeared from the record, leaving behind a stack of letters, four ciphers, two sketches, and a handful of descriptions that do not quite agree with each other. The FBI has noted that not every letter attributed to the Zodiac was definitely established as authentic, and over the years the police received thousands of hoax letters from people pretending to be him. The authenticated letters, the ones the police are confident came from the killer, number in the dozens, and they end in 1974.

The Suspects

The search for the Zodiac produced one of the largest suspect lists in American criminal history. The San Francisco Police Department alone eventually investigated an estimated 2,500 suspects over the years, and other agencies added more. The list included men who lived near the crime scenes, men whose handwriting resembled the letters, and men who had been reported by neighbours, ex-wives, and co-workers. Every one of them was checked, and every one of them was cleared, or died, or faded from the investigation without ever being charged.

Only one man was ever publicly named as a suspect by the authorities. Arthur Leigh Allen was a former elementary school teacher from Vallejo who lived near several of the crime scenes. He had been interviewed by police from the early days of the investigation, and he was the subject of several search warrants over a period of twenty years. The case against him, as it was assembled by the writer Robert Graysmith in his 1986 book, was circumstantial: Allen owned a watch of the brand Zodiac, he lived close to the victims, and he had a history of troubling behaviour with children that had put him in prison in the 1970s. In 1991, Michael Mageau, the survivor of the Blue Rock Springs attack, picked Allen out of a photographic lineup, though he acknowledged he had seen his attacker only briefly, in the dark.

The evidence against Allen, examined closely, fell apart. His handwriting did not match the letters, according to the examiners who studied it. His fingerprints did not match the prints found on the letters. In 2002, the San Francisco police developed a partial DNA profile from saliva on the stamps and envelopes of the Zodiac’s letters, and compared it with Allen’s DNA. It did not match. A similar comparison with Don Cheney, the former friend who had first suggested Allen to the police, also came back negative. In 2010, Dave Toschi, the detective who had worked the case from the beginning, said that all the evidence against Allen had ultimately turned out to be negative. Allen died in 1992, without ever being charged with any of the Zodiac murders.

Other names have been put forward since. In 2021, a private group of investigators calling themselves the Case Breakers announced that they had identified the killer as Gary Francis Poste, a man who had died in 2018, and linked him to the murder of Cheri Jo Bates in Riverside as well. Law enforcement did not confirm the claim. The San Francisco police said the case was not solved. The Riverside police said the Bates case was still unsolved. A private group can name a man. Only evidence can convict one, and the evidence in this case has never pointed at anyone with enough force to survive a courtroom.

The Cases That May Not Belong

The Zodiac’s own claims made the case bigger than it was, and other people’s theories made it bigger still. Over the years, a long list of other murders has been proposed as the work of the same man, and almost none of them has survived examination. Two of them have stayed in the argument longer than the rest, and they deserve to be described honestly, because they show how a famous case can pull other cases into its orbit.

The strongest of the disputed cases is the murder of Cheri Jo Bates, an eighteen-year-old student at Riverside City College, killed on the night of October 30, 1966, more than two years before the first confirmed Zodiac attack. Bates had gone to the college library that evening, and when she came out, someone had disabled her car by tampering with its distributor wiring, a trick designed to draw her out into the dark. She was attacked in the grounds of the college and killed. A month later, a typed letter claiming responsibility arrived in Riverside, describing details of the crime that the writer said only the killer could know. In April 1967, three short handwritten notes were sent to Bates’s father, the local newspaper, and the Riverside police.

The connection to the Zodiac was not proposed until 1970, when a reporter at the Chronicle received a tip about the similarities between the Bates case and the Bay Area killings. In March 1971, a letter to the Los Angeles Times, attributed to the Zodiac, referred to Riverside activity and said the police were only finding the easy ones. That letter is the strongest thread tying Bates to the Zodiac, and it is a thin one. The Riverside Police Department has consistently said it does not consider the Bates murder a Zodiac crime. Its detectives have said they believe the killer was someone Bates knew, not a stranger from the Bay Area. The handwriting examiner who studied the Riverside letters linked some of them to the Zodiac, but other examiners have disagreed, and the question has never been settled to the satisfaction of the police who own the case. Bates was a real victim of a real murder, and her case is unsolved in its own right. Whether she belongs in the Zodiac file is a separate question, and the honest answer is that nobody knows.

The second disputed case is the disappearance of Donna Lass, a twenty-five-year-old nurse who was last seen on September 6, 1970, in Stateline, Nevada, on the California border. Six months later, a postcard arrived at the Chronicle that some researchers have interpreted as the Zodiac claiming Lass as a victim. There is no physical evidence connecting her disappearance to the Zodiac, no witness, no letter that names her, and no body has ever been found. The postcard is ambiguous, the interpretation is contested, and the case remains what it was before the Zodiac was attached to it: a young woman who vanished, and a family that never got an answer.

These disputed cases matter because they show how the Zodiac case works on the people who study it. A famous unsolved case attracts other unsolved cases. Each new link makes the killer seem larger and more terrible, and each new link makes the real case harder to see. The confirmed record is seven people attacked, five killed, two survived, in four attacks over ten months. Everything beyond that is argument, and the argument has been going on for more than fifty years without producing a single confirmed victim more.

Why the Case Stays Open

The Zodiac case has never been closed. The San Francisco Police Department marked it inactive in April 2004, a bureaucratic step that meant no detective was assigned to it full time, but it was reopened before March 2007, and it remains open in San Francisco, in Vallejo, in Napa County, and in Solano County. The California Department of Justice has maintained an open case file on the murders since 1969. Murder has no statute of limitations in California, so the file can stay open for as long as it takes.

The hope, for many years now, has been DNA. In 2002, the partial profile developed from the stamps and envelopes was the first real forensic lead the case had ever produced, and it excluded Allen and Cheney without identifying anyone else. In May 2018, after the arrest of the Golden State Killer through genetic genealogy, the Vallejo Police Department announced that it would try to collect DNA from the backs of the stamps the Zodiac had used, in the hope of identifying him through the same process. No results have ever been reported. The difficulty is that the DNA on a stamp may not be the killer’s at all. In 2018, it was reported that the 2002 sample had been collected from the outside of a stamp rather than from behind it, which means it could have come from anyone who handled the envelope. A partial profile is not a name, and a name is what the case needs.

The case stays open because the alternative is unthinkable to the people who work it. Five people were killed, and two more carry the memory of the nights they survived. The detectives who worked the case in the 1960s are mostly gone now, and the case has passed to people who were not born when the letters arrived. That is the real measure of how long this has gone on: the investigation has outlived the investigators. It will go on as long as there is a file to keep open and a technique left to try.

From the record

This is the Zodiac speaking.

The opening line of the letter sent to the San Francisco Examiner on August 4, 1969 — the words that gave the killer the name he chose. The letters and ciphers, as published by the San Francisco Chronicle, the San Francisco Examiner and the Vallejo Times-Herald in 1969–1974, are the primary record of this case. The FBI has released its case file — eleven parts of reports, letters and laboratory material — in the FBI Vault.

What Is Documented, and What Is Not

  • Seven people were attacked in four confirmed incidents between December 20, 1968 and October 11, 1969, in Benicia, Vallejo, Lake Berryessa, and San Francisco; five were killed and two survived, and no one has ever been charged with any of the attacks.
  • The writer who called himself the Zodiac sent letters and cards to Bay Area newspapers from July 1969 to January 1974, claiming responsibility for the attacks, enclosing four ciphers, and claiming thirty-seven victims, a figure the police have never been able to support.
  • The 408-character cipher was solved in August 1969 by Donald and Bettye Harden, and the 340-character cipher was solved on December 5, 2020 by David Oranchak, Sam Blake, and Jarl Van Eycke, with the solution confirmed by the FBI; neither message contained a name or any new fact about the crimes.
  • The murder of Cheri Jo Bates in Riverside in October 1966 is claimed by some researchers as an early Zodiac crime, on the strength of a confession letter and later correspondence, but the Riverside Police Department does not consider it a Zodiac case and believes the killer was someone Bates knew.
  • Kathleen Johns identified the man who abducted her on March 22, 1970 as the Zodiac, and the writer claimed the abduction in a letter four months later, but her accounts of the night changed in details over the years and researchers continue to disagree about whether the case belongs in the Zodiac file.
  • The partial DNA profile developed from the Zodiac’s letters in 2002 excluded Arthur Leigh Allen and Don Cheney, but it was later reported that the sample may have come from the outside of a stamp rather than from behind it, so it cannot be stated with certainty that the DNA belongs to the letter writer.
  • Claims that the thirteen-character and thirty-two-character ciphers contain the killer’s name and the location of a buried bomb have never been proved, and experts have said the ciphers are too short for any proposed solution to be verified.
  • Claims that the Zodiac killed thirty-seven people rest entirely on the writer’s own letters, and no additional victim has ever been confirmed or linked to the case by physical evidence.
  • Claims that Gary Francis Poste was the Zodiac, announced by a private investigative group in 2021, have not been confirmed by any law enforcement agency, and the San Francisco and Riverside police departments have both said their cases remain unsolved.

How we checked this: every claim above is measured against the record this article draws on — the police accounts of the four attacks, the letters and ciphers as published by the Bay Area newspapers, and the FBI’s confirmation of the 340 cipher’s solution in December 2020. Where the record is silent, the article says so.

If a killer can write to the newspapers for five years, leave behind ciphers, sketches, descriptions, and thousands of pages of evidence, and still walk away without a name, what does that say about the limits of even the most famous investigation in American history?

Sources

  • The letters and ciphers as published by the San Francisco Chronicle, the San Francisco Examiner and the Vallejo Times-Herald, 1969–1974.
  • The FBI Vault — The Zodiac Killer: eleven parts of reports, letters and laboratory material.
  • San Francisco Police Department and California Department of Justice case files, open since 1969.
  • The FBI’s confirmation of the December 2020 solution of the 340 cipher.

Frequently asked questions

Was anyone ever convicted?

No. No one has ever been charged with the Zodiac crimes. Arthur Leigh Allen was publicly named as a suspect in 1971 and died in 1992 without ever being charged; the handwriting, fingerprints and a partial DNA profile all failed to match him.

Is the case still open?

Yes. The San Francisco Police Department marked the case inactive in April 2004 and reopened it before March 2007. It remains open in San Francisco, Vallejo, Napa County and Solano County, and murder has no statute of limitations in California.

Where can I read the primary sources?

The letters and ciphers as published by the San Francisco Chronicle, the San Francisco Examiner and the Vallejo Times-Herald in 1969–1974, and the FBI Vault file — eleven parts of reports, letters and laboratory material.

Further reading

  • Robert Graysmith, Zodiac (1986) — the San Francisco Chronicle cartoonist’s account; the book that assembled the case against Arthur Leigh Allen.
  • Robert Graysmith, Zodiac Unmasked (2002) — Graysmith’s follow-up names his suspect; the evidence against him did not match, and he was never charged.

More case files

One case file a week, in your inbox. The Weekly Briefing is free — join it from the homepage.

Leave a Comment