In the spring of 1992, over just 29 days, an unidentified gunman murdered six people working alone in small specialty shops across the American Midwest. The victims were shot in the back of the head at quiet times of day, and only small amounts of cash were taken. The shops were all near Interstate 70 or a connecting highway — hence the name. Despite composite sketches, a multi-state task force and a distinctive murder weapon, no one has ever been arrested.
April 8: Indianapolis
The spree began on April 8, 1992, in Indianapolis, Indiana. Robin Fuldauer, 26, manager of a Payless ShoeSource on Pendleton Pike, was working alone when she was shot about 1:30 p.m. Her body was found in a back storage room at around 3 p.m. Less than $100 had been taken.
April 11: Wichita
Three days later, on April 11, the killer struck 675 miles away in Wichita. Patricia Smith, 23, and the shop’s owner, Patricia Magers, 32, were at La Bride d’Elegance, a bridal shop on East Kellogg Drive. They had stayed past the 6 p.m. closing time so a male customer could collect a cummerbund, and let the gunman in, apparently believing he was that customer. Both women were taken to a back room and killed — the only one of the five scenes with two victims, and investigators believe the killer thought only one woman was inside.
The expected customer then arrived, came face to face with the armed killer, and was told to come to the back of the shop. He refused and was told to leave; so frightened, he did not report it for more than an hour. He later helped police draw a composite sketch of a slender white man with reddish hair carrying what looked like an Uzi-style gun.
April 27: Terre Haute
On April 27, the killer returned to Indiana. Michael McCown, 40, was working in his mother Sylvia’s ceramics shop in Terre Haute when he was shot at about 4 p.m. His wallet was taken, along with less than $50. McCown was the only male victim, and investigators believe the killer chose the shop because its name — Sylvia’s Ceramics — suggested a woman worked there, and mistook McCown for a woman: he wore his hair in a ponytail and was shot from behind while kneeling to stock shelves. No witnesses saw the killer beforehand.
May 3: St. Charles
On May 3, in St. Charles, Missouri, Nancy Kitzmiller, 24, was working alone at Boot Village, a footwear shop. She had opened the shop at noon, although she was supposed to be off that day. Customers found her dead at 2:30 p.m., shot in the back of the head. Some money was taken. No one heard the shot, but a witness who had seen Kitzmiller with a customer minutes before her death helped police produce a second composite drawing.
May 7: Raytown
The final confirmed murder came on May 7 in Raytown, Missouri. Sarah Blessing, 37, was working in her gift shop, the Store of Many Colors, at the Woodson Village Shopping Center. The owner of a video store next door saw a man enter, heard a pop, and saw him leave, then found Blessing’s body. A clerk at a nearby grocery store also saw the killer, climbing a hill toward Interstate 70. Then, as suddenly as it had begun, the killing stopped.
The gun, the sketches and the pattern
The murders were conclusively linked after a St. Charles detective suspected a connection. All six victims were killed with a .22-caliber firearm and shot in the back of the head. There were no signs of sexual assault. Robbery appeared secondary: every shop was a small specialty business holding little cash. The attacks came at slow times — after lunch or near closing — when stores were deserted, and several were in strip malls near Interstate 70, allowing a quick escape.
Ballistics confirmed that bullets from four of the six scenes were fired from the same weapon. Police believe it was an Erma Werke Model ET22 pistol or an Intratec Scorpion pistol, though other .22-caliber models have not been definitively ruled out. The ammunition was .22-caliber CCI copper-clad lead bullets, and the casings showed traces of jeweller’s rouge. Witnesses described a thin white man in his twenties or thirties, 5 feet 7 to 5 feet 9 inches, with lazy eyelids and sandy blond or reddish hair. Two composite sketches were produced.
Two men were investigated and eliminated as suspects — Donald Waterhouse of Tennessee and Sean Patrick Goble of North Carolina — over differences in height, age, hairstyle, method and description. Investigators have never publicly named a suspect.
Suspected later killings — unconfirmed
Investigators believe the killer may also have been responsible for two murders in Texas in 1993 and an attempted murder in 1994, all of store clerks: Mary Ann Glasscock, 51, killed on September 25, 1993, at a Fort Worth antiques store; Amy Vess, 22, killed on November 1, 1993, at an Arlington dance apparel store; and Vicki Webb, 35, shot on January 15, 1994, at a Houston gift shop, who survived after the bullet struck a vertebra and the gun misfired. The Texas crimes shared the method and calibre, but ballistics showed the gun used in Texas was not the 1992 weapon, so the link cannot be confirmed.
Terre Haute police also named the I-70 killer as a suspect in the 2001 murder of liquor store clerk Billy Brossman, seven blocks from where McCown died. Security footage exists, and police say they have a person of interest; the connection is unconfirmed.
In 2021, police from the five cities formed a renewed task force to re-examine the case with modern forensic techniques, and St. Charles police released age-progressed versions of the original sketch. Investigators believe the killer would be between 52 and 70 if still alive; a $25,000 reward remains on offer.
What the record shows
What is documented is this: six people — Robin Fuldauer, Patricia Magers, Patricia Smith, Michael McCown, Nancy Kitzmiller and Sarah Blessing — were murdered in five small shops in Indiana, Kansas and Missouri between April 8 and May 7, 1992. All were shot in the back of the head with a .22-caliber firearm; ballistics linked at least four scenes to a single gun. Small amounts of cash were taken from each shop. Witnesses produced two composite sketches of a thin white man in his twenties or thirties with reddish or sandy blond hair. No suspect has ever been publicly named, and no arrest has been made.
Disputed or unconfirmed: whether the Texas shootings of 1993–94 and the 2001 Terre Haute murder were committed by the same person — the Texas gun was shown not to be the 1992 weapon, and the 2001 link rests on similarity of method; and the exact make of the murder weapon, believed to be an Erma Werke ET22 or Intratec Scorpion but never definitively established. The I-70 killer is unrelated to the “I-70 Strangler,” a separate series along the same highway. More than thirty years on, the six murders remain open in five police departments.