In the spring of 1895, Oscar Wilde was the most celebrated playwright in London. The Importance of Being Earnest had opened to acclaim in February, and An Ideal Husband was running at the Haymarket. Within three months, Wilde was convicted of gross indecency, sentenced to two years’ hard labour, and ruined. The trials that destroyed him were, in their way, as much a product of Victorian England as his plays were.
The card at the Albemarle Club
The trouble began with John Sholto Douglas, the 9th Marquess of Queensberry, the father of Lord Alfred Douglas — “Bosie” — Wilde’s young lover. Queensberry, a former amateur boxing champion and a man of violent temper, objected furiously to the relationship. In February 1895, he left a calling card at Wilde’s club, the Albemarle, bearing the words “To Oscar Wilde, posing as a sodomite” — Queensberry had intended to write “posing as a sodomite” but the handwriting was ambiguous.
Against the advice of his friends, Wilde sued Queensberry for criminal libel. The trial opened at the Old Bailey on 3 April 1895. Queensberry’s defence was justification: the charge, he argued, was true and made in the public interest. His lawyers, led by Edward Carson, produced evidence of Wilde’s relationships with young men, including letters Wilde had written to Lord Alfred Douglas and testimony from rent boys and blackmailers. Wilde, cross-examined by Carson, gave brilliant, evasive answers — but when Carson pressed him on a letter to Douglas describing “your slim gilt soul”, Wilde’s wit began to fail him.
On the third day, Wilde’s counsel withdrew the prosecution. Queensberry was acquitted, and under the law of the time, Wilde was liable for Queensberry’s legal costs. Worse, the evidence aired in the libel trial was passed to the Director of Public Prosecutions.
Two criminal trials
Wilde was arrested on 5 April 1895 and charged with gross indecency under the Criminal Law Amendment Act of 1885 — the Labouchere Amendment, which made sexual acts between men a crime punishable by up to two years’ imprisonment with hard labour. He was refused bail and held in Holloway Prison.
The first criminal trial, in April and May 1895, ended with a hung jury. The second, before Justice Wills, began on 20 May. The prosecution called young men who testified to sexual encounters with Wilde in hotel rooms and rented lodgings. Wilde’s defence argued that the witnesses were blackmailers and liars, and that the evidence was tainted. On 25 May 1895, the jury found Wilde guilty on all counts except one. Justice Wills sentenced him to two years’ hard labour — the maximum — calling the sentence “totally inadequate for such a case”.
Prison and after
Wilde served his sentence first at Pentonville and Wandsworth, then at Reading Gaol. The hard labour, the poor food and the solitary confinement broke his health. In prison he wrote De Profundis, a long letter to Lord Alfred Douglas, and after his release in May 1897 he wrote The Ballad of Reading Gaol, about the execution of a fellow prisoner. He left England for France, living under the name Sebastian Melmoth, and died in Paris on 30 November 1900, aged 46, of cerebral meningitis following an ear infection.
The law under which Wilde was convicted remained on the books for decades. Homosexual acts between consenting adult men were partially decriminalised in England and Wales in 1967, and fully in 2003. In 2017, the “Alan Turing law” — part of the Policing and Crime Act — granted posthumous pardons to men convicted of historical offences of gross indecency, including Wilde.
The trials destroyed Wilde in every way that mattered. He was declared bankrupt, and his wife Constance — who had stood by him through the libel case — took their two sons to Switzerland and changed the family name to Holland. His plays were withdrawn from London theatres, his books were removed from sale, and the publisher of his works cancelled his contracts. When he was released from Reading Gaol in May 1897, he was a broken man, his health ruined by the prison regime. He lived the remaining three years of his life in exile in France, dependent on the charity of friends, and died owing money to almost everyone who had helped him.
His reputation recovered slowly. By the mid-twentieth century, Wilde was recognised again as one of the great writers of the Victorian age, and his plays returned to the West End, where they have rarely been out of production since. The trials themselves became a symbol of the cruelty of the laws against homosexuality — and of the price paid by a man who, as he put it in De Profundis, had chosen to live his life as a work of art.
What the record shows
- In February 1895, the Marquess of Queensberry left a card at Wilde’s club accusing him of “posing as a sodomite”. Wilde sued for libel; the trial opened at the Old Bailey on 3 April 1895.
- Queensberry’s defence was justification. His counsel, Edward Carson, presented letters to Lord Alfred Douglas and testimony from young men. Wilde withdrew the prosecution on the third day; Queensberry was acquitted.
- Wilde was arrested on 5 April 1895 and charged with gross indecency under the Criminal Law Amendment Act 1885. The first trial ended in a hung jury; at the second trial, on 25 May 1895, he was convicted and sentenced to two years’ hard labour, the maximum.
- He served his sentence at Pentonville, Wandsworth and Reading Gaol, and was released in May 1897. He died in Paris on 30 November 1900, aged 46.
- In 2017, the Policing and Crime Act granted posthumous pardons to men convicted of historical gross indecency offences, including Wilde.
- Disputed/unverified: The exact wording of Queensberry’s card is uncertain — his handwriting was ambiguous, and accounts differ. The credibility of several prosecution witnesses, some of whom had attempted to blackmail Wilde, was contested at the time and remains debated.
- Unresolved: The full extent of the prosecution’s motives — whether the case was pursued as a matter of law or as a public example — is a matter of historical argument.