Jack the Ripper, 1888: Five Women, One Autumn, and No Answer
In the autumn of 1888, the East End of London was one of the poorest districts in the capital. Whitechapel and Spitalfields packed tens of thousands of people into narrow streets and crowded lodging houses. Work was casual and uncertain. For many women, a bed for the night in a common lodging house cost a few pence, and finding those pence was the day’s work. It was in that world, over ten weeks, that five women were killed — and a name that no police officer invented, and no killer ever proved he used, entered the language: Jack the Ripper.
The canonical five
The Metropolitan Police investigated eleven killings in Whitechapel between April 1888 and February 1891. Of those, five are known as the “canonical five” — the deaths most often linked to a single killer, a grouping fixed largely by a police memorandum written in 1894 by Sir Melville Macnaghten, then Chief Constable of the Criminal Investigation Department, which said the murderer had “5 victims — & 5 victims only.”
The five were Mary Ann Nichols, known as Polly, 43; Annie Chapman, 47; Elizabeth Stride, 44; Catherine Eddowes, 46; and Mary Jane Kelly, about 25. Nichols was found in the early hours of 31 August 1888 in Buck’s Row, now Durward Street. Chapman was found on 8 September in the yard behind 29 Hanbury Street, Spitalfields. Stride and Eddowes were both found in the early hours of 30 September — Stride in Dutfield’s Yard off Berner Street, Eddowes in Mitre Square — in what the press called the “double event.” Kelly, the youngest of the five, was found on 9 November in her room at 13 Miller’s Court. She was the only one of the five killed indoors.
The attacks shared a pattern that the police noted at the time: they happened at night or in the early morning, in public or semi-public places, and the victims’ throats had been cut. In several cases there were further injuries after death, and in at least three cases organs had been removed. The police and the doctors who examined the bodies debated what that meant — whether the killer had anatomical or surgical knowledge, or experience as a butcher. No conclusion was ever proved.
The women, not only the killer
For more than a century, the five women were described in police files and in almost everything written since as prostitutes. Recent historical research has challenged that description. The historian Hallie Rubenhold, in her 2019 book The Five, examined the lives of the five women in detail and found that only Mary Jane Kelly was earning her living through sex work at the time of her death. As Smithsonian magazine summarised her findings, there is no evidence tying Mary Ann Nichols, Annie Chapman or Catherine Eddowes to prostitution at all.
What the five did have in common was poverty. Most of them were homeless or sleeping rough. All five drank. Nichols, born Mary Ann Walker in 1845, had married at 18 and had five children; by 1888 she was separated from her husband and living in lodging houses. Chapman, born Eliza Ann Smith in 1841, had a similar history of marriage, separation and drink. Stride, born Elisabeth Gustafsdotter in Sweden in 1843, had emigrated to London and worked as a domestic servant and seamstress. Eddowes, born in 1842, had lived with two common-law husbands and worked as a casual labourer. Kelly, born in Ireland around 1863, was the youngest and the least documented; she had lived in Wales and in London, and by 1888 she was living in Miller’s Court with a partner.
That context matters, because it explains both why the women were vulnerable and why the investigation struggled. They moved between lodging houses, they had few fixed addresses, and the people who knew them best were often as poor and as transient as they were. Witnesses were hard to find and harder to keep.
The investigation
The investigation was, by the standards of 1888, large. Scotland Yard sent more than 2,000 officers into Whitechapel at various points. Detectives carried out door-to-door searches, tried bloodhounds, and used early crime-scene photography. Dr Thomas Bond, a police surgeon, produced post-mortem notes that amounted to one of the first attempts at offender profiling, suggesting a solitary man, possibly with medical or butchery experience.
The limits of the era mattered. There were no fingerprint databases — fingerprinting as a police tool was still years away. DNA testing was unknown. The Metropolitan Police and the City of London Police, whose boundary ran through the murder area, sometimes worked at cross purposes. And the press, which reported every development in detail, also generated hundreds of letters from members of the public claiming to be the killer, each of which had to be checked.
Suspects were questioned, and some were detained. Aaron Kosminski, a Polish-born barber who suffered from mental illness, was mentioned by police at the time. A DNA claim made in 2014, based on tests on a shawl said to have been found at the scene of Eddowes’s murder, has not been accepted as proof: the shawl has no proven link to the crime. No one was ever charged with any of the five canonical murders.
Why it remains unsolved
There are two honest answers to that question. The first is evidence. The police of 1888 had no forensic tools that could identify a person from a scene, and the scenes themselves — dark streets, yards and courts — were contaminated by crowds, by the press and by the simple fact that bodies were often moved before a doctor arrived. The second is time. By the time modern forensic science existed, the physical evidence was long gone, and the witnesses were dead.
Over a hundred theories about the killer’s identity have been proposed. They have named doctors, artists, members of the royal family and policemen. None has been proved. The case is, in the judgement of most historians, unlikely ever to be solved.
What the record shows
Five women — Mary Ann Nichols, Annie Chapman, Elizabeth Stride, Catherine Eddowes and Mary Jane Kelly — were killed in Whitechapel between 31 August and 9 November 1888. Eleven killings in all were recorded in the police file between April 1888 and February 1891, but how many belong to one killer is disputed. The name “Jack the Ripper” came from a letter that was probably a hoax. No one was ever charged, and the killer was never identified.
What the record does show, clearly, is who the victims were: five women living in poverty in Victorian London, whose lives have only recently been studied on their own terms, rather than as footnotes to a killer’s legend.
Sources
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jack_the_Ripper?oldid=626137285
- https://serialkillercalendar.com/JACK%20THE%20RIPPER.php
- https://dyerbolical.com/jack-the-ripper-the-unidentified-killer-who-terrorised-victorian-london/
- https://gotchacrimes.substack.com/p/jack-the-ripper-and-the-whitechapel?r=6dm1p3&triedRedirect=true
1 thought on “Jack the Ripper, 1888: Five Women, One Autumn, and No Answer”