The Freeway Phantom: Six Girls Murdered in Washington, D.C., 1971–72

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

Between April 25, 1971, and September 5, 1972, six Black girls and young women disappeared from Washington, D.C., and were found murdered near the freeways of the capital and Prince George’s County, Maryland. They were aged 10 to 18, each had been strangled, and nearly all were found without their shoes. The Metropolitan Police Department still lists the case as open, with a $150,000 reward outstanding. No one has ever been charged.

The victims were children and teenagers from working-class Black families in Southeast and Northeast Washington, whose families have long said the investigation did not receive the urgency it deserved.

The six victims

Carol Denise Spinks, 13, was the first. On the evening of April 25, 1971, her older sister sent her to buy groceries at a 7-Eleven about half a mile from home in Southeast Washington. She was abducted on her way back, and her body was found six days later on an embankment beside Interstate 295, behind St. Elizabeths Hospital. She had been strangled and was missing her shoes.

Darlenia Denise Johnson, 16, of Congress Heights, was abducted on July 8, 1971, on her way to a summer job at the Oxon Hill Recreation Center. A witness reported seeing her in an old black car shortly afterwards. Her body was found eleven days later, only about 15 feet from where Spinks had been found — an anonymous caller with details only the killer could have known had told police the location nearly a week earlier. By then the body was too decomposed to determine a cause of death, though strangulation was evident.

Brenda Faye Crockett, 10, vanished on July 27, 1971, after her mother sent her to the store. About two hours later the family telephone rang; her seven-year-old sister answered. Crockett was on the line, crying, saying a white man had picked her up and she was heading home in a cab, and that she believed she was in Virginia. A short time later she called again, speaking to her stepfather, repeating the story and saying she was alone in a house with a white man. Heavy footsteps were heard before she hung up. Investigators concluded the calls were made at the killer’s direction, with false information to buy time and mislead the search. At 5:50 the next morning, a hitchhiker found her body beside U.S. Route 50 near the Baltimore–Washington Parkway in Prince George’s County. She had been strangled, a scarf knotted around her neck.

Nenomoshia Yates, 12, was walking home from a Safeway store in Northeast Washington on October 1, 1971, when she was abducted. Her body was found within three hours, just off Pennsylvania Avenue in Prince George’s County. Like the others, she was missing her shoes, and unidentified green fibres were found on her clothing. A witness reported seeing her get into a blue Volkswagen; the lead went nowhere. The name “Freeway Phantom” first appeared in a Daily News article after this murder.

Brenda Denise Woodard, 18, had dinner with a high school classmate on November 15, 1971, and boarded a city bus at about 11:30 p.m. to return home. About six hours later a police officer found her body in a grassy area near Prince George’s County Hospital, along an access ramp to Route 202 from the Baltimore–Washington Parkway. Unlike the other victims, she was still wearing her shoes, and a coat had been placed over her chest. In a pocket was a note, written on paper cut from her own school notebook:

“This is tantamount to my insensitivity to people especially women. I will admit the others when you catch me if you can! Free-way Phantom”

Authorities believed, from handwriting samples, that the note had been dictated by the killer and handwritten by Woodard herself — the only direct communication from the killer in the series.

Diane Denise Williams, 17, a senior at Ballou High School, was the last victim. On September 5, 1972, she cooked dinner for her family, visited her boyfriend, and was last seen boarding a bus at 11:20 p.m. A few hours later her strangled body was found beside Interstate 295, just south of the District line, near where Carol Spinks had been found. Her shoes were missing. After her murder, the killings stopped.

The investigation — and the lost files

The investigation brought together the Metropolitan Police Department, Maryland county police, the Maryland State Police and the FBI, with a public hotline taking tips. But the case files were a casualty of the era: files were kept by individual detectives, and many were later discarded or lost. All the original investigators have long since retired or died. A possible DNA sample from Diane Williams’s clothing was sent to the FBI in 2009; no one has ever been charged.

In 2010 the Cold Case Homicide Unit re-examined the case; it remains open.

The suspects who were never charged

Several lines of inquiry were pursued and none produced a prosecution. Members of a gang known as the Green Vega Rapists, convicted of abductions and rapes near the Capital Beltway, were interviewed at Lorton Prison. One inmate implicated another, giving details of a killing — including a signature detail not released to the public — that checked out. The informant withdrew his cooperation after a Maryland political candidate publicly announced a break in the case, and the lead died.

Another major suspect was Robert Elwood Askins, a National Science Foundation computer technician with a history of violence against women reaching back to 1938, when he poisoned and stabbed two women in Washington and was found criminally insane. After a 1977 rape charge, his home was searched. Investigators found court documents in a desk drawer in which a judge had used the word “tantamount” — the unusual word in the Woodard note — and colleagues said the word cropped up frequently in Askins’s speech. His backyard was dug up. No physical evidence was obtained, and he was never charged. Askins died in federal prison in 2010 at 91.

What the record shows

What is documented is this: six girls and young women — Carol Denise Spinks, Darlenia Denise Johnson, Brenda Faye Crockett, Nenomoshia Yates, Brenda Denise Woodard and Diane Denise Williams, aged 10 to 18 — were abducted in Washington, D.C., between April 1971 and September 1972 and found murdered near freeways in the District and Prince George’s County, Maryland. All were strangled; nearly all were found without their shoes. A note dictated by the killer was found with Brenda Woodard. The case remains open, with a $150,000 reward outstanding.

Disputed or unproven: the identity of the killer, including the theories surrounding the Green Vega Rapists and Robert Askins, neither of which produced evidence sufficient for a charge; the meaning of the Woodard note, including whether Woodard knew her kidnapper, as investigators speculated from the handwriting; and some details in secondary accounts, which variously spell Carol Spinks’s surname as “Spencer” and give slightly different ages and dates. The official record, maintained by the Metropolitan Police Department, names six victims over the span from April 25, 1971, to September 5, 1972. The families of those six girls are still waiting for an answer.

Sources

Leave a Comment