Stephanie St. Clair: Harlem’s Numbers Queen

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

Stephanie St. Clair was the only woman to run a large-scale numbers bank in Harlem, and she did it in an age when the rackets were run by men who did not expect to be defied by anyone — least of all by a Black woman from the Caribbean. She built her business from a ten-thousand-dollar investment into an organisation that employed dozens of people, and when Dutch Schultz, the most violent gangster in New York, moved to take Harlem’s numbers trade for himself, she refused to surrender. She fought him in the streets and in the newspapers, and she outlived him.

St. Clair was born on 24 December 1897 in the French Caribbean. Her own papers give her birthplace as Moule, on Grande-Terre in Guadeloupe, though many accounts say Martinique. According to her biographer Shirley Stewart, she travelled to the United States by steamer in 1911, aged thirteen, although some sources give the year as 1912. She settled in Harlem, and she arrived with two advantages her competitors lacked: she could read and write in both French and English, and she had no fear of the white establishment.

The Numbers Bank

The numbers game — known as policy — was a daily lottery in which players bet small sums on a three-digit number. Thousands of Harlem residents played it every day. St. Clair invested ten thousand dollars in developing a numbers bank of her own, and by the late 1920s she was one of the leading policy bankers in the neighbourhood. At her peak she employed twenty controllers and forty runners, and her business was reported to earn her as much as two hundred and fifty thousand dollars a year. She led her own organisation, the Forty Thieves, and her chief enforcer was a young man named Ellsworth “Bumpy” Johnson, who would later become the best-known Black racketeer in Harlem himself.

St. Clair was not a quiet operator. She was famous in Harlem for her sense of fashion, for the newspaper advertisements she took out to denounce her enemies, and for her refusal to pay protection to anyone. She was known as “Madame Queen,” “Madam St. Clair” and “Queenie,” and she cultivated the image deliberately: a woman who answered to no man.

War with Dutch Schultz

The threat to her empire came in the early 1930s, when Dutch Schultz — born Arthur Flegenheimer, a Bronx bootlegger of legendary temper — decided to take over Harlem’s numbers trade. Schultz’s men beat and killed numbers operators who would not pay him protection, and they put a price on St. Clair herself. She responded by organising the other Black bankers, fighting back in the streets, and taking out newspaper advertisements denouncing Schultz and the corrupt police who protected him. The conflict was bloody: dozens of people were killed in the war for Harlem’s numbers, and St. Clair was forced into hiding for a time. In the end she was outmatched — Schultz had the backing of the Five Families — and she handed her organisation over to her rivals. Her operation passed to Bumpy Johnson, under an arrangement with Lucky Luciano.

Schultz did not enjoy his victory for long. When he proposed assassinating the crusading District Attorney Thomas Dewey, Luciano and the other bosses of the Five Families refused to authorise it — and instead had Schultz killed. On 23 October 1935 two gunmen shot Schultz and three of his associates at the Palace Chop House in Newark, New Jersey. Schultz lingered for almost a day, delirious and dying, and St. Clair sent a telegram to his hospital bed: “As ye sow, so shall ye reap” — a verse from Galatians.

Prison and Later Life

St. Clair had already spent time in prison once: on 30 December 1929 she was arrested for possession of numbers slips, convicted, and sentenced to eight months and twenty days in the workhouse on Welfare Island, from which she was released on 9 December 1930. At her trial she testified openly about the protection payments she had been forced to make to the police. Her second prison term had nothing to do with the rackets. In about 1936 she married Sufi Abdul Hamid, a Harlem religious leader who claimed descent from Egyptian pharaohs and was described by some as a con man. On 19 January 1938, in an office building on 125th Street, St. Clair shot Hamid after accusing him of an affair with the fortune-teller Dorothy “Fu Futtam” Matthews. She claimed the gun had gone off during a struggle. An all-white jury convicted her of assault, and she was sentenced to two to ten years at Bedford Hills. She served about three years and was released in the early 1940s.

What happened to her afterwards is largely a mystery. She lived on in New York, still wealthy thanks to careful investments, and remained an activist for the Black community. She died in December 1969, aged seventy-one — the Mob Museum gives the place as Central Islip, New York, though some accounts say Harlem. Bumpy Johnson, her former enforcer and protégé, had died of a heart attack eighteen months earlier.

What Is Documented — and What Is Not

Documented: Stephanie St. Clair was born on 24 December 1897 in the French Caribbean; her own papers give Moule, Grande-Terre, Guadeloupe, as her birthplace. According to her biographer Shirley Stewart, she arrived in the United States by steamer in 1911, aged thirteen. She invested $10,000 in a numbers bank in Harlem and became one of the neighbourhood’s leading policy bankers, employing twenty controllers and forty runners by the late 1920s. Her chief enforcer was Ellsworth “Bumpy” Johnson. In the early 1930s she fought a war with Dutch Schultz for control of Harlem’s numbers trade and was eventually forced to hand her organisation over. Schultz was shot on 23 October 1935 at the Palace Chop House in Newark, New Jersey, and St. Clair sent a telegram to his hospital bed reading “As ye sow, so shall ye reap.” On 30 December 1929 she was arrested for possession of numbers slips and sentenced to eight months and twenty days in the workhouse; she was released on 9 December 1930. On 19 January 1938 she shot her husband, Sufi Abdul Hamid, in an office on 125th Street; she was convicted of assault and sentenced to two to ten years at Bedford Hills, serving about three years. She died in December 1969, aged 71.

Not documented / unverified: Sources disagree on St. Clair’s birthplace — Guadeloupe or Martinique — and on the year of her arrival in the United States, 1911 or 1912. The figure of $250,000 a year for her earnings is reported in secondary sources and has not been independently confirmed. The details of her life after her release from prison in the early 1940s are largely unknown, and accounts disagree on the place of her death — Central Islip, New York, or Harlem. Much of her early biography comes from a biographical novel by Raphaël Confiant, Madame St-Clair, Reine de Harlem, and should not be treated as documented fact.

Sources

https://themobmuseum.org/notable_names/stephanie-st-clair/
https://blackpast.org/african-american-history/st-clair-stephanie-1886-1969/
https://www.gothamcenter.org/blog/the-queen-of-numbers-stephanie-st-clair-and-harlems-gambling-racket
https://www.casino.org/blog/stephanie-st-clair/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephanie_St._Clair

Leave a Comment