The Assassination of James Garfield: A Disappointed Office-Seeker and a Dying President

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

On the morning of 2 July 1881, President James A. Garfield walked into the Baltimore and Potomac Railroad Station in Washington, D.C., with Secretary of State James G. Blaine, on his way to catch a train to Long Branch, New Jersey, for a summer holiday. He had been president for less than four months. Behind him, in the ladies’ waiting room, stood Charles Julius Guiteau, a failed lawyer and writer who believed he had won Garfield the election and was owed a consulship in return. As the president passed, Guiteau stepped forward and fired twice with a British Bulldog revolver he had bought for ten dollars. One bullet grazed Garfield’s arm. The other entered his back, broke two ribs, damaged his spine, and lodged behind his pancreas.

Garfield did not die at once. He lingered for eleven weeks — seventy-nine days — while the country followed every bulletin, and while his doctors, with the best intentions of their age, made his wounds worse. He died on 19 September 1881. Guiteau, who insisted to the end that the doctors had killed the president and not he, was hanged the following June.

The Man Who Wanted an Office

Charles Julius Guiteau was born on 8 September 1841 in Freeport, Illinois. He had been, by turns, a law clerk, a failed lawyer, a religious enthusiast who spent time in the Oneida Community, and a writer of pamphlets nobody read. In 1880 he attached himself to Garfield’s presidential campaign, wrote a speech in support of the ticket, and became convinced that his efforts had been decisive. He applied repeatedly for a diplomatic post — a consulship in Vienna or Paris — and was repeatedly refused.

His frustration curdled into a fixed idea: that God had told him to remove the president, and that Chester A. Arthur, the vice president, would then take office and reward him. He stalked Garfield for days, waiting for an opportunity. He chose the railway station because the president would be there without a guard, and because he knew the route. The revolver he bought had ivory grips; he later said he had chosen it because it would look good in a museum.

Eleven Weeks

Garfield was carried back to the White House, where a team of doctors led by Dr. Willard Bliss took charge. The medicine of 1881 did not yet accept that germs caused infection, and the doctors probed the president’s wounds with unsterilised fingers and instruments, searching for a bullet they could not find. They did this again and again, over weeks. The wound became infected. Garfield developed abscesses, fever, pneumonia and sepsis. In September he was moved to Elberon, on the New Jersey shore, in the hope that the sea air would help. It did not. He died there on 19 September 1881, at 10:35 in the evening.

Chester A. Arthur was sworn in as the twentieth president’s successor the same night. Garfield was forty-nine years old, and had served one hundred and ninety-nine days in office — the second-shortest presidency in American history, after William Henry Harrison’s thirty-one days.

Historians widely hold that Garfield might have survived the bullet itself. The shot had missed his vital organs; it was the infection, carried into the wound by his own doctors’ hands, that killed him. The case became a landmark in the history of medicine: within a few years, Joseph Lister’s antiseptic methods, long resisted in America, became standard practice in the country’s hospitals.

The Trial

Guiteau was indicted for murder in October 1881 and tried from 17 November 1881 to 25 January 1882 in the Supreme Court of the District of Columbia, before Justice Walter Cox. His lawyers pleaded insanity. Guiteau himself insisted that God had taken away his free will, and that he was therefore not responsible — while also arguing, with a logic all his own, that he had not killed the president at all, since the doctors had done that. His behaviour in court was bizarre: he insulted his own defence team, interrupted the proceedings, and recited poetry.

The trial was one of the first in American history to turn on psychiatric testimony, with experts arguing over whether Guiteau was insane, a narcissist, a psychopath, or simply a fanatic. The jury found him guilty on 25 January 1882, and Justice Cox sentenced him to death. Arthur refused clemency. On 30 June 1882, Guiteau was hanged at the District of Columbia jail. Before the trapdoor fell, he was allowed to recite a poem he had written that morning: “I am going to the Lordy.”

His body was later exhumed, and his brain was removed for study. Portions of it are held today at the National Museum of Health and Medicine in Washington and at the Mütter Museum in Philadelphia — a strange coda to a case that had already given medicine one of its hardest lessons.

A Reform Born of Murder

Garfield’s death had one lasting political consequence. Guiteau was a product of the spoils system, in which government jobs were handed out as rewards for political support, and his crime turned public opinion against it. Within two years, Congress passed the Pendleton Civil Service Reform Act of 1883, which began the move to a professional civil service chosen by examination rather than by patronage. It was a reform the murdered president had himself supported.

What Is Documented — and What Is Not

Documented: James A. Garfield, the twentieth president, was shot on 2 July 1881 at about 9:30 a.m. in the Baltimore and Potomac Railroad Station in Washington, D.C., by Charles Julius Guiteau, who fired twice with a British Bulldog revolver. One bullet grazed the president’s arm; the other lodged behind his pancreas. Garfield died on 19 September 1881 at Elberon, New Jersey, eleven weeks after the shooting, of infection arising from the wound. His doctors probed the wound repeatedly with unsterilised hands and instruments. Guiteau was tried from 17 November 1881 to 25 January 1882, convicted of murder, and hanged on 30 June 1882. Chester A. Arthur succeeded him as president. The Pendleton Civil Service Reform Act followed in 1883.

Not documented / unverified: Guiteau’s exact mental condition has never been settled: he has been described since as insane, narcissistic, schizophrenic, psychopathic, and as suffering from neurosyphilis, and modern writers continue to disagree. Whether Garfield would certainly have survived with antiseptic treatment is widely believed by historians but cannot be proved. The claim that Guiteau chose his revolver for its ivory grips because it would look good in a museum is widely repeated and attributed to Guiteau himself, but rests on secondhand reports.

Sources

Leave a Comment