Arthur Simon Flegenheimer was born in the Bronx on 6 August 1901, the son of German Jewish immigrants Herman and Emma Flegenheimer. He grew up poor, left school early, and was arrested for burglary as a teenager, serving a brief prison sentence on Blackwell’s Island. When he came out, he went to work for a trucking company that smuggled beer and whiskey into New York. He changed his name — to one that fit better in newspaper headlines — and became Dutch Schultz.
Within a decade, he was one of the most feared men in New York. And within a year of his greatest courtroom victory, he was dead in a Newark restaurant, killed on the orders of the very organised-crime council he had defied.
The Beer Baron of the Bronx
Prohibition, which took effect in 1920, made Schultz’s fortune. He seized control of the Bronx’s illegal beer supply, supplying speakeasies across the borough and beyond. His method was simple and brutal: speakeasy owners bought Schultz’s beer, or they suffered the consequences. Rivals were driven out or killed. By the mid-1920s, Schultz controlled nearly all illegal beer distribution in the Bronx, earning — by some estimates — at least half a million dollars a year from beer alone.
He fought bloody “beer wars” against rivals, including the Irish gangster Legs Diamond, and built a reputation for a violent, unpredictable temper. He was, in the words of the Mob Museum, a man whose “vicious ambition catapulted him to the top of the New York City underworld.” His gang, the Noe–Schultz gang, moved from bootlegging into extortion, including a restaurant shakedown operation, and control of at least one labour union.
Schultz was not a subtle operator. He was loud, paranoid, and violent, and he trusted almost no one. That temperament made him rich. It also made him enemies — including, eventually, the men who ran organised crime in America.
The numbers racket
As Prohibition drew to a close, Schultz needed a business that would outlast it. He found one in Harlem: the numbers racket, also called policy. It was an illegal daily lottery in which players bet pennies on a three-digit number, with the winning number often tied to racetrack results. It was played by hundreds of thousands of ordinary people, many of them poor, and it generated enormous sums.
Schultz muscled out the independent Black and Latino bankers who had built the game, often by force, and took it over. His accountant, Otto “Abbadabba” Berman, was a mathematical prodigy who worked out how to manipulate the winning digits so that less frequently played numbers won, increasing the gang’s profit. By the early 1930s, the numbers racket was Schultz’s most lucrative operation, bringing in — by one contemporary estimate — tens of thousands of dollars a day.
The takeover of the Harlem numbers racket was not only a business move. It displaced Black operators who had built a community institution, and it was enforced with the same violence Schultz had used in the beer wars. The people who played the numbers lost money they could not afford; the people who ran it before Schultz lost their livelihoods, and some lost their lives.
Two tax trials — and an acquittal
In January 1933, Schultz was indicted for income-tax evasion, the charge that had already sent Al Capone to prison. He went on the run for nearly two years before surrendering in Albany in November 1934. His lawyers won a change of venue, and his first trial, in Syracuse in the spring of 1935, ended in a hung jury.
The second trial was moved to Malone, a small town near the Canadian border. Schultz arrived weeks early and mounted a public-relations campaign: he spent freely, made friends with townspeople, sent gifts to hospitalised children, and had himself received into the Catholic Church. In the summer of 1935, the jury acquitted him. The judge told the jury, in effect, that they had reached a verdict based on something other than the evidence. But Schultz was a free man.
Freedom did not last. A new special prosecutor, Thomas E. Dewey, had made Schultz his first target, and Dewey was now pursuing him over the numbers racket. Schultz’s answer was to kill Dewey.
The decision that killed him
Schultz put the idea to the Commission, the council of Mafia bosses that Lucky Luciano had helped establish in 1931. The Commission refused. Killing a prosecutor, they argued, would bring overwhelming law-enforcement heat down on everyone. Schultz said he would do it anyway.
That defiance sealed his fate. The Commission voted to eliminate Schultz before he could carry out the killing. On the night of 23 October 1935, Schultz and three associates — his accountant Otto Berman, his lieutenant Abe Landau, and his bodyguard Bernard “Lulu” Rosenkrantz — were at the Palace Chop House, a restaurant at 12 East Park Street in Newark, New Jersey, which Schultz was using as a headquarters.
At least two gunmen entered the restaurant. Charles “the Bug” Workman found Schultz in the men’s room and shot him; Mendy Weiss opened fire on the men at the table. All four were taken to hospital. Berman, Landau, and Rosenkrantz died of their wounds. Schultz, shot in the side, lingered for about a day. As his fever rose, he spoke in a rambling, delirious monologue that a police stenographer recorded — the famous “deathbed transcript,” full of fragmented phrases that have fascinated writers ever since. He died on the evening of 24 October 1935, aged 34, of peritonitis from the gunshot wound.
Only one man was ever convicted in connection with the killing: Workman, years later, when the Murder, Inc. cases broke open in Brooklyn in 1940.
The legend that followed
Schultz’s death left behind two legends. The first was the treasure: stories that he had buried a waterproof safe full of gold coins, cash, diamonds, and bonds somewhere in the Catskill Mountains, worth millions of dollars. Treasure hunters have searched for it for nearly a century. It has never been found, and its existence has never been proved.
The second legend was Schultz himself — the Bronx boy who became a beer baron, beat the government in court, and was killed by his own side for refusing to back down. Films and novels, from E. L. Doctorow’s Billy Bathgate to The Cotton Club, have retold his life. The real story is less romantic: a violent man who built an empire on intimidation, displaced the people who had built the Harlem numbers game, and was killed because his own allies decided he was too dangerous to keep alive.
His rackets were taken over by the Luciano family. Dewey, the man he had wanted dead, went on to convict Luciano in 1936 and later became Governor of New York. Schultz’s grave is in New York; his fortune, if it ever existed in the form the legends claim, has never been found.
What Is Documented, and What Is Not
Documented: Arthur Simon Flegenheimer, known as Dutch Schultz, was born in the Bronx on 6 August 1901 and died in Newark on 24 October 1935, a day after being shot at the Palace Chop House with Berman, Landau, and Rosenkrantz. He built a bootlegging empire during Prohibition, took over the Harlem numbers racket, and was indicted for tax evasion in 1933; his first trial in Syracuse ended in a hung jury in spring 1935, and he was acquitted at a second trial in Malone in summer 1935. He sought the Commission’s permission to kill prosecutor Thomas Dewey, was refused, said he would do it anyway, and was then killed on the Commission’s orders.
Unverified or disputed: Flag — birth year: most sources, including Wikipedia and the Mob Museum, give 1901; a few secondary sources give 1902. The 1901 date is used here. Flag — treasure: the buried-treasure story is legend; no safe or fortune has ever been found or proved to exist, and the reported values (tens of millions of dollars) vary widely. The exact words and meaning of Schultz’s delirious deathbed monologue are recorded in a police transcript, but interpretations of what he meant are speculation. The precise earnings of his rackets (figures of $20 million a year and similar) are contemporary estimates, not audited accounts.
Sources
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dutch_Schultz
- https://themobmuseum.org/blog/beer-baron-dutch-schultz-gunned-down-90-years-ago/
- https://nationalcrimesyndicate.com/dutch-schultz-biography/
- http://www.historynet.com/thomas-e-dewey-defeats-dutch-schultz.htm
- https://www.livescience.com/dutch-schultz-treasure-prohibition.html
- https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/biography/dutch-schultz