On the evening of 20 August 1989, José and Kitty Menendez were killed in the living room of their home on Elm Drive in Beverly Hills, California. José was 45, a wealthy entertainment executive; Kitty was 47. Their sons, Lyle, 21, and Erik, 18, called the police and said they had come home to find their parents dead. Seven months later, both brothers were arrested and charged with the murders. What followed was one of the most watched criminal cases of the 1990s — two trials, a conviction, a life sentence, and, nearly three decades later, a resentencing that reopened the case in the public mind.
The brothers did not deny that they had killed their parents. From the start, the question was why. The prosecution said the motive was money: the brothers stood to inherit a fortune estimated at about $14 million, and prosecutors pointed to their spending in the months after the killings. The defence said the brothers had acted after years of abuse by their father, and that they had believed their parents were about to kill them. The abuse claims were supported by testimony from family members and from the brothers themselves, but the prosecution argued that the claims were invented to excuse a planned murder for inheritance.
Two Trials
The first trial began in 1993, with each brother tried before a separate jury in the same courtroom. Both juries deadlocked in January 1994 — one leaning towards manslaughter, the other towards murder — and the judge declared a mistrial. The brothers were tried again together in 1995. This time the judge limited the abuse evidence the defence could present, ruling that much of it was not relevant to the charges. In March 1996, the jury convicted both brothers of two counts of first-degree murder, with special circumstances of lying in wait and multiple murder. On 2 July 1996, they were sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.
The brothers were sent to separate prisons and spent more than two decades apart. Their case faded from the headlines, but it never disappeared entirely. Books, documentaries, and later a popular television dramatisation kept public interest alive, and the abuse claims were re-examined by a new generation of lawyers and journalists.
The Resentencing
In October 2024, Los Angeles County District Attorney George Gascón recommended that the brothers be resentenced, citing their age at the time of the crime and their conduct in prison. A new filing also pointed to evidence that had not been presented at trial, including a letter Erik had written to a cousin in 1988 describing abuse, and a claim by a former member of the boy band Menudo that José Menendez had abused him. The district attorney’s office later changed its position after a new district attorney, Nathan Hochman, took office and opposed release, arguing that the brothers had not fully accepted responsibility.
On 13 May 2025, Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge Michael Jesic resentenced Lyle and Erik Menendez to 50 years to life in prison. The new sentence mattered because both brothers had been under 26 when the killings took place — Erik was 18 and Lyle was 21 — and under California’s youth offender laws the sentence made them immediately eligible for parole. Their convictions were not overturned, and no court has granted them a new trial.
Both brothers went before the California Board of Parole Hearings in August 2025 — Erik on 21 August, Lyle on 22 August. Both were denied parole, each receiving a three-year denial, the shortest available under the system. The board questioned their conduct in prison, including rule violations and the use of contraband mobile phones. Their next hearings had been scheduled for August 2028, but in September 2026 the board granted them early suitability hearings, tentatively set for March 2027. Any grant of parole would also be subject to review by the Governor of California. The brothers are held at the Richard J. Donovan Correctional Facility in San Diego.
What the Case Still Turns On
The Menendez case has always turned on the same dispute: whether the brothers killed their parents out of fear after years of abuse, or out of greed for an inheritance. The courts that tried them accepted the prosecution’s account. The resentencing did not change the verdict; it changed the sentence, on the ground that the brothers were young when they committed the crime and have spent nearly 36 years in prison. Their lawyers continue to pursue a habeas petition, arguing that the abuse evidence should have been heard in full. The district attorney’s office continues to oppose their release.
The case is a reminder that a verdict is not always the end of a story. The brothers were convicted in 1996, and the conviction stands. But the sentence imposed in 1996 no longer stands, and the question of whether they will ever be released is now in the hands of the parole board.
What Is Documented — and What Is Not
Documented: José and Kitty Menendez were killed in their Beverly Hills home on 20 August 1989. Lyle and Erik Menendez were arrested in March 1990 and charged with the murders. The first trial in 1993–94 ended in hung juries and a mistrial. At the second trial in 1995–96, both were convicted of two counts of first-degree murder, and on 2 July 1996 they were sentenced to life without parole. On 13 May 2025, Judge Michael Jesic resentenced them to 50 years to life, making them eligible for parole under California’s youth offender laws. Both were denied parole in August 2025, and early parole hearings were granted in September 2026, tentatively scheduled for March 2027. The brothers are held at the Richard J. Donovan Correctional Facility in San Diego.
Not documented / unverified: The brothers’ claims of long-term abuse by their father were presented in testimony but have never been established by a court finding; the prosecution disputed them, and the jury in the second trial convicted on a murder theory. The 2023 habeas filing cites a 1988 letter from Erik to a cousin and allegations by a former Menudo member; neither has been tested in court. Claims about the brothers’ spending after the killings are documented in the trial record, but the inference that spending proves a financial motive is the prosecution’s argument, not a proven fact. The outcome of the March 2027 hearings is not yet known.