The Murder of Dorothy Stratten: A Rising Star Killed at Twenty

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

Dorothy Stratten was twenty years old when she died in Los Angeles on August 14, 1980. In less than two years she had gone from working in a fast-food restaurant in British Columbia to becoming one of the best-known young models in America, with a film career beginning. She was killed by her estranged husband and former manager, Paul Snider, who then took his own life. The case was closed as a murder-suicide. It has endured in public memory not because it was mysterious, but because it was a clear and terrible record of how control and possessiveness can end a young life.

A Teenager From Vancouver

Dorothy Ruth Hoogstraten was born on February 28, 1960, in Vancouver, British Columbia, and grew up in the nearby city of Coquitlam, in a family of Dutch descent. As a teenager she worked at a Dairy Queen restaurant. In 1978, when she was eighteen, she met Paul Snider, a twenty-seven-year-old promoter who noticed her and spoke to her about modelling.

Snider arranged for photographs of her to be taken and sent them to the West Coast office of Playboy magazine. The magazine accepted her. She was chosen as Playmate of the Month for August 1979, and she and Snider married in Las Vegas that year. They moved to Los Angeles, where she also worked at the Playboy Club.

The speed of her rise was remarkable. In June 1980, she was named Playmate of the Year for 1980. She had begun to act, appearing in comedy films and on television, and she had been cast by director Peter Bogdanovich in They All Laughed, a film that also featured Audrey Hepburn. At twenty, she appeared to have a long career ahead of her.

A Marriage Coming Apart

By 1980, the marriage was breaking down. Stratten was separating from Snider, in the process of divorcing him, and ending their business relationship. Snider had been her manager as well as her husband, and the separation meant the loss of both his marriage and his control over her career.

Friends and colleagues later described a pattern that is familiar in cases of this kind: a man who had introduced a young woman to fame and wealth, and who could not accept her growing independence. Stratten had begun a relationship with Bogdanovich, and she was building a professional life of her own. Snider, by the accounts of those who knew him, was increasingly desperate and resentful as she moved away from him.

On August 13, 1980, Snider bought a used twelve-gauge shotgun from a private seller he had found through a classified advertisement. That evening he told friends that he had bought a gun. What he said about his intentions has been reported differently by different accounts, and this article does not rely on any single version of those conversations.

August 14, 1980

On August 14, 1980, Stratten went to the Los Angeles apartment she had once shared with Snider, to meet him and discuss the terms of their separation, including a property settlement. It was a meeting she had agreed to, about practical matters, and she went alone.

What happened inside the apartment was established by the physical evidence and by the coroner’s findings. Snider shot Stratten, killing her, and then shot himself. Both were found dead in the apartment later that day by Snider’s roommates, who called the police. Stratten was twenty years old.

The police investigation was brief. The sequence of events was clear from the evidence: Snider had bought the shotgun the day before, his fingerprints were on the weapon, and there was no sign of anyone else having been present. The case was closed as a murder-suicide. There was no trial, because there was no surviving suspect to try.

What Followed

Stratten’s death was widely reported, and it prompted serious discussion about the circumstances of her life: the age at which she had been brought into the modelling world, the control exercised by the man who had discovered her, and the responsibilities of the institutions around her. Playboy issued a statement mourning her death. Hugh Hefner, the magazine’s founder, spoke at her funeral.

Her family later brought a civil suit against Playboy, which was settled privately. The terms were not made public.

Stratten’s story was retold in two films. A television movie, Death of a Centerfold: The Dorothy Stratten Story, was released in 1981, with Jamie Lee Curtis playing Stratten. Bob Fosse’s theatrical film Star 80 followed in 1983, with Mariel Hemingway in the role. Bogdanovich wrote a book about her, The Killing of the Unicorn, published in 1984, in which he criticised the handling of young models and the men who controlled their careers.

Journalist Teresa Carpenter wrote an account of the murder, “Death of a Playmate”, for The Village Voice. It won the Pulitzer Prize for Feature Writing in 1981.

A Life Remembered for Its Beginning

Dorothy Stratten’s public life lasted less than two years. She is remembered as a young woman of striking promise who was killed at the moment her career was opening up, by a man who could not accept her independence. The facts of the case are not in dispute, and there is no mystery about who killed her. What has kept the case in public memory is the question it raises about the world she entered at eighteen: who was looking out for her, and what might have been different if someone had been.

What Is Documented — and What Is Not

Documented: Dorothy Stratten, born February 28, 1960, was Playmate of the Month for August 1979 and Playmate of the Year for 1980. She married Paul Snider in 1979 and was separating from him in 1980. Snider bought a shotgun on August 13, 1980. On August 14, 1980, Stratten went to his Los Angeles apartment to discuss their separation, and both were found dead there later that day. The coroner’s findings and the police investigation established a murder-suicide. The case was closed on that basis. Death of a Centerfold (1981), Star 80 (1983), and The Killing of the Unicorn (1984) retold her story. Teresa Carpenter’s “Death of a Playmate” won the 1981 Pulitzer Prize for Feature Writing.

Not established: The exact words of the conversations inside the apartment, which no witness survived to report. The precise content of what Snider said to friends on the evening of August 13, on which accounts differ. Any claim about the detailed sequence of events inside the apartment beyond what the physical evidence and coroner’s findings established. This article deliberately omits graphic detail about the scene; some secondary accounts include such detail, but it is not needed to understand the case, and the most graphic claims in those accounts are not part of the official record relied on here.

Sources

Leave a Comment