A night in Central Park
On the evening of 19 April 1989, Trisha Meili, a 28-year-old investment banker, went for a run in Central Park in Manhattan. She was found hours later in a ravine, beaten and raped, barely alive. She survived, but she had no memory of the attack. The crime horrified New York, a city already frightened by street crime, and the police were under enormous pressure to solve it.
That same evening, a large group of teenagers had entered the park, and some of them had harassed cyclists and pedestrians. Police picked up a number of them for questioning. Five — Antron McCray, 15, Kevin Richardson, 14, Yusef Salaam, 15, Raymond Santana, 14, and Korey Wise, 16 — were arrested and interrogated. All five were Black or Latino, all from Harlem. After hours of questioning, each of them gave a statement implicating himself and the others in the attack on Meili. Within days, all five had recanted, saying the statements had been coerced — that detectives had promised they could go home if they confessed, and had threatened them if they did not.
Two trials
The five were tried in two trials in 1990, before a city that had already made up its mind. Donald Trump, then a real estate developer, had paid for full-page advertisements in four New York newspapers calling for the reinstatement of the death penalty. The confessions were the prosecution’s case: there was no physical evidence linking any of the five to the crime scene, no DNA match, no witness who placed them with Meili. The defence argued that the confessions were false, extracted from frightened children who had been questioned for hours without lawyers or parents present.
The juries convicted all five. McCray, Salaam and Santana were found guilty of rape, assault, robbery and riot. Richardson was found guilty of attempted murder, rape, assault and robbery. Wise, who was sixteen and tried as an adult, was found guilty of sexual abuse, assault and riot. The four younger boys were sentenced to five to ten years in juvenile detention; Wise was sentenced to fifteen years in adult prison. They served between six and thirteen years.
The confession that changed everything
In 2002, Matias Reyes, a convicted serial rapist and murderer already serving a life sentence, told a prison official that he had attacked Meili alone, and that the five teenagers had nothing to do with it. DNA testing confirmed his confession: his DNA matched the evidence recovered from the crime scene, and none of the five had contributed any DNA to it. Reyes said he had acted alone — a claim consistent with his history, since he had always attacked alone.
The Manhattan District Attorney’s office investigated, and its report recommended that the convictions be vacated. On 19 December 2002, New York Supreme Court Justice Charles Tejada vacated all five convictions and dismissed the charges. The five men — by then adults who had spent their youth in prison — walked out of court as free men. They became known as the Exonerated Five.
The settlement
In 2003, the five men sued the City of New York for malicious prosecution, racial discrimination and emotional distress. The city fought the case for more than a decade. In 2014, under Mayor Bill de Blasio, it settled for $41 million — about $7.125 million each for McCray, Richardson, Salaam and Santana, and $12.25 million for Wise, reflecting the far longer time he had spent in prison. A separate settlement with the State of New York in 2016 added $3.9 million.
The case has remained in public life ever since. The Ken Burns documentary The Central Park Five (2012) and Ava DuVernay’s Netflix series When They See Us (2019) brought the story to new audiences. Yusef Salaam was elected to the New York City Council in 2023. In 2024, members of the group filed a defamation lawsuit over public statements continuing to assert their guilt after their exoneration.
What the case changed
The Central Park Five case is now taught as one of the most serious wrongful convictions in American history, and it changed how the country thinks about confessions. The five teenagers confessed, and then said they had been coerced — and the courts believed the confessions. It took thirteen years, a serial rapist’s conscience, and a DNA test to undo what those confessions had done.
The case also exposed how race and fear shape a trial. The five were tried in a city that was frightened and angry, and the pressure to convict was enormous. The confessions, extracted from children without lawyers, were treated as proof — and the absence of physical evidence was treated as a detail. Today, the case is cited by reformers who argue for recording interrogations, for keeping parents and lawyers present when children are questioned, and for treating a confession as evidence to be tested, not as the end of the inquiry.
For the five men, the exoneration did not return the years they had lost. Korey Wise spent thirteen years in adult prison for a crime he did not commit. The others lost six or seven years of their youth. The $41 million settlement acknowledged the injustice. It did not undo it.
The interrogations
The heart of the case — and the heart of the controversy — was the confessions. The five boys were questioned for hours, some for a full day and into the night, without lawyers and, for the younger ones, without parents present. Parts of the interrogations were videotaped, but the hours before the cameras were switched on were not recorded. The boys later said that detectives had promised they could go home if they admitted involvement, and that they had been told what to say. They described being frightened, tired, and confused, and giving the answers they thought the police wanted.
The police disputed this. They said the boys had confessed voluntarily, and that the details in their statements — details about the attack that only someone present could know — proved the confessions were genuine. But the defence pointed out that the statements were inconsistent with each other and with the physical evidence: the boys gave different accounts of who had done what, of where the attack had happened, and of how Meili had been injured, and none of them could account for the DNA evidence at the scene.
The press, meanwhile, had already convicted them. The New York tabloids called the attack “wilding” — a word the police said the boys themselves had used — and portrayed the five as a gang of predators. The word “wilding” entered the language. Donald Trump’s full-page advertisements, published in the New York Times, the Daily News, the New York Post and Newsday in May 1989, called for the death penalty to be restored in New York and for the police to be “unshackled” — and although the advertisements did not name the five, everyone knew who they were about. The atmosphere made a fair trial almost impossible, and the defence argued at the time that the jury pool had been poisoned.
The five men have taken different paths since their release. Yusef Salaam was elected to the New York City Council in 2023, representing Harlem — the neighbourhood where he grew up and where he was arrested as a fifteen-year-old. Korey Wise, who spent the longest time in prison, has become a prominent advocate for criminal justice reform, and has donated money to the Innocence Project, which helped secure his exoneration. Raymond Santana and Kevin Richardson have also spoken publicly about their experiences. Trisha Meili, who recovered from her injuries, published a memoir, I Am the Central Park Jogger, in 2003, in which she wrote about her recovery and her decision to identify herself publicly. She has said that she does not remember the attack, and that she has never blamed the five men for the years they lost.
What is documented — and what is not
Documented: On 19 April 1989, Trisha Meili was attacked in Central Park. Five teenagers — Antron McCray, Kevin Richardson, Yusef Salaam, Raymond Santana and Korey Wise, aged 14 to 16 — were arrested, confessed after hours of interrogation, and were convicted in two trials in 1990. They served between six and thirteen years. In 2002, Matias Reyes confessed that he alone had attacked Meili, and DNA testing confirmed his confession. On 19 December 2002, Justice Charles Tejada vacated all five convictions. New York City settled the men’s civil lawsuit for $41 million in 2014, and the state settled for $3.9 million in 2016.
Unverified or unproven: Whether the police deliberately coerced the confessions — the five men say they were threatened and promised they could go home; the detectives involved have denied coercion, and no court has ruled on the question. Whether any of the five took part in the other assaults in the park that night — their convictions on those charges were also vacated, and no evidence has linked them to those attacks. Claims about the motives of individual prosecutors and detectives rest on reporting and advocacy, not on court findings.
Sources
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Central_Park_Five
https://www.history.com/articles/central-park-five
http://kreizerlaw.com/central-park-five-case-summary-david-kreizer/
https://www.the-ledger.org/entry/INDIV-005