The Springfield Three: Three Women Vanish from a House in Missouri

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

On 6 June 1992, Suzanne “Suzie” Streeter, 19, and her friend Stacy McCall, 18, graduated from Kickapoo High School in Springfield, Missouri. The ceremony was held at Missouri State University that afternoon. That evening they went to graduation parties with friends, as teenagers do on the night they finish school. They had planned to spend the night at the home of Suzie’s mother, Sherrill Levitt, at 1717 East Delmar Street in central Springfield.

By the following morning, all three women were gone. Their cars were still outside. Their purses, keys, money and cigarettes were still inside. The family dog was still there. No one has ever explained how they left, or where they went.

Graduation night

Sherrill Elizabeth Levitt was 47, a cosmetologist who ran a hair salon. She had been at home that evening. Suzie, born 9 March 1973, was her daughter; Stacy Kathleen McCall, born 23 April 1974, was Suzie’s close friend. The two young women had spent the evening at parties, and Suzie had telephoned her mother at about 10:30 p.m. to discuss their plans for the night.

According to the police account, Suzie and Stacy left the last party at about 2:15 a.m. on 7 June and went to the house on Delmar Street. The FBI’s ViCAP missing-persons alert later put the window for the disappearance at between about 2:15 a.m. and 7:30 a.m. that morning. Nothing in the record explains what happened inside that window. There is no surviving account from inside the house, no witness who saw the women leave, and no confirmed sighting of them after that night that investigators have accepted.

What friends and family found later that day was a house that looked lived in and undisturbed. The three women’s cars were parked outside. Their purses were inside, with money still in them — reports have put the amount of cash left behind at more than $800. Their clothes, keys and cigarettes were there. The dog was there. Police described no signs of a struggle inside the home and no forced entry.

The two clues that were lost

Two things at the house have been discussed ever since, and both are frustrating precisely because they cannot now be examined. The first was the front porch light: the glass globe was broken. Some accounts describe the glass as having been swept into a neat pile before investigators could examine its original arrangement. Whether the light was broken deliberately, to darken the porch, or accidentally, has never been established — and the sweeping meant the evidence was disturbed before it could be read.

The second was the answering machine. There was a message on it that police believed might have provided a clue about the disappearances. It was inadvertently erased before investigators could listen to it properly, and it could not be recovered. What the caller said, who the caller was, and whether the message had anything to do with the disappearance at all, are all unknown. The erased message is one of the most famous lost clues in American true crime, and it is also a reminder of how thin the evidence in this case is: the two things that might have told investigators something were a broken light and a recording no one can hear.

Stacy’s mother, Janice McCall, became worried when she had not heard from her daughter by the morning of 7 June, and called the house. When friends checked and found no one there, Janice reported her daughter missing to the Springfield Police Department. The police filed a missing-persons report and asked her to bring Stacy’s dental records to the station the next morning. Janice also created and distributed missing-person flyers featuring her daughter, Suzie and Sherrill. The FBI formally joined the investigation on 9 June.

The investigation

The Springfield Police Department, with the FBI, the Missouri State Highway Patrol and other agencies, mounted an extensive investigation. More than 5,000 tips came in from the public over the years. The women’s lives were examined in detail — their families, their friends, their routines. A reward fund was established, reported at about $43,000, though some reports have cited about $42,000. Searches were carried out, and leads were followed across the country. None of them explained why three women vanished from a house in a single night, leaving everything they owned behind.

Several people have been discussed in reporting as persons of interest, and several claims have been made about the case. The most widely reported is that of Robert Craig Cox, a convicted kidnapper and robber imprisoned in Texas, who told journalists in 1997 that he knew the three women had been murdered and that their bodies would never be recovered. Investigators in the case have said they do not believe Cox has any credibility, and his claim has never been corroborated by any evidence. It should be treated as an uncorroborated claim by a convicted offender, not as a fact about what happened.

Other tips led nowhere. In 2007, a tip that the women’s bodies were buried in the foundations of a parking garage at Cox Hospital in Springfield was examined with ground-penetrating radar. Nothing was found. The case has been featured on 48 Hours, Unsolved Mysteries and America’s Most Wanted, and on Investigation Discovery’s Disappeared. In 2021, a podcast about the case brought it to a new audience. None of this attention has produced an answer.

In 1997, Sherrill Levitt and Suzie Streeter were declared legally dead. Their case files, however, are still officially filed as missing persons, and the case remains active with the Springfield Police Department under case number 92-40169. In 2022, for the thirtieth anniversary, the FBI’s ViCAP program reissued its alert on the case, with new age-progressed images showing what the three women might look like today. A memorial to the three women stands in Phelps Grove Park in Springfield.

What the record shows

The documented record is this: on the night of 6–7 June 1992, Suzanne Streeter, 19, and Stacy McCall, 18, who had graduated from Kickapoo High School the day before, went to spend the night at the home of Sherrill Levitt, 47, at 1717 East Delmar Street, Springfield, Missouri. By the morning of 7 June, all three had vanished. Their cars, purses, money, keys, clothing and the family dog were left behind. Police found no signs of forced entry or of a struggle inside the house. The only reported anomalies were a broken porch-light globe, which was swept up before it could be properly examined, and an answering-machine message that was accidentally erased.

More than 5,000 tips have been received. No trace of the three women — no remains, no confirmed sighting, no verified account of how they left — has ever been found. No one has ever been charged. Robert Craig Cox’s 1997 claim that he knew the women had been murdered is uncorroborated, and investigators have said they do not consider him credible. The case remains open with the Springfield Police Department, and the FBI’s ViCAP alert on the three women remains active.

Sources

Leave a Comment