Jesse Woodson James was born on 5 September 1847 near Kearney, in Clay County, Missouri, and died on 3 April 1882 in St. Joseph, Missouri, shot in the back of the head by a member of his own gang. Between those dates he became the most famous outlaw in America — and the most mythologised. Newspapers and later films cast him as a Robin Hood who robbed from the rich and gave to the poor. The documented record does not support that picture: there is no evidence that James and his gang shared their loot with anyone outside their own network, and many of their targets were small local banks whose losses fell on the communities around them.
To understand Jesse James, it helps to start not with the robberies but with the war that shaped him.
A border-state childhood and the Civil War
Clay County sat in “Little Dixie,” a part of Missouri settled largely by families from the Upper South who brought enslaved people with them. Jesse’s father, Robert James, was a Baptist minister and farmer who held enslaved workers; he died in California during the Gold Rush when Jesse was three. His mother Zerelda remarried, and the household remained firmly sympathetic to the Confederacy when the Civil War began.
Missouri was a border state, and its war was fought in large part by guerrillas. Jesse’s older brother Frank joined pro-Confederate guerrilla bands known as “bushwhackers,” and in 1863, at sixteen, Jesse followed him into the group led by William Quantrill. He later rode with the band of William “Bloody Bill” Anderson. Both brothers were accused of taking part in atrocities against Union soldiers and civilians, including the Centralia Massacre of September 1864, in which guerrillas stopped a train carrying unarmed Union soldiers returning home from duty and killed or wounded some twenty-two of them, before ambushing and killing more than a hundred pursuing Union troops who tried to surrender.
The first robberies
After the war, Missouri remained bitterly divided, and armed bands of veterans on both sides continued to clash. Out of that atmosphere came a wave of bank robberies.
On 13 February 1866, a gang robbed the Clay County Savings Association in Liberty, Missouri, in what is often described as the first daylight bank robbery in peacetime America. During the escape, a seventeen-year-old bystander, George C. “Jolly” Wymore, a student at William Jewell College, was shot dead in the street. Whether Jesse and Frank James took part remains unclear: no evidence has been found that connects either brother to the crime or that conclusively rules them out, and some accounts suggest Jesse was still recovering from his war wounds. The uncertainty is a reminder of how much of the James legend was assembled afterwards, by writers who credited the brothers with crimes they may not have committed.
By the late 1860s the James brothers were riding with Cole Younger and his brothers, forming what became known as the James–Younger Gang. Over the following decade the gang robbed at least twelve banks, seven trains and four stagecoaches. The robberies stretched from Iowa to Texas and from Kansas to West Virginia, and were often carried out openly, in front of crowds.
Jesse became widely known after 7 December 1869, when he and most likely Frank robbed the Daviess County Savings Association in Gallatin, Missouri. Jesse is believed to have shot and killed the cashier, Captain John Sheets, apparently mistaking him for Samuel P. Cox, the militia officer who had killed “Bloody Bill” Anderson.
Turning to the trains
As banks improved their security, with time-lock vaults replacing older combination locks, the gang turned increasingly to trains. On 21 July 1873, they derailed a Rock Island Line train west of Adair, Iowa, and took about $3,000 from the train’s safe and passengers. Later robberies usually targeted the express safe in the baggage car rather than the passengers, though the danger to everyone aboard was real.
The gang’s targets were not the great corporations of legend. Most were small, local banks built on local capital, and the robberies only penalised the local people the gang’s defenders claimed they supported.
Northfield: the raid that broke the gang
On 7 September 1876, eight members of the gang rode into Northfield, Minnesota, to rob the First National Bank — far outside their usual territory. Three men entered the bank and demanded the vault be opened. The acting cashier, Joseph Lee Heywood, refused, and was killed. Outside, townspeople armed themselves and opened fire. Two of the robbers, Clell Miller and Bill Chadwell, were killed in the street, and Cole and Bob Younger were wounded.
Frank and Jesse James escaped and made their way back to Missouri. The rest of the gang fled on foot and were cornered two weeks later, on 21 September, at Hanska Slough near La Salle, Minnesota. Charlie Pitts was killed and the three Younger brothers — Cole, Jim and Bob — were captured, wounded. They pleaded guilty to murder to avoid execution and received life sentences at the state prison in Stillwater. Bob Younger died of tuberculosis in prison; Cole and Jim were paroled in 1901.
The Northfield raid lasted only minutes, but it destroyed the James–Younger Gang. It is still re-enacted every year in Northfield, and the bank building is preserved as a museum.
The last gang and the last years
In 1879 Jesse recruited a new gang, including Charlie and Robert Ford, and between October 1879 and September 1881 the group robbed five trains. He married his cousin Zerelda “Zee” Mimms in 1874, and by 1882 the family was living quietly in St. Joseph, Missouri, under the name Thomas Howard.
Missouri’s governor, Thomas Crittenden, had offered a reward of $10,000 for Jesse James, dead or alive. Robert Ford, a new recruit to the gang, secretly accepted the governor’s offer of the reward and a pardon for his own past crimes. On the morning of 3 April 1882, Ford visited the James house. While Jesse stood on a chair straightening a picture on the wall, his back turned and his guns laid aside, Ford drew a revolver and shot him in the back of the head. Jesse James was thirty-four.
Ford was convicted of murder and sentenced to death — and pardoned by Governor Crittenden about two hours later. He collected at least part of the reward, but public feeling against him was so strong that he never profited from the killing as he had hoped. He was himself shot dead in Colorado ten years later, in 1892.
Rumours, DNA and the legend
Rumours that Jesse James had survived began almost as soon as the newspapers announced his death. A doctor’s examination of the body identified it as James, and in 1995 DNA testing of the exhumed remains confirmed it.
The Robin Hood story was largely the work of newspaper editor John Newman Edwards, who framed the gang’s crimes as resistance to Northern rule.
What the record shows
Jesse James was a product of a brutal guerrilla war who carried its violence into peacetime and sustained it for sixteen years. His fame owed as much to newspaper publicity as to the crimes themselves.
Sources
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jesse_James
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James%E2%80%93Younger_Gang
- https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/history/jesse-and-frank-james
- http://news.minnesota.publicradio.org/features/200109/07_steilm_jamesgang-m/
- https://www.truewestmagazine.com/article/northfield-minnesota/
- https://blog.genealogybank.com/on-this-day-the-bank-robbery-that-destroyed-jesse-james-gang.html