In March 1951, at the height of American fear of communism, a young New York couple stood trial in Manhattan for conspiring to commit espionage for the Soviet Union. Julius Rosenberg, 32, an electrical engineer, and his wife Ethel, 35, a former secretary, were accused of passing atomic bomb secrets to Moscow. Three weeks later, both were convicted; two years later, both were executed — the only American civilians ever put to death for conspiracy to commit espionage.
The case has never stopped being argued over. It took place in a climate of fear — the Korean War had begun the previous summer, Senator Joseph McCarthy’s campaign against alleged communists was gathering force, and the Soviet Union’s first atomic bomb test in August 1949 had shocked Washington. Decades later, declassified files and a key witness’s admissions revealed that important parts of the prosecution’s case, above all the evidence against Ethel, were false — even as those files confirmed that Julius had worked for Soviet intelligence.
How the Case Began
The chain began in Britain. In January 1950, Klaus Fuchs, a German-born physicist on the Manhattan Project, was exposed as a Soviet spy. Fuchs named his courier, Harry Gold, arrested in May 1950. Gold led investigators to David Greenglass, an army machinist at the Los Alamos laboratory. Greenglass was arrested on 15 June 1950, confessed to passing information to the Soviet Union, and said his sister Ethel and her husband Julius had recruited him.
Julius was arrested on 17 July 1950; Ethel on 11 August, after refusing, on Fifth Amendment grounds, to answer a grand jury’s questions about her politics. Their co-defendant was Morton Sobell, a former classmate of Julius’s who had fled to Mexico and was brought back.
The Trial
The trial opened on 6 March 1951 in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, before Judge Irving R. Kaufman. Irving Saypol prosecuted, assisted by Roy M. Cohn; Emanuel Bloch defended the Rosenbergs.
The charge was conspiracy to commit espionage under the Espionage Act of 1917. The couple could not be tried for treason, since the United States was not at war with the Soviet Union; conspiracy required no proof that any document had changed hands — only an agreement to pass defence information to a foreign power.
The prosecution’s case rested almost entirely on David and Ruth Greenglass. David testified that Julius had recruited him in 1944, that he had provided a sketch of an implosion-type atomic bomb and notes in 1945, and that Ethel had been present and typed them up. Ruth said she had acted as a courier. Harry Gold testified he had received material from Greenglass in New Mexico, using the recognition signal “I come from Julius.”
The Rosenbergs testified in their own defence and denied all the charges. When pressed about their politics, they invoked the Fifth Amendment — which many in the courtroom and the press treated as an admission of guilt, though legally it was not.
After about two weeks of testimony, the jury convicted all three defendants on 29 March 1951. Sobell was sentenced to thirty years. On 5 April 1951, Judge Kaufman sentenced both Rosenbergs to death, calling their conduct “worse than murder” and claiming they had caused the Korean War by giving the Russians the atomic bomb. That claim was the judge’s rhetoric, not a finding of fact, and historians note there was no evidence for it.
Two Years of Appeals — and Execution
For more than two years, the Rosenbergs’ lawyers appealed to the Supreme Court nine times, without success. Clemency campaigns drew support from scientists — including Albert Einstein — clergy and protesters in the United States and Europe. Presidents Harry Truman and Dwight Eisenhower both refused clemency. A last-minute stay by Justice William O. Douglas was vacated by the full Court, convened in special session.
On 19 June 1953, Julius and Ethel Rosenberg were executed in the electric chair at Sing Sing Prison in Ossining, New York, minutes apart — the first American civilians executed for espionage. Both maintained their innocence to the end, refusing the government’s offer to spare their lives if Julius named other spies and they admitted guilt.
What Later Evidence Revealed — and What It Did Not
As secret files opened over the decades, the picture that emerged was more complicated than either side claimed.
The evidence against Ethel was false — this is now documented, not merely alleged. In 2001, David Greenglass admitted on 60 Minutes II that he had lied at trial about Ethel typing his notes, to protect his wife Ruth, who he believed had done the typing. Grand jury transcripts released in 2008 and 2015 show neither Greenglass mentioned the supposed September 1945 meeting, the atomic sketch, or Ethel typing anything — David in fact testified he had never discussed espionage with Ethel. FBI files show prosecutors regarded the case against Ethel as weak and pursued it as a “lever” to pressure Julius into confessing. In 1986, assistant prosecutor Roy Cohn said the government had “manufactured” evidence against the Rosenbergs.
Julius Rosenberg did spy for the Soviet Union — this is also now documented. In 1995, the United States released the VENONA decryptions of Soviet wartime cables. They identify an agent codenamed “Antenna,” later “Liberal,” as a courier and recruiter passing military and industrial information — radar, sonar, jet engines — to Moscow. Historians identify that agent as Julius Rosenberg. In 2008, Morton Sobell acknowledged that he and Julius had passed non-atomic, military-industrial information to the Soviet Union, chiefly during the Second World War, when it was an American ally.
What the later evidence does not show is that Julius passed the secret of the atomic bomb. VENONA does not name Julius, does not confirm that he transmitted atomic secrets, and in one cable calls the agent “ignorant” of the atomic bomb project. Ethel was given no Soviet codename, which historians treat as significant evidence that she was not an agent. The atomic information that reached Moscow came principally from Klaus Fuchs, whose material was far more advanced than Greenglass’s crude sketches, which scientists judged incomplete and of little practical value.
The Rosenbergs’ sons, Michael and Robert Meeropol, campaigned for decades for their mother’s exoneration, eventually acknowledging their father had spied while maintaining their mother was innocent — a position reflecting the declassified record, though some historians argue Ethel at least knew of her husband’s activities. What she knew, as opposed to what she did, remains disputed.
What the record shows
- Julius and Ethel Rosenberg were tried in New York from 6 to 29 March 1951 for conspiracy to commit espionage and convicted. Morton Sobell was convicted with them and sentenced to thirty years.
- The prosecution’s case rested chiefly on David and Ruth Greenglass. Both Rosenbergs denied the charges and invoked the Fifth Amendment when questioned about their politics.
- Judge Irving R. Kaufman sentenced both to death on 5 April 1951. They were executed at Sing Sing Prison on 19 June 1953, the only American civilians ever executed for conspiracy to commit espionage.
- Documented as false: the key testimony against Ethel. Greenglass admitted in 2001 that he lied about her typing his notes; grand jury transcripts released in 2008 and 2015 contradict the Greenglasses’ trial testimony; FBI files show Ethel was prosecuted as a “lever” against her husband.
- Documented: Julius did work for Soviet intelligence, passing military-industrial information during the Second World War — confirmed by the VENONA cables (1995) and Sobell’s 2008 acknowledgement.
- Not established: that Julius passed atomic bomb secrets, or that Ethel was a Soviet agent. VENONA gives Julius no atomic role and Ethel no codename; whether Ethel knew of her husband’s activities remains disputed.