Keddie is a small resort community in the Sierra Nevada mountains of Plumas County, in northern California — a scattering of cabins along the Feather River, the kind of place where neighbours know each other and doors are not always locked. In the autumn of 1980, Glenna Susan Sharp, known as Sue, moved there from Connecticut with her five children after her divorce. Her brother lived nearby. She rented Cabin 28 at the Keddie Resort, a larger house than the trailer the family had first stayed in. It was meant to be a fresh start.
On the night of 11–12 April 1981, that fresh start ended. Four people died, a family was broken apart, and a case began that has now lasted more than four decades without a charge.
The morning of 12 April 1981
Fourteen-year-old Sheila Sharp had spent the night at a neighbouring cabin with the Seabolt family, so she could go to church with them the next morning. When she returned to Cabin 28 at about 8 a.m. on 12 April, she found her mother, her older brother and his friend dead in the living room. Her mother was Glenna Susan “Sue” Sharp, 36. Her brother was John Sharp, 15. His friend was Dana Wingate, 17, who had come to stay the night.
Three younger boys were still in the house, in a back bedroom, unharmed: Sue’s sons Rick, 10, and Greg, 5, and their friend Justin Smartt, 12, who had been allowed to sleep over. One person was missing. Twelve-year-old Tina Sharp was nowhere in the cabin.
The three victims found in the living room had been bound with medical tape and electrical cords. The autopsy findings, as reported in the record, were that Sue and John died from knife wounds and blunt-force trauma, and Dana died by asphyxiation. The details of the injuries are part of the police file; what matters for understanding the case is that the attack was sustained and that it happened while three small children slept a few steps away, unharmed and apparently unaware.
Tina remained a missing person for three years. On 11 April 1984 — the third anniversary of the murders — a bottle collector found part of a human skull and part of a jaw near Camp 18, close to Feather Falls in Butte County, roughly 60 miles from Keddie. In June 1984 a forensic pathologist confirmed the remains were Tina’s. The case, which had begun as a triple homicide and a missing-child investigation, was now a quadruple homicide.
The investigation, and its problems
The Plumas County Sheriff’s Office investigated, with help from the California Department of Justice. From the start, the investigation was dogged by problems that later investigators have acknowledged openly. The cabin was not secured as it should have been, and people entered the scene before all the evidence was documented. Statements were, according to later reporting, lost or never filed. Cabin 28 itself was demolished in 2004, removing the scene altogether.
Two men drew attention early, because of where they lived and what they said. Martin “Marty” Smartt lived in Cabin 26, a short distance from the Sharps, with his partner Marilyn and her son Justin — the boy who had slept over in Cabin 28 that night. Smartt told police that a claw hammer had inexplicably gone missing from his home. John “Bo” Boubede, a friend of Smartt’s who had arrived in Keddie only days before the murders, was staying in the same cabin. Boubede told investigators he was a former Chicago police officer and that Marilyn was his niece; both claims were later shown to be untrue, and reporting has linked him — on the basis of allegation, not proof — to organised crime in Chicago.
It must be said plainly: neither man was ever charged with the Keddie murders, and neither was ever convicted of them. Both men are now dead; Boubede died in 1988. Smartt was reported to have told his wife, in a letter and in a therapy session, that he was involved — accounts that come from Marilyn Smartt’s reporting of what he said, not from a confession made to police, and which were never tested in court. They are part of the record of the investigation, not a verdict. The case remains officially unsolved, and any living person connected to it is entitled to the presumption of innocence.
New evidence, decades later
The case did not go quiet. In 2016, special investigator Mike Gamberg, working with the Plumas County Sheriff’s Office on a renewed review, recovered a hammer from a pond near the old resort on 24 March 2016. It matched the general description of the hammer Smartt had said was missing. Sheriff Greg Hagwood, who had been 16 at the time of the murders and knew the Sharp family, said the location where it was found suggested it had been deliberately discarded rather than accidentally lost. The hammer was taken into evidence. It did not lead to charges.
Then, in April 2018, Gamberg announced that DNA recovered from a piece of medical tape at the crime scene — tape found near Sue Sharp’s body — matched a known living suspect. Gamberg said he had held the DNA sample for years before obtaining comparison profiles that produced the match. The identity of that person has not been publicly released, and no arrest followed. Gamberg also said at the time that six potential suspects were being examined, and both he and Sheriff Hagwood have suggested that more than one person may have been involved in the murders or in a cover-up. That, too, is an investigative view, not a proven fact.
An anonymous telephone call received by the Butte County Sheriff’s Office shortly after Tina’s remains were found, identifying them as hers, was also recovered years later — a tape of the call was found at the bottom of an evidence box after 2013. The call was never documented at the time. It is one more small thread in a case full of threads that lead nowhere conclusive.
Why it remains unsolved
There is no single reason the Keddie murders remain unsolved. The early handling of the scene cost the investigation evidence it can never recover. The cabin is gone. The two men most often discussed as suspects died without being charged, and the DNA announcement of 2018 — the most promising development in decades — has not, as of the latest public reporting, produced a prosecution. The Plumas County Sheriff’s Office has said the case remains open.
What the case leaves behind is not only a mystery but a family. Sheila Sharp, who found the scene that morning at 14, and her brothers Rick and Greg, who slept through the attack, grew up without their mother, their brother John and their sister Tina. The Sharp family moved to Keddie for a new beginning. Instead, their name became attached to one of California’s most painful unsolved cases — a case in which the known facts are terrible enough, and the unknown facts have had more than forty years to grow.
What the record shows
The documented record is this: on the night of 11–12 April 1981, Glenna Susan Sharp, 36, her son John Sharp, 15, and John’s friend Dana Wingate, 17, were killed in Cabin 28 at the Keddie Resort in Keddie, California, and 12-year-old Tina Sharp disappeared from the house. Three younger boys in a back bedroom were unharmed. Tina’s remains were found near Camp 18 in Butte County on 11 April 1984 and identified that June. A hammer was recovered from a nearby pond in 2016, and in 2018 investigators announced a DNA match from crime-scene tape to a known living person whose identity has not been made public. Cabin 28 was demolished in 2004.
No one has ever been charged with the murders. Martin Smartt and John Boubede, the two men most often named in reporting as suspects, were never charged and are both dead; their alleged involvement is unproven. The DNA match announced in 2018 has not led to an arrest. The case remains open with the Plumas County Sheriff’s Office.