Barbara Jeanne Grimes was 15. Patricia Kathleen Grimes, known as Petey, was 12 — she would turn 13 in three days. They were two of the seven children of Joseph and Lorretta Grimes, a working-class family in the McKinley Park neighbourhood on Chicago’s South Side. Barbara, the quieter and more serious of the two, was a sophomore at Thomas Kelly High School. Patricia was an exuberant seventh-grader at St. Maurice’s Catholic School. Both were devoted fans of Elvis Presley, whose first film had just been released.
On the evening of Friday 28 December 1956, with their mother’s permission, they left home at about 7:30 p.m. with $2.50 for tickets, snacks and possibly a second showing, and walked to the Brighton Theater in nearby Brighton Park to see Love Me Tender. They never came home. Their disappearance set off one of the largest missing-persons investigations in Chicago’s history — and their deaths, when they were finally found, raised questions the record has never settled.
A night at the cinema
The girls were last seen at the theatre that evening. What happened after they left the Brighton is not known. Their mother, Lorretta, waited up. When they had still not returned by about 2 a.m., she called the police to report them missing.
What followed was a search on a scale Chicago had rarely seen. Hundreds of officers were assigned to the case, and a dedicated task force was created. Police, volunteers and the press combed the city. Sightings were reported from all over Chicago and beyond — the girls were said to have been seen on buses, in restaurants, on street corners. None of the sightings produced a lead that held up. The family, meanwhile, waited through the Christmas holidays and into the new year with no word.
The search was complicated by the fact that the girls were teenagers who had gone out on their own, in a city where teenagers did go out on their own. There was no sign of a struggle at the theatre, no witness who could say they had seen the girls leave with anyone, and no ransom demand. For weeks, the case was a disappearance with no direction at all.
The discovery at Willow Springs
On 22 January 1957, almost a month after the girls vanished, a construction worker named Leonard Prescott was driving along German Church Road in unincorporated Willow Springs, south-west of Chicago, when he noticed what looked like discarded mannequins beyond a roadside guardrail. He went home for his wife and returned for a closer look. The shapes were the bodies of two girls, lying in the snow. Their clothing was missing. Joseph Grimes was brought to identify them, and broke down before a formal identification could be completed; a family member later confirmed they were Barbara and Patricia.
The autopsy, carried out by experienced pathologists, reached a conclusion that has shaped the case ever since. Based on the contents of the girls’ stomachs — the proportions of their last known meal — the doctors concluded that both sisters had died within about five hours of the time they were last seen at the theatre: that is, on the evening of 28 December or in the early hours of 29 December. The official cause of death on both death certificates was murder, with the specific means given as secondary shock — death from exposure to the cold. Laboratory tests found no alcohol, drugs or carbon monoxide in their bodies, and the doctors found no injury they considered sufficient on its own to have caused death. One pathologist put it plainly: the girls were alive when they froze.
But that conclusion was disputed from the start, and the dispute is part of the case. Harry Glos, the chief investigator for the Cook County coroner’s office, disagreed with the time of death. He pointed to a thin layer of ice found on the bodies, and argued that it showed the girls had been alive until at least 7 January, since only after that date had there been snowfall enough to react with their warm bodies and create the ice layer — and to hide the bodies until they were found. If Glos was right, the girls had lived for more than a week after they disappeared. If the pathologists were right, they died the night they went to the cinema. The many reported sightings of the girls in the weeks between 28 December and 22 January would fit Glos’s version — but reported sightings in a case this public are notoriously unreliable, and none was ever confirmed.
The confession that did not hold
The most consequential lead in the case came from a diner. Minnie Duros, owner of the D&L Restaurant, told police that a young drifter named Edward Lee “Bennie” Bedwell, 21, from Tennessee, had been in her restaurant with the Grimes sisters on the morning of 30 December 1956. Bedwell, a former circus worker who had briefly served in the U.S. Air Force and worked as a dishwasher, was tracked down and taken into custody.
After several days in custody, Bedwell signed a confession on 27 January 1957. As he told it, he and an accomplice he knew only as “Frank” had met the girls at a Madison Street tavern on 7 January, spent a week drinking with them in cheap hotels on West Madison Street — Chicago’s skid row — and then, on 13 January, after the girls resisted the men’s advances, struck them and left their bodies beside German Church Road.
The confession fell apart against the evidence. The pathologists’ finding was that the girls had died on 28 or 29 December, days before Bedwell said he met them. There was no alcohol in their bodies, and no sign of the beating he described. Factory time records gave Bedwell an alibi for the night the girls disappeared. And the “Frank” he named — a man later identified in reporting as William Willingham — denied involvement in the deaths, while acknowledging that he had spent time with Bedwell and two young women after Christmas, whom he said were not the Grimes sisters. Bedwell recanted the confession. He was released from jail on bond on 5 February 1957. He was never convicted of the Grimes murders, and the case against him collapsed.
Whether Bedwell ever met the Grimes sisters at all remains unproven. His confession is part of the record, but the forensic evidence contradicts it, and it cannot be treated as a reliable account of what happened.
Other leads, no answers
After Bedwell, other names surfaced, and none of them stuck. One was Charles Melquist, a suburban man convicted in 1959 of murdering another girl, Bonnie Leigh Scott, 15, whose body was found in a wooded area a few miles from where the Grimes sisters were found. Melquist was investigated in connection with the Grimes case, but no evidence has ever been published linking him to their deaths, and he was never charged with them. He must not be presented as their killer.
Other theories have been offered over the years — that the girls died after going for a ride with teenage boys from a local gang, that they were picked up by a stranger after the film — but none rests on evidence that can be checked. The case remains officially unsolved and open with law enforcement.
The Grimes parents died without ever seeing justice for their daughters: Joseph on 19 June 1965, and Lorretta on 8 December 1989, at the age of 83. They are buried with their daughters at Holy Sepulchre Cemetery in Alsip, Illinois.
What the record shows
The documented record is this: Barbara Grimes, 15, and Patricia Grimes, 12, disappeared on the evening of 28 December 1956 after going to the Brighton Theater in Chicago to see Love Me Tender. Their bodies were found on 22 January 1957 beside German Church Road in Willow Springs. Their death certificates record murder, with the cause given as secondary shock, and the pathologists concluded they died within about five hours of their last confirmed sighting. That time of death was disputed by the coroner’s chief investigator, Harry Glos, who argued from the ice on the bodies that they had lived until at least 7 January. Many sightings of the girls in the intervening weeks were reported but never confirmed.
Edward “Bennie” Bedwell confessed to the murders in January 1957 and then recanted; his confession was contradicted by the forensic evidence and by his own time records, and he was never convicted. No one else has ever been charged. The murder of Barbara and Patricia Grimes remains unsolved.