In the spring and summer of 1988, women began disappearing from New Bedford, a fishing city on the south coast of Massachusetts. By April 1989, the bodies of nine of them had been found along highways in the towns around the city — in Dartmouth, Freetown, Westport, and Marion, along Massachusetts Route 140, Interstate 195, and Route 88. Two more women disappeared in the same period and have never been found.
Eleven women in all. Nine confirmed dead. Two still missing. No one has ever been convicted of any of the killings. The case has been described as possibly the largest unsolved murder case in New England, and investigators have called it the largest homicide investigation in Massachusetts since the Boston Strangler.
The women
The women who disappeared were, in the main, women living on the margins of New Bedford life. Most were involved in sex work, and many struggled with addiction. Several were mothers. Their names deserve to be recorded, because for years the case was discussed as if the victims were interchangeable. They were not.
Debra Medeiros, 29, of Fall River, was reported missing on 27 May 1988 after a fight with her boyfriend. Her body was found on 3 July 1988 in woods beside Route 140 — the first of the bodies to be found. Nancy Lee Paiva, 36, of New Bedford, was last seen walking home from a bar in the early hours of 7 July 1988; her body was found beside Interstate 195 in Dartmouth on 30 July 1988. Debra Greenlaw DeMello, 35, was last seen on 11 July 1988; her body was found on 8 November 1988 off an Interstate 195 ramp. Mary Rose Santos, 26, was last seen dancing at a lounge on the evening of 16 July 1988; her body was found on 31 March 1989 along Route 88 in Westport.
The others were Robbin Lynn Rhodes, 29, found on 28 March 1989 along Route 140 in Freetown; Rochelle Clifford Dopierala, 28, found on 10 December 1988 in a gravel pit off Reed Road; Deborah Lynn McConnell, 25, found on 1 December 1988 off Route 140 in Freetown; Sandra Botelho, 24, last seen on 11 August 1988 and found on 24 April 1989 in woods along Interstate 195 in Marion, the last body recovered; and Dawn Mendes, 25, last seen on 4 September 1988 and found on 29 November 1988 off an Interstate 195 ramp. Two more women — Christina Monteiro, 19, last seen in May 1988, and Marilyn Cardoza-Roberts, 34, last seen in June 1988 — disappeared in the same period and have never been found.
Where a cause of death could be determined, it was most often strangulation. In several cases, decomposition meant no firm cause could be established. The bodies were found in similar circumstances — left in wooded areas, embankments, and gravel pits near highway ramps and shoulders — which led investigators to believe a single killer was responsible. That belief has never been proven in court.
The investigation
The case was investigated by the Bristol County District Attorney’s office and the Massachusetts State Police, with the FBI involved at points. From the start, the investigation was troubled. The district attorney at the time, Ronald Pina, has been widely criticised for his handling of the case, and the investigation became a byword for missed opportunities and poor coordination between agencies.
Two men became the focus of sustained attention. Kenneth Ponte, a 40-year-old New Bedford attorney, was the only person ever charged in connection with the killings. In August 1990, a grand jury indicted him for the murder of Rochelle Clifford Dopierala, who had been beaten to death. Ponte had represented Dopierala in a legal matter shortly before she disappeared, and prosecutors suggested he had killed her because she planned to expose his drug activities. Ponte pleaded not guilty. On 29 July 1991, the district attorney dropped the murder charge, citing lack of evidence. The remaining drug and assault charges against Ponte were dropped the following year, and the case went cold. Ponte died in January 2010. He was never convicted of any of the highway killings.
The other man was Anthony DeGrazia, a 26-year-old construction worker. In May 1989, a local sex worker told a detective that DeGrazia looked like a man who had tried to choke her, and DeGrazia was arrested and charged with 17 rapes and assaults on sex workers in the Weld Square area. He spent thirteen months in jail before being released on bail in June 1990. He was found dead a month later, on 17 July 1990, at the home of his former girlfriend’s parents in Freetown. The autopsy ruled his death a homicide; the district attorney’s office later described it as a suicide. The disagreement has never been resolved, and DeGrazia was never charged in the highway killings.
A third figure entered the picture years later. Daniel Tavares, imprisoned for the murder of his mother, sent a letter from prison indirectly claiming responsibility for the highway killings, and was later convicted in 2015 of the murder of Gayle Botelho, a woman whose body was found near his home. Tavares has not been charged in the New Bedford highway case, and his claim has not been established as fact.
A case that will not close
The investigation has never fully ended. Authorities reopened the case in 2007, and prosecutors have said that DNA testing of evidence was completed in 2021. In June 2024 and again in June 2026, FBI agents searched woods in Westport in connection with the case. The Massachusetts State Police Unresolved Case Unit still takes tips.
Nine women were found. Two were never found. Eleven families are still waiting for an answer.
What is documented — and what is not
Documented: Between March 1988 and April 1989, eleven women disappeared from New Bedford, Massachusetts; the bodies of nine were found along highways in Dartmouth, Freetown, Westport, and Marion, and two — Christina Monteiro and Marilyn Cardoza-Roberts — have never been found. Kenneth Ponte was indicted in August 1990 for the murder of Rochelle Clifford Dopierala, and the charge was dropped on 29 July 1991 for lack of evidence; he was the only person ever charged. Anthony DeGrazia was charged with 17 rapes and assaults in 1989–90 and was found dead on 17 July 1990; his death was ruled a homicide by autopsy and later described as a suicide by the district attorney’s office. No one has been convicted in the case.
Unverified or unproven: That all eleven disappearances were the work of a single killer — investigators believe the cases are linked, but this has never been proven. That Kenneth Ponte or Anthony DeGrazia was the killer — Ponte was never convicted, and DeGrazia was never charged in the highway case. Daniel Tavares’s prison claim of responsibility — reported, but not established and never charged. Any link between the New Bedford killings and the Lisbon murders — explored by investigators in 1993, never established.