For more than a decade, from 1974 to 1986, an offender committed a long series of violent crimes across California — burglaries, sexual assaults and murders — and then stopped. For decades afterwards, investigators knew his DNA but not his name. The case was finally solved in 2018, when a new technique, investigative genetic genealogy, turned a crime-scene DNA sample into a family tree, and the family tree into an arrest. It was one of the most consequential breakthroughs in modern criminal investigation, and it began with evidence that had been waiting in a freezer for years.
Three names, one offender
For most of the investigation, the crimes were treated as separate series. In the Sacramento area, an intruder who attacked people in their homes was known as the East Area Rapist. In Southern California, a killer who murdered couples in their homes was called the Original Night Stalker. Earlier still, a series of burglaries in the town of Visalia was attributed to the Visalia Ransacker. Only in 2001 did DNA testing confirm what some investigators had long suspected: the East Area Rapist and the Original Night Stalker were the same person.
The name that stuck came later, from the writer Michelle McNamara, who called him the Golden State Killer in her writing about the case. McNamara died in 2016, two years before the arrest. She never learned the answer to the question that had consumed her.
The scale of the crimes is difficult to absorb, and it should be stated plainly rather than sensationally. The offender was eventually linked to thirteen murders and a large number of sexual assaults and burglaries across California, and at his guilty plea he admitted 161 uncharged crimes. Behind every one of those numbers was a person, a household and a family. Many victims lived for decades without knowing who had attacked them, or whether he might return.
The science that changed the case
By the 2010s, investigators had the offender’s DNA profile from crime scenes, but it matched no one in the criminal DNA databases. That is the point at which most cold cases stop. In this case, investigators tried something new.
Working with the genealogist Barbara Rae-Venter and the investigator Paul Holes, they took a crime-scene DNA sample and created a SNP profile — a detailed map of the genetic variations in the sample. They then uploaded that profile to GEDmatch, a public genealogy database where people voluntarily share their DNA results to find relatives. The profile matched distant relatives of the offender. From those matches, Rae-Venter and the team built out family trees, generation by generation, narrowing the possibilities until one man fit: Joseph James DeAngelo, born in 1945.
DeAngelo was a Navy veteran and a former police officer, who had served with the police in Exeter and Auburn, California, in the 1970s before being dismissed for shoplifting. He had lived an outwardly ordinary life in Citrus Heights, near Sacramento, for decades.
The genealogy work alone was not enough for an arrest. Investigators needed a direct DNA comparison. They obtained a discarded DNA sample from DeAngelo, and it matched the crime-scene DNA. On 24 April 2018, DeAngelo, then aged seventy-two, was arrested at his home in Citrus Heights.
The guilty plea
On 29 June 2020, DeAngelo pleaded guilty to thirteen counts of first-degree murder and thirteen counts of kidnapping to commit robbery, and admitted 161 uncharged crimes, including sexual assaults. The plea meant that victims and their families were spared a trial, and that the full scope of the crimes entered the public record through his own admissions.
In August 2020, he was sentenced to multiple life terms without the possibility of parole — eleven consecutive life terms. He will spend the rest of his life in prison. For many victims, the sentence brought a measure of closure after more than forty years of waiting, though no sentence can undo what was done.
A technique, and its questions
The Golden State Killer case made investigative genetic genealogy famous, and it has since been used to identify suspects in other cold cases across the United States. The method is powerful precisely because it uses information that was never meant for law enforcement: DNA shared by ordinary people with genealogy websites, to find their ancestors and cousins, can also identify a distant relative who committed a crime.
That power has raised serious questions, and they are still being debated. The people whose DNA helped identify DeAngelo had not consented to police use of their genetic information. Genealogy databases have since changed their policies, and the law is still catching up with the science. Those questions matter, and they deserve a full public debate. But they should not obscure what the technique achieved here: the identification of a man who had evaded capture for more than four decades, through evidence, not speculation.
The victims at the centre
It is worth remembering what the case looked like from the victims’ side. For years, people in Sacramento and across California locked their doors, kept lights on, and slept with telephones beside their beds. Survivors lived with the knowledge that the person who attacked them was still free, and still unknown. Some waited forty years to learn his name. The arrest in 2018 did not arrive in time for all of them — some victims had died in the intervening years — but for those who were still living, and for the families of those who were murdered, it answered a question that had hung over their lives for most of it.
The case also belongs, in part, to the investigators who refused to let it go, and to the writer who gave the offender his name and kept public attention on the case when it might have faded. Michelle McNamara’s book, I’ll Be Gone in the Dark, was published after her death. Its title came from a warning the offender was said to have given a victim. The book helped keep the case alive. The science finished it.
Where the case stands
Joseph James DeAngelo, born in 1945, a former police officer in Exeter and Auburn, California, and a Navy veteran, was identified through investigative genetic genealogy after investigators uploaded a crime-scene DNA profile to the public database GEDmatch and built family trees from distant relatives, with the help of genealogist Barbara Rae-Venter and investigator Paul Holes. A discarded DNA sample confirmed the match, and he was arrested on 24 April 2018 in Citrus Heights, aged seventy-two. On 29 June 2020 he pleaded guilty to thirteen counts of first-degree murder and thirteen counts of kidnapping to commit robbery, admitting 161 uncharged crimes, and in August 2020 he was sentenced to multiple life terms without parole. The case is closed. The debate about genetic genealogy — its power, its limits, and the privacy of the relatives whose DNA makes it possible — continues.
Sources
- https://legalclarity.org/how-did-dna-impact-the-golden-state-killer-case/
- https://www.fbi.gov/news/stories/golden-state-killer
- https://www.britannica.com/biography/Joseph-James-DeAngelo
- https://www.nytimes.com/2018/04/25/us/golden-state-killer-serial.html
- https://www.pexels.com/photo/close-up-shot-of-test-tubes-on-a-blue-surface-7723191/