The Kidnapping of Patty Hearst, 1974: Heiress, Captive, Defendant
Patricia Campbell Hearst was born on 20 February 1954, in Los Angeles, California. She was the granddaughter of newspaper magnate William Randolph Hearst, and an heiress to the Hearst media empire. She was 19 years old, a student, living in an apartment in Berkeley, California, with her fiancé, Steven Weed, when, on the night of 4 February 1974, three members of a small left-wing militant group called the Symbionese Liberation Army broke into the apartment, beat Weed, and took Hearst away.
The SLA claimed responsibility for the abduction and demanded the release of two recently arrested SLA members, Joe Remiro and Russ Little. The group, led by ex-convict Donald DeFreeze, who called himself Cinque, had emerged from the more radical wings of the Black Power movement and espoused Marxist and anti-imperialist ideas. It had claimed responsibility for the murder of Oakland Superintendent of Schools Marcus Foster in November 1973. It probably never had more than 11 or 12 members.
What followed — 19 months in which Hearst went from captive to participant in the group’s crimes, and then to defendant in a federal courtroom — raised legal questions about coercion, culpability and the psychological effects of captivity that have not been settled since.
Captivity
According to Hearst’s testimony at her 1976 trial, she was held for a week in a closet, blindfolded and with her hands tied. During that time, DeFreeze repeatedly threatened her with death. She testified that she had been assaulted and threatened while held captive. This article records that testimony in general terms, without graphic detail.
When she was asked for her decision, Hearst elected to remain and fight with the SLA. On 3 April 1974, two months after she had been taken, she announced on an audiotape released to the media that she had joined the SLA and adopted the name Tania, a tribute to Tamara Bunke, a comrade of Che Guevara.
The SLA also extorted from her father $2 million in a food giveaway to the poor — the “People in Need” programme — as a condition for her release, a condition the group then did not honour.
The bank robbery
On 15 April 1974, Hearst took part in the robbery of a Hibernia Bank branch at 1450 Noriega Street in San Francisco’s Sunset District. Surveillance video from the robbery captured her, masked and holding a rifle, alongside other SLA members, as more than $10,000 was taken. Two bystanders were wounded by gunfire during the robbery.
It was her first publicly documented criminal act after her kidnapping, and it became the centre of her trial. The SLA also took part in at least one other robbery, of a store in Los Angeles. Six of the group’s members, including DeFreeze, were killed in a police shootout and house fire in Los Angeles on 17 May 1974.
Hearst remained at large with the surviving members of the group for more than a year after that. She issued statements adopting the SLA alias “Tania” and denouncing her family and the U.S. government.
Arrest and trial
On 18 September 1975, FBI agents arrested Hearst at a residence on Morse Street in San Francisco. She was taken into custody along with Wendy Yoshimura and SLA members Bill and Emily Harris. She had been a fugitive for 19 months.
Her trial began in January 1976 in federal court. She was represented by the attorney F. Lee Bailey. The defence argued that she had been brainwashed and coerced into participating in criminal activity through physical and psychological pressure during her captivity — a defence centred on duress and psychological coercion. The prosecution suggested that Hearst had joined the SLA of her own volition, and pointed to the bank robbery video and to her statements as evidence that she had participated willingly.
On 20 March 1976, the jury found Hearst guilty of bank robbery and use of a firearm in the commission of a felony. Judge William Orrick sentenced her to seven years in federal prison. She was incarcerated at the Federal Correctional Institution in Pleasanton, California.
Commutation and pardon
Hearst served 22 months before President Jimmy Carter commuted her sentence on 1 February 1979. The commutation came after public advocacy and reconsideration of the psychological testimony presented at her trial. Carter’s decision recognised the extraordinary circumstances surrounding her participation in the crimes, while stopping short of a full pardon. Hearst was released in February 1979.
On 20 January 2001, in one of his final acts in office, President Bill Clinton granted Hearst a full pardon. The pardon restored her civil rights and formally acknowledged the coercive conditions under which her kidnapping had occurred.
Hearst later wrote, with Alvin Moscow, an account of her ordeal from 1974 to 1979, Every Secret Thing, published in 1982. She has since worked as an actress and as an advocate for victims of kidnapping.
What the record shows
Patricia Hearst, 19, was taken from her Berkeley apartment on 4 February 1974 by the Symbionese Liberation Army. On 3 April 1974 she announced that she had joined the group under the name Tania. On 15 April 1974 she took part in the robbery of a Hibernia Bank branch in San Francisco. She was arrested by the FBI on 18 September 1975. On 20 March 1976 a jury found her guilty of bank robbery and use of a firearm in a felony, and she was sentenced to seven years. Her sentence was commuted by President Jimmy Carter on 1 February 1979, after she had served 22 months. President Bill Clinton granted her a full pardon on 20 January 2001.
The case remains, in the judgement of legal historians, one of the most difficult in American law: a victim who became a participant, a defendant who said she had been coerced, and a jury that convicted her anyway. The record shows what she did, what she said in her defence, what the jury decided, and what two presidents later decided about that conviction. It does not settle, finally, the question at its centre — how much choice a captive has.