On the night of 4 April 1991, Angela Hammond stopped at a payphone in a Clinton, Missouri, supermarket lot to call her fiancé, Rob Shafer. She was 20, four months pregnant, and engaged to be married. She told Rob she was too tired to meet him and was going home to take a bath. As they talked, she noticed a man circling the parking lot in an old pickup truck. Moments later, Rob heard her scream — and then the line went dead.
Rob drove toward the lot at once. On the way, he passed the truck going the other way and heard Angela scream his name from inside it. He turned to follow, but his car’s transmission failed, and the truck disappeared into the night. Angela Hammond has never been seen again.
Angie Hammond
Angela Marie Hammond was born on 9 February 1971 in Kansas City, Kansas, the oldest child of Christopher and Marsha Hammond, with a younger sibling, Loren. In 1975, when Angela was four, the family moved to Clinton, Missouri, a quiet farming town about 80 miles southeast of Kansas City, where she grew up. Friends and family knew her as Angie: outgoing, friendly, and popular.
She graduated from Montrose High School, worked most evenings as a night processor at Union State Bank, and was taking classes at Central Missouri State University in Warrensburg. Her fiancé, Rob Shafer, 18, had been her boyfriend for about a year. He proposed in January 1991, after learning that she was pregnant. The couple had no telephone at home, so they often talked by payphone in the evenings.
Angela was 4 feet 11 inches tall and weighed between 120 and 140 pounds. She had brown hair and brown eyes, a small scar on her upper lip, and wore contact lenses. She was last seen wearing a white button-down shirt with black spots, black slacks, and white sneakers.
The evening of 4 April 1991
Thursday, 4 April 1991, began as an ordinary evening. Angela and Rob went to a barbecue at her mother’s home. Afterwards, Angela dropped Rob off at his family’s house, where he had promised to babysit his younger brother until his mother returned home from work. Angela then spent a few hours with her best friend, Kyla Engeman, driving around town and spending time with friends in the town square.
Around 11:13 p.m., Angela called Rob from a payphone in the Food Barn parking lot, at Jefferson Street and 2nd Street in the centre of Clinton, seven blocks from the Shafer home. She told Rob she felt too tired to go out later that night and was going home to take a bath instead. It was an unremarkable call — until Angela noticed something that worried her.
The phone call
Angela told Rob that a suspicious man was circling the parking lot in his old truck. The man parked near the booth, got out carrying a flashlight, and walked to the booth next to Angela’s. She asked if he needed the phone; he said he would try the other one in a minute.
Angela described the man to Rob while she was still on the phone with him: a filthy, bearded man with a mustache, wearing coveralls and a dark baseball cap, with black-rimmed glasses. The truck was a late 1960s or early 1970s model green Ford F-150 pickup, possibly two-tone with a white top, with a decal of a fish jumping out of water covering the entire rear window. There may also have been damage to its left front fender.
Then, according to Rob, the man came back toward her. Rob heard Angela scream. A man’s voice said, “I didn’t need to use the phone anyway.” And then the line went dead.
Rob dropped the phone, ran to his car, and drove toward the lot. On the way, he passed the green pickup truck coming toward him in the opposite direction — and he heard Angela scream his name, “Robbie,” from inside it. He threw his car into reverse to follow, damaging the transmission. He followed the truck for about a mile along 2nd Street and Culvert Drive before the transmission failed and his car broke down. Her car was found abandoned near the payphone.
The search
Rob notified the Clinton police, who called in the FBI. An extensive search began at once, on land and by air, with the Highway Patrol assisting. More than 250 volunteers helped search, and by Sunday night they had covered much of Henry County — but found no trace of her, the man, or the truck.
Officers checked hundreds of trucks matching the description. Every one was ruled out. Two witnesses said they had seen a truck and a suspicious man around the payphones between 11:30 and 11:45 p.m., but could not describe him in detail. A composite sketch of the suspect was circulated widely. The case aired on NBC’s Unsolved Mysteries in 1992, and a $16,000 reward was offered for leads.
Rob was considered a suspect for a time. FBI agents questioned him for more than five hours and gave him a polygraph test, which indicated he was telling the truth; within a week he was cleared. There were unconfirmed sightings of Angela in several states and in Canada, including a December 1991 tip placing her in Selkirk, Manitoba. All led nowhere.
The other cases
Within days, investigators wondered whether her abduction was connected to two other Missouri cases that same year. On 19 January 1991, Trudy Darby, a convenience store worker in Macks Creek, was abducted from her workplace; the store was robbed of $220, and her body was found in the Little Niangua River two days later. Half-brothers Jesse Rush and Marvin Chaney were later convicted of the robbery and Darby’s rape and murder. On 27 February 1991, Cheryl Ann Kenney, another convenience store worker, disappeared after locking up her store in Nevada, Missouri, about 70 miles from Macks Creek. She has never been found.
An FBI spokesman, Jeff Lanza, said a link was possible but only one of several theories, and cautioned against jumping to conclusions. There is no hard evidence linking the cases. Darby’s was eventually solved with the convictions of Rush and Chaney; Kenney’s and Angela’s remain unsolved.
Clinton Police Chief Bob Pattison said detectives were staying on the case, but there had been nothing solid in the first four weeks. Six months on, Detective Damon Parsons admitted he feared for her welfare and that the chances of finding her alive were slim. The case went quiet — but it was never closed.
Thirty years on: the letter and the mistaken-identity theory
In April 2021, on the thirtieth anniversary of her disappearance, Clinton police announced a new lead — and a new theory.
The lead centred on a confidential informant who had helped disrupt a narcotics operation by testifying in court. When his identity was disclosed, he received a cryptic letter made of cut-and-paste characters, in the style of a ransom note. It addressed him by the confidential number assigned to protect his identity, named his estranged wife, and warned: “We know where your foxy daughter is at, she will see us soon.” It was postmarked 4 April 1991 — the day Angela was abducted. The informant’s wife and daughter — also named Angela — lived in Clinton at the time.
Investigators theorised that, in retribution for the testimony, someone in the enterprise planned to kidnap the informant’s daughter — but mistook Angela Hammond, who resembled her, for the targeted “Angie.” Police said they could not refute the theory and that it seemed credible. They had also received an anonymous call from someone who mentioned details of the letter that, police said, only someone involved would know, and who named two people possibly involved. Police appealed for the caller to contact them again, promising to protect his identity.
As of April 2021, the theory was still being investigated. It has not produced a break. No one has been charged, Angela’s remains have never been found, and her abductor has never been identified. More than three decades after that phone call, her disappearance remains unsolved.
Anyone with information about Angela Hammond’s abduction is asked to contact the Clinton Police Department at (660) 885-5561, or the FBI.
What is documented — and what is not
Documented: Angela Marie Hammond, 20, was last seen in Clinton, Missouri, on 4 April 1991, talking to her fiancé, Rob Shafer, on a payphone in the Food Barn parking lot at Jefferson Street and 2nd Street. Phone records show the call ran from about 11:13 p.m. to about 11:45 p.m. Rob heard her scream before the line went dead, then passed a late-1960s or early-1970s green Ford F-150 pickup, heard Angela scream his name, and followed it for about a mile before his car’s transmission failed. Her car was found abandoned in the lot. Two witnesses saw a similar truck near the telephones between 11:30 and 11:45 p.m. A composite sketch was circulated. Rob was questioned by the FBI, passed a polygraph, and was cleared within a week. The Highway Patrol checked hundreds of matching trucks and ruled them all out. The case aired on Unsolved Mysteries in 1992, and a $16,000 reward was offered. Trudy Darby was abducted in Macks Creek on 19 January 1991 and her killers were later convicted; Cheryl Ann Kenney disappeared in Nevada, Missouri, on 27 February 1991 and has never been found. In April 2021, Clinton police announced a mistaken-identity theory based on a cut-and-paste letter postmarked 4 April 1991 to a narcotics informant whose daughter was also named Angela. Angela was four months pregnant, and she has never been found.
Unverified or unproven: That Angela’s abduction was a case of mistaken identity — the 2021 theory rests on the letter, and police have said they cannot rule it out, but it has not been proven and no one has been charged. That her case is linked to Kenney’s disappearance or Darby’s murder — an FBI spokesman called a link possible but only one of several theories, with no hard evidence connecting them. The reported sightings of Angela in other states and in Canada, including the December 1991 tip from Selkirk, Manitoba — none was ever verified. Small details vary between sources, including the exact minute the call began, her weight (120 to 140 pounds), and her hair colour (brown in most sources, blonde in the Highway Patrol flyer). The identity of the man in the truck, and what happened to Angela after the truck drove away, remain unknown.
Sources
- https://charleyproject.org/case/angela-marie-hammond
- https://unsolved.com/gallery/angela-hammond/
- https://www.missingkids.org/poster/NCMC/1116976/1
- https://www.mensjournal.com/news/one-of-missouris-most-baffling-missing-person-cases-remains-unsolved-35-years-later
- https://mshort.substack.com/p/angela-angie-hammond-missouri-woman
- https://www.coldandmissing.com/cold-and-missing-angie-hammond/
- https://discover.hubpages.com/health/missing-angela-hammond-could-have-been-mistaken-identity