The Kidnapping of Carlina White: Stolen from a Hospital, Found 23 Years Later

Reading Time: 5 minutes ·

On 4 August 1987, Joy White and Carl Tyson brought their 19-day-old daughter to Harlem Hospital Center in New York City. The baby, Carlina Renae White, had a fever of 104 degrees Fahrenheit, and doctors admitted her for intravenous antibiotics. Joy, just 16 years old, stayed by the crib. Sometime between 2:30 and 3:55 that morning, a woman dressed as a nurse removed the IV line, picked up the baby, and walked out of the hospital. Carlina would not see her parents again for 23 years.

The case became the first known infant abduction from a New York hospital, and one of the longest gaps between an abduction and a reunion in American history. What solved it, in the end, was not a detective or a tip line. It was Carlina herself, grown up, asking questions about her own life — and finding her own face on a missing-children website.

The night at Harlem Hospital

Carlina was born on 15 July 1987 at Harlem Hospital Center. Three weeks later, her fever brought the family back to the emergency room. She was admitted to a ward and given intravenous antibiotics, and her parents waited with her through the night.

The woman who took her had been seen in the hospital earlier, behaving like a member of staff. She comforted Joy White, reassured her about the baby, and at some point in the early hours removed the IV and carried Carlina away. No one stopped her. The hospital’s security cameras were not working properly, and the abduction was not discovered until a nurse noticed the empty crib.

Police searched the hospital and the surrounding streets, and the case drew heavy press coverage in New York. But there were few leads: no clear description of the woman beyond her nurse’s uniform, no vehicle, no ransom demand. The trail went cold within weeks. Joy White and Carl Tyson never stopped looking, but as the years passed, the chances of finding a baby taken from a hospital seemed to shrink to nothing.

A childhood under another name

The woman who took Carlina was Annugetta Pettway, known as Ann Pettway, a woman from Connecticut who had suffered multiple miscarriages and wanted a child. She took the baby home to Bridgeport, Connecticut, renamed her Nejdra Nance, and raised her as her own daughter.

Nejdra grew up believing Pettway was her mother. The family lived in Bridgeport for years, and Pettway later moved to North Carolina. Nejdra went to school, made friends, and lived an ordinary childhood — except for the questions that would not go away. There was no birth certificate for her. Pettway’s explanations for the missing paperwork shifted. When Nejdra applied for health coverage as a young adult and was asked for a birth certificate, the questions became harder to ignore. She began searching online for missing children, looking for a case that matched her own story.

She found it on the website of the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children. There was a photograph of a missing baby — Carlina White, taken from Harlem Hospital in 1987 — and an age-progressed image of what that baby might look like as a young woman. The face in the picture looked like her own.

The centre had kept Carlina’s case alive for more than two decades, updating the age-progressed image as the years passed, so that the baby in the photograph could grow up on paper even as the real child grew up elsewhere. Joy White and Carl Tyson had never stopped looking either. They had kept in touch with the centre, kept Carlina’s picture in circulation, and kept hoping that someone, somewhere, would recognise her. In the end, the person who recognised her was Carlina herself.

The reunion

Nejdra contacted the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, and the case was reopened. DNA testing was arranged through the FBI, and in January 2011 the results confirmed what she had suspected: she was Carlina White, the infant stolen from Harlem Hospital 23 years earlier.

The reunion with Joy White and Carl Tyson was emotional and widely covered. A mother who had last held her daughter as a three-week-old baby was meeting a 23-year-old woman. But the reunion was also difficult. The family had been changed by the loss in ways that could not simply be undone. Carlina had grown up with a different family, a different name, and a different life, and the relationship with her birth parents took time to find its footing. The hospital’s insurance settlement, and questions about what had been done with it, added further strain.

For the public, though, the story was extraordinary: a kidnapping victim who had solved her own case. Carlina had done what two decades of police work had not — she had recognised herself.

The hospital’s failings

The abduction raised serious questions about Harlem Hospital’s security. The woman who took Carlina had walked into a maternity ward, dressed as a nurse, and walked out again with a baby, without being challenged. The hospital’s security cameras were not working properly, and the ward’s controls were loose enough that a stranger could move freely among patients and staff.

Carlina’s case was the first known infant abduction from a New York hospital, and it became a case study in hospital security. In the years that followed, hospitals across the United States tightened their maternity-ward procedures: electronic tagging of newborns, matching wristbands for mother and baby, locked ward doors, and cameras that were actually monitored. None of that helped Carlina’s parents in 1987. They had trusted the hospital to keep their daughter safe, and that trust had been broken in a single night.

Joy White and Carl Tyson later received a settlement from the hospital’s insurers, but money was never the point. What they wanted was their daughter back, and for 23 years they lived with the knowledge that she was somewhere, growing up, with no idea who she was.

The reckoning

Ann Pettway’s life caught up with her quickly once Carlina’s identity was confirmed. An arrest warrant was issued in January 2011, initially over a probation violation from an earlier embezzlement conviction in North Carolina. On 23 January 2011, Pettway turned herself in at the FBI office in Bridgeport, Connecticut.

A federal grand jury indicted her on a kidnapping charge on 17 February 2011. The following year, on 10 February 2012, she pleaded guilty to one count of federal kidnapping. As part of the plea bargain, the child-victim specification of the charge was dropped, and prosecutors agreed to recommend a sentence of 10 to 12 and a half years. Prosecutors later argued for a longer sentence, pointing to new facts about Pettway’s conduct, but on 30 July 2012 Judge P. Kevin Castel sentenced her to 12 years in federal prison, within the range agreed in the plea deal.

Pettway had told investigators that she took the baby because she wanted a child after her miscarriages. She also had a criminal record, including five convictions while Carlina was in her custody, and had admitted to cocaine use over many years. She served her sentence at the Federal Correctional Institution in Aliceville, Alabama, and was released on 14 April 2021.

What is documented — and what is not

Documented: Carlina Renae White was born on 15 July 1987 at Harlem Hospital Center, New York. On 4 August 1987, aged 19 days, she was taken from the hospital by a woman posing as a nurse, later identified as Annugetta Pettway. Pettway raised her in Bridgeport, Connecticut, under the name Nejdra Nance. As an adult, Carlina found her own missing-child listing on the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children website; DNA testing in January 2011 confirmed her identity, and she was reunited with her birth parents, Joy White and Carl Tyson. Pettway turned herself in on 23 January 2011, pleaded guilty to federal kidnapping on 10 February 2012, and was sentenced on 30 July 2012 to 12 years in prison. She was released on 14 April 2021.

Unverified or unproven: The exact sequence of Pettway’s visits to Harlem Hospital before the abduction is based on witness accounts and her own statements, and some details differ between reports. The precise reasons for the strain in the reunion between Carlina and her birth parents have been reported in different ways; the family has spoken about the difficulty only in general terms. Any claim that hospital staff knowingly helped Pettway is not supported by the record — the hospital was criticised for lax security, but no staff member was charged.

Sources

Leave a Comment