Holcomb, Kansas, was the kind of place where a family could be known by everyone and a locked door could seem unnecessary. Herbert Clutter, a prosperous wheat farmer, lived with his wife Bonnie and their teenage children, Nancy and Kenyon, in a large farmhouse just outside the town. He was a respected figure in the community, active in local affairs and known for hiring local young people to work on the farm. On the morning of 15 November 1959, the family was found dead in the house. The news travelled quickly through Finney County and then across the country, because the crime seemed to have no motive that anyone in Holcomb could understand. There had been no sign of a quarrel, no obvious enemy, and nothing in the family’s life that pointed to such violence.
The investigation was led by Alvin Dewey, an agent of the Kansas Bureau of Investigation. Dewey and his colleagues began with the house itself and with the family’s routines, trying to establish who had last seen them alive and whether anything had been taken. The house showed signs of a search, and a small amount of cash and a portable radio were reported missing, but the scale of what had been taken did not match the scale of what had happened. That mismatch became an early clue: whoever had entered the house had expected to find far more money than was there. Herb Clutter was widely believed, wrongly, to keep large sums of cash at home. In fact he paid by cheque and kept little money in the house, a fact his killers apparently did not know.
A tip from a prison cell
The break in the case came not from the farmhouse but from the Kansas State Penitentiary at Lansing. A former prisoner named Floyd Wells told the prison warden that he had once shared a cell with a man named Richard Hickock, and that Hickock had talked about robbing the Clutter family. Wells said Hickock had described Herb Clutter as a wealthy farmer who kept a safe full of money in his house. The information reached Dewey, and Hickock became a suspect. Hickock, in turn, was known to have been travelling with another recently paroled prisoner, Perry Edward Smith. The two men had met in prison and had been released within weeks of each other.
Dewey’s team traced the pair across the country. Hickock and Smith had left Kansas after the murders and travelled through the American South and West, spending money, passing bad cheques and moving on before questions could catch up with them. The trail was thin, but the investigators kept following it, checking hotels, shops and garages where the men were reported to have stopped. The search ended in Las Vegas, where both men were arrested on 30 December 1959, six weeks after the murders. They were brought back to Kansas to face charges.
Confessions and a trial in Garden City
Once in custody in Kansas, both men were questioned by KBI detectives. Each eventually gave an account of the night of 14 and 15 November, although their accounts differed on an important point: who had killed whom. Smith later said in his confession that Hickock had killed the two women, while Hickock maintained that Smith had carried out all four killings. The two men did not testify at their trial, so no courtroom record settles that question, and it remains a point on which the two accounts contradict each other. What the trial did establish, to the jury’s satisfaction, was that both men had entered the Clutter home together, that the family had been killed during the robbery, and that both men were responsible under the law for the four deaths.
The trial was held at the Finney County courthouse in Garden City, the county seat, from 22 to 29 March 1960. Hickock and Smith were tried together. Their defence was temporary insanity, but local doctors who examined them pronounced them sane, and the defence did not persuade the jury. After deliberating for only 45 minutes, the jury found both men guilty of four counts of first-degree murder. Under Kansas law at the time, the conviction carried a mandatory death sentence. Both men were sent to death row at the Kansas State Penitentiary in Lansing.
Five years on death row
During those years on death row, the writer Truman Capote came to Kansas to report on the case, interviewing the investigators, the townspeople and, extensively, the two condemned men. His account, In Cold Blood, was first published as a four-part serial in The New Yorker beginning in September 1965 and then as a book in 1966. Later research showed that parts of the book differ from the real events, so it is not a reliable substitute for the court record. The appeals failed. On 14 April 1965, after five years on death row, Hickock and Smith were executed by hanging at the Kansas State Prison near Lansing. Hickock was executed first and was pronounced dead at 12:41 a.m.; Smith followed shortly afterwards and was pronounced dead at 1:19 a.m. The executions closed the legal case, but they did not close the questions the case had raised in Holcomb, where the loss of a whole family in a single night remained, for many residents, the defining event of the town’s history.
What the record shows
Documented: Four members of the Clutter family — Herb, Bonnie, Nancy and Kenyon — were killed in their home near Holcomb, Kansas, in the early hours of 15 November 1959. Richard Hickock and Perry Edward Smith, two recently paroled prisoners, were arrested in Las Vegas on 30 December 1959 after a tip from former prisoner Floyd Wells. They were tried together at the Finney County courthouse in Garden City from 22 to 29 March 1960, found guilty of four counts of first-degree murder after 45 minutes of jury deliberation, and sentenced to death. Both were executed by hanging on 14 April 1965 at the Kansas State Prison near Lansing — Hickock pronounced dead at 12:41 a.m., Smith at 1:19 a.m. Truman Capote’s In Cold Blood was serialised in The New Yorker from September 1965 and published as a book in 1966.
Disputed or unverified: Hickock and Smith gave conflicting accounts of who killed whom, and neither testified at trial, so the record does not settle that question. Parts of Capote’s In Cold Blood differ from the real events, and the book should not be treated as a verbatim record. Hickock and Smith were also questioned about the 1959 Walker family murders in Florida, but that connection has not been proven, and they were never charged in that case. The ages sometimes given for Nancy and Kenyon Clutter vary between secondary sources, so this article does not state them as settled fact.