The Chowchilla Kidnapping: 26 Children, One Bus Driver, and an Escape from Underground

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

On a summer afternoon in 1976, a school bus carrying 26 children home from a swimming trip vanished from a country road in central California, in one of the largest kidnappings in American history — and one of the most remarkable escapes. The victims were not freed by police or ransom. They freed themselves, digging out of an underground trailer with their bare hands.

A Summer Afternoon in Chowchilla

Chowchilla is a small farming town in Madera County, California. On Thursday, 15 July 1976, 55-year-old bus driver Frank Edward “Ed” Ray was driving 26 pupils of Dairyland Elementary School home after a summer class trip to the swimming pool at the Chowchilla Fairgrounds. The children were aged between 5 and 14.

At about 4 p.m., a van drove into the bus’s path and blocked the road. Ray stopped. Three men with nylon stockings covering their faces came out of the van and hijacked the bus. One pointed a gun at Ray, a second took the wheel, and the third followed in the van.

The kidnappers drove the bus to Berenda Slough, a shallow branch of the Chowchilla River, and hid it there. A second van was waiting nearby. Both vans had been modified for the crime, with blacked-out rear windows and soundproof panelling, and the kidnappers ordered Ray and the children into them, making them jump between vehicles to avoid leaving footprints.

Buried in a Quarry

The vans then drove roughly 110 miles (180 km) to the California Rock & Gravel quarry in Livermore. In the early hours of 16 July, the victims were forced at gunpoint to climb down a ladder, through a hatch, and into an underground bunker.

The bunker was a buried truck trailer fitted with ventilation and a pit toilet and stocked with mattresses and a little food and water. As each victim climbed down, the kidnappers wrote the child’s name and age on a Jack in the Box hamburger wrapper. Once everyone was inside, they removed the ladder, covered the hatch with a heavy sheet of metal weighted with two 100-pound (45 kg) industrial batteries, and buried the opening.

Notes found later showed the plan: a $5 million ransom, to be dropped from a plane into the Santa Cruz Mountains at night, intended to fund restoration of the Victorian Rengstorff House in Mountain View, California.

The Escape

The ransom demand was never made: on 16 July the Chowchilla police telephone lines were jammed with calls from the media and frantic families, so the kidnappers could not get through. They decided to call back later — and fell asleep.

Underground, Ray and the older children worked on a way out. After several hours they stacked the mattresses to reach the hatch; as Ray lifted it, 14-year-old Michael Marshall wedged a piece of wood into the opening, and together they moved the sheet metal and batteries and dug away the remaining debris.

Sixteen hours after being imprisoned, they climbed out and walked to the quarry guard’s shack. Alameda County Sheriff’s deputies took them to Santa Rita Jail, the nearest facility with medical staff, for examination, food and water. All 27 victims survived; several children had cuts, bruises and burns, but none was seriously injured physically. They were then driven back to their families in Chowchilla.

When the kidnappers woke that evening, they saw television news reports that the victims had freed themselves and were safe.

The Investigation and the Arrests

Suspicion fell quickly on 24-year-old Frederick Newhall Woods IV, son of the owner of the California Rock & Gravel quarry, who had keys to the quarry and unlimited access to it. His accomplices were brothers James Schoenfeld, 24, and Richard Schoenfeld, 22, all three from wealthy San Francisco Bay Area families and all previously convicted of motor vehicle theft and sentenced to probation.

A search of Hawthorne, the 78-acre Woods estate in Portola Valley, turned up journals, a draft ransom demand, maps, plans, receipts for the vans and trailer, false identification, one of the guns used, and the hamburger wrapper bearing the children’s names and ages. A rented storage facility held the vans and a getaway Cadillac painted flat black.

Richard Schoenfeld surrendered voluntarily eight days after the kidnapping. Two weeks later James Schoenfeld was arrested in Menlo Park, and on the same day Woods was arrested by the Royal Canadian Mounted Police in Vancouver, Canada, where he had fled.

Convictions and Parole

All three pleaded guilty to kidnapping for ransom and robbery. They contested a separate charge of infliction of bodily harm, which carried a mandatory life sentence without parole; they were convicted on it at trial, but an appellate court overturned those convictions, finding the children’s physical injuries — mostly cuts and bruises — did not meet the legal standard. They were resentenced to life with the possibility of parole.

Richard Schoenfeld was released on parole in 2012, after 36 years in prison. James Schoenfeld was paroled on 7 August 2015, after 39 years. Woods was denied parole repeatedly — 19 times by October 2019 — before a parole panel recommended his release in March 2022. After the recommendation was affirmed, his parole was granted, and he was released in August 2022 at the age of 70. By then, all three kidnappers had been paroled.

The Aftermath for the Victims

The physical injuries healed quickly; the psychological ones did not. Many of the children suffered panic attacks, nightmares and lasting personality changes, and many still reported symptoms of trauma 25 years later, including depression and substance abuse. The case changed how California law treated bodily injury and psychological trauma, and what was learned from the Chowchilla children has guided the treatment of young trauma victims ever since.

Ed Ray received a California School Employees Association citation for outstanding community service. He died on 17 May 2012, visited beforehand by many of the children he had helped save. In 2015 Chowchilla renamed its Sports & Leisure Park as Edward Ray Park and declared 26 February, his birthday, “Edward Ray Day”. In 2016 the surviving victims settled a lawsuit against the kidnappers, paid from Woods’s trust fund; the amount was not disclosed.

What Is Documented — and What Is Not

Documented: The date, location, ages of the victims, the sequence of the hijacking, the underground trailer, the 16-hour escape, the $5 million ransom plan, the arrests, the guilty pleas, the overturning of the bodily-harm convictions, and the parole dates are all established in court records and contemporary reporting summarised in the sources below.

Unverified / to treat with care: Some popular retellings describe details of the hours inside the trailer — conversations, songs, and individual children’s words — that vary between accounts and cannot all be independently verified. This article does not rely on them. The precise value of Woods’s trust fund was disputed by his own lawyer. The influence of the 1969 story “The Day the Children Vanished” on the kidnappers has been noted by commentators but was not established as a motive in court.

Sources

Leave a Comment