Frank Abagnale: The Con Man Behind Catch Me If You Can — and What the Records Actually Show

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

Frank William Abagnale Jr. was born on 27 April 1948 in New York City. He is a convicted check forger who later built a career as a fraud-prevention consultant, and one of the most famous con men in the world, thanks to his 1980 memoir Catch Me If You Can and Steven Spielberg’s 2002 film, in which Leonardo DiCaprio played him as a teenage impostor who posed as a Pan Am pilot, a doctor, and a lawyer while cashing millions in forged cheques — all before his twenty-first birthday.

That story is, in its broad outline, a story Abagnale himself told. The problem is that the public record does not support most of it. Journalists began questioning his claims as early as 1978, and a detailed investigation published in 2020 by the Irish science writer Alan C. Logan, The Greatest Hoax on Earth, concluded from court records, prison documents, and newspaper archives that most of the famous version was fabricated.

The Documented Record

Abagnale grew up in New York, and his parents separated when he was a teenager. In June 1965, at seventeen, he stole blank cheques from a petrol station in Tuckahoe, New York, and was sentenced to three years in a state prison. He was paroled after two years, then returned to prison after stealing a car in Boston, and was released in December 1968, at twenty.

That timeline matters, because it leaves very little room for the career described in his memoir. According to the memoir, Abagnale spent the years from sixteen to twenty-one impersonating a Pan Am pilot, flying more than two million miles, and cashing more than $2.5 million in forged cheques in every American state and in two dozen foreign countries. According to the public records Logan examined, Abagnale was in prison for most of that period — about fourteen months of freedom in total between sixteen and twenty-one, according to Britannica.

What is documented after his release in December 1968 is a short period of check fraud. In 1969 he was arrested in France, and he served time in prison in France and in Sweden before being returned to the United States. In July 1970 he cashed a cheque made to resemble a Pan Am pay cheque in Durham, North Carolina, which drew the FBI’s attention. On 2 November 1970 he was arrested in Cobb County, Georgia, after cashing ten fake Pan Am payroll cheques across five states. The total in that federal case was $1,448.60 — not millions. In April 1971 he was sentenced to twelve years in prison, and he was released on federal parole on 8 February 1974, after serving about two years at the Federal Correctional Institution in Petersburg, Virginia.

The Pilot Impersonation

The most famous part of the story is the pilot impersonation. In the memoir and the film, Abagnale poses as a Pan Am co-pilot for years, flying around the world and cashing the airline’s payroll cheques. The record shows something much smaller. According to Logan’s research, Abagnale wore a pilot’s uniform for about three months in 1970, when he was twenty-two — not as a teenager, and not for years. Britannica reports that Logan concluded he impersonated a pilot for only a few weeks. The accounts differ on the exact length, but both agree it was weeks or months, not years.

A San Francisco Chronicle reporter, Stephen Hall, had raised doubts in 1978, two years before the memoir, after contacting institutions Abagnale had named and finding no evidence of his claimed impersonations. A Pan Am spokesman, asked in 2002, denied that Abagnale had ever stolen the money he claimed.

The Doctor, the Lawyer, and the Professor

The memoir also claims Abagnale posed for months as a hospital supervisor in Georgia, a sociology professor at Brigham Young University, and an assistant attorney general in Louisiana. None of these claims has been supported by the institutions involved: Brigham Young University told reporters in 2002 that it had no record of Abagnale or his known aliases. The film’s FBI agent, Carl Hanratty, is fictional — there was no single agent who pursued Abagnale for years. Abagnale has said his co-writer, Stan Redding, exaggerated parts of the book, and the book itself notes that names, dates, and places were changed. That does not resolve the central problem: the record shows he was in prison during most of the period in which the memoir places his most spectacular crimes.

After Prison

What happened after 1974 is better documented, and it is the least disputed part of Abagnale’s life. After his parole, he was arrested again in Texas in 1974 for theft, though not imprisoned for it. In 1975 he approached a bank and offered to teach its staff how check forgers worked, proposing that they pay him only if they found his advice useful. In 1976 he founded Abagnale & Associates, a consultancy advising companies, financial institutions, and government agencies on fraud prevention.

He has since built a long career as a speaker and consultant on fraud and cybercrime, lecturing at the FBI Academy and field offices. His website claims an FBI association of more than four decades, but the FBI has said it cannot confirm the accuracy of all his claims, and Logan found no evidence that Abagnale was placed on the FBI’s Ten Most Wanted list as a teenager, or given a special parole for undercover work.

What the record shows

Documented: Frank William Abagnale Jr. was born on 27 April 1948 in New York City. In June 1965 he stole blank cheques in Tuckahoe, New York, and was sentenced to three years in state prison; he was paroled after two years, returned to prison after stealing a car in Boston, and was released in December 1968. He was arrested in France in 1969 and served time in France and Sweden. On 2 November 1970 he was arrested in Georgia after cashing ten fake Pan Am payroll cheques across five states, totalling $1,448.60. In April 1971 he was sentenced to twelve years in prison, and he was released on parole on 8 February 1974. In 1976 he founded Abagnale & Associates, a fraud-prevention consultancy.

Disputed or unverified: The memoir’s claims that Abagnale, between sixteen and twenty-one, cashed more than $2.5 million in forged cheques (or more than 17,000 cheques) in every American state and two dozen countries; that he impersonated a Pan Am pilot for years and flew more than two million miles; that he posed as a hospital supervisor, a university professor, and an assistant attorney general; that he was pursued for years by a single FBI agent or task force; that he escaped from a federal penitentiary; and that he was placed on the FBI’s Ten Most Wanted list as a teenager. Logan’s 2020 investigation found no evidence for most of these claims and showed Abagnale was in prison for most of the period in question. Abagnale has attributed some exaggeration to his co-writer; the book’s own note says names, dates, and places were changed.

Sources

Leave a Comment