George Kelly Barnes was not the most dangerous gangster of the 1930s, and he was not the cleverest. What he was, briefly, was the most famous. In the summer of 1933, he kidnapped an Oklahoma oil millionaire, collected a ransom of $200,000, and was caught within weeks by a federal agency that was still finding its feet. The case made the Federal Bureau of Investigation a household name, and it gave its agents the nickname by which they are still known: G-Men.
Kelly’s career lasted only a few years, and it ended in a prison cell. He died in Leavenworth in 1954, having spent more than twenty years behind bars. His name, though, survived him — in part because of a legend about his arrest that is almost certainly not true.
The making of Machine Gun Kelly
George Kelly was born on 18 July 1895 in Memphis, Tennessee. He came from a respectable family, attended school, and worked at a series of ordinary jobs before drifting into bootlegging during Prohibition. He was a bank robber of modest talent, and by the early 1930s he was running with a small gang in the American Southwest.
In 1930, Kelly married Kathryn Thorne, a woman with ambitions larger than his own. Kathryn bought him a Thompson submachine gun and encouraged him to build a reputation around it. She is generally credited with inventing the name “Machine Gun Kelly” — and with promoting it to the newspapers. Whether Kelly himself ever used the name is less clear.
The couple’s big plan was kidnapping. In the early 1930s, kidnapping for ransom was a growth business for American criminals, and the most famous case — the Lindbergh kidnapping of 1932 — had shown how much money could be made. Kelly and his gang chose their target carefully: Charles Urschel, a wealthy oilman from Oklahoma City.
The Urschel kidnapping
On the night of 22 July 1933, Kelly and Albert Bates seized Urschel from his home in Oklahoma City and took him to a farm in Texas. Urschel was blindfolded, but he paid close attention to everything he could hear and feel: the sound of an aeroplane passing overhead at a particular time of day, the smell of a nearby oil well, the direction of the wind. When he was released on 31 July, after the $200,000 ransom was paid, he gave the FBI a detailed account that helped agents locate the hideout.
The case mattered for another reason. In 1932, after the Lindbergh kidnapping, Congress had passed a law making kidnapping across state lines a federal crime. The Urschel case was one of the first major tests of that law, and the FBI — then still called the Bureau of Investigation — threw everything it had at it. Agents traced the ransom money by its serial numbers, and the trail led them to the gang.
On 26 September 1933, agents arrested Kelly and Kathryn in Memphis, Tennessee. The arrest gave rise to the most famous story about Kelly: that he cried out “Don’t shoot, G-Men! Don’t shoot!” as the agents closed in. The story was printed everywhere, and “G-Men” — short for Government Men — became the popular name for FBI agents.
The trial and the legend
Kelly was tried in Oklahoma City in October 1933 and convicted of kidnapping. He was sentenced to life imprisonment. Kathryn was convicted as well and sentenced to life; she died in prison in 1985.
Kelly was sent first to the federal prison at Leavenworth, Kansas, and in 1934 he was transferred to Alcatraz, the new maximum-security prison in San Francisco Bay. He spent seventeen years there, and was returned to Leavenworth in 1951. He died of a heart attack at Leavenworth on 17 July 1954, the day before his 59th birthday.
The “Don’t shoot, G-Men!” story deserves a note of caution. It was reported at the time, but no agent present at the arrest ever confirmed it in those words, and historians now believe it was invented or exaggerated by the press and the Bureau itself, which was happy to have a catchy nickname. Kelly himself later said he had not used the phrase. What is certain is that the case made the Bureau famous, and that J. Edgar Hoover used the publicity to build the FBI into the institution it became.
Kelly’s career was short and, by the standards of the era, not especially violent. He never killed anyone. His importance lies not in what he did, but in what his case did for American law enforcement: it showed that the federal government could pursue kidnappers across state lines, and it gave the FBI its first great public success.
What the record shows
- George Kelly Barnes, known as “Machine Gun” Kelly, was born on 18 July 1895 in Memphis, Tennessee. He married Kathryn Thorne in 1930; she bought him a Thompson submachine gun and promoted the “Machine Gun Kelly” name.
- On 22 July 1933, Kelly and Albert Bates kidnapped oilman Charles Urschel in Oklahoma City. A ransom of $200,000 was paid, and Urschel was released on 31 July. His observations while blindfolded helped the FBI locate the hideout.
- Kelly and Kathryn were arrested in Memphis on 26 September 1933. Kelly was convicted of kidnapping in Oklahoma City in October 1933 and sentenced to life imprisonment.
- Kelly was held at Leavenworth and then at Alcatraz from 1934 to 1951. He died of a heart attack at Leavenworth on 17 July 1954.
- Disputed/unverified: The story that Kelly cried “Don’t shoot, G-Men!” at his arrest is widely repeated but was never confirmed by the agents present, and Kelly himself denied it. The origin of the “G-Men” nickname is commonly credited to this case, but the phrase was already in occasional use.
- Unresolved: None of the central facts of the case is in doubt, but the precise role of Kathryn Thorne — whether she planned the kidnapping or merely supported it — is a matter of interpretation.