On the night of 9–10 June 1912, eight people were killed inside a modest two-storey house at 508 East Second Street in Villisca, Iowa. The victims were the entire Moore family — Josiah B. Moore, aged 43, his wife Sarah, aged 39, and their four children — and two young sisters who were spending the night as guests. The killer used the family’s own axe. No one was ever convicted, and the case remains one of the most widely known unsolved crimes in American history.
Villisca was a small railroad town in Montgomery County in southwestern Iowa, home to roughly 2,000 people. Josiah Moore, known locally as Joe, ran an implement dealership, a John Deere franchise, and was a well-known businessman in the town. Sarah Moore was active in the local Presbyterian church. The couple had married in 1899 and had four children: Herman Montgomery, aged 11; Mary Katherine, aged 10; Arthur Boyd, aged 7; and Paul Vernon, aged 5.
An Ordinary Evening
The evening of Sunday 9 June 1912 was an ordinary one. The Moore family attended a Children’s Day programme at the Presbyterian church, where Sarah helped direct the event and the children took part. Two neighbour girls, Lena Gertrude Stillinger, aged 12, and her sister Ina May Stillinger, aged 8, attended with them and were invited to stay the night at the Moore home. The group walked home together after the programme ended, at around 9.30 p.m.
Nothing about that evening suggested danger. The house was an ordinary middle-class home, and Villisca was the kind of town where doors were often left unlocked. At some point after midnight, someone entered the house and attacked the sleeping occupants with an axe taken from the family’s own yard. All eight people in the house were killed. The axe was later found in the guest bedroom where the Stillinger sisters had slept.
The crime was discovered on the morning of Monday 10 June, when the family failed to appear for their morning routine. Josiah Moore’s brother Ross entered the house with a neighbour, Mary Peckham, and found the victims. Word spread quickly through the town, and within hours crowds of curious onlookers had entered the house. The scene was badly disturbed before it could be properly secured, and the National Guard was eventually called in to cordon off the property. Evidence that might have identified the killer was lost in those first chaotic hours, a failure that has haunted the investigation ever since.
The Investigation
The investigation began under the local sheriff, Henry Horton, but soon drew in outside help, including private detectives and a special agent from the federal Bureau of Investigation. From the start, the inquiry was fragmented. Different agencies and private detectives pursued different theories and different suspects, and the competing efforts often worked against each other rather than together.
Investigators found no clear motive. Nothing of value appeared to have been stolen, and there was no sign that the killer had a personal connection to the family that could explain the attack. The victims had been attacked while they slept, and the killer had taken care to keep the house dark, with lamps turned low and mirrors and glass covered. These details suggested planning, but they pointed to no one in particular.
Several suspects were examined over the following years. One was Frank F. Jones, a prominent Villisca businessman and state senator who had once employed Josiah Moore. A private detective with the Burns Detective Agency, James Wilkerson, built a long public campaign accusing Jones of hiring the killer, but Jones was never charged, and no evidence connecting him to the crime was ever presented in court.
Another man examined by investigators was Henry Lee Moore, no relation to the victims. He was later convicted of killing his own mother and grandmother with an axe, and some investigators theorised that he was responsible for a series of axe murders across the Midwest. That theory was never proved in connection with Villisca.
The Only Trial
The only person ever tried for the Villisca murders was the Reverend Lyn George Jacklin Kelly, an English-born travelling preacher. Kelly had been in Villisca on the night of the murders to take part in the Children’s Day services, and he left town on an early morning train. He was a troubled man with a history of mental illness and strange behaviour, and he had made confused statements about the case over the years.
Kelly was arrested in 1917. After hours of interrogation, he signed a confession on 31 August 1917, but he later recanted it at trial, saying it had been forced from him. His first trial, which began in September 1917, ended in a hung jury, with eleven jurors favouring acquittal. A second trial in November 1917 ended in a full acquittal. Kelly was never tried again.
A Theory That Endures
In 2017, the book The Man from the Train, by Bill James and Rachel McCarthy James, argued that the Villisca murders were the work of a travelling serial killer who moved between railroad towns across the Midwest, committing a series of similar axe murders in 1911 and 1912. The theory has attracted considerable attention, and it fits the pattern of a killer who arrived by train and left the same way. But it remains a theory. No suspect in that pattern has ever been identified by name with evidence that would stand in court, and the Villisca case itself remains officially unsolved.
The house at 508 East Second Street still stands. It was listed on the National Register of Historic Places as the Josiah B. and Sara Moore House, and it is now operated as a museum. The eight victims are buried in the Villisca cemetery. More than a century after that June night, the town still lives with the crime, and the question of who entered the Moore home has never been answered.
What Is Documented — and What Is Not
Documented: Eight people were killed in the Moore home in Villisca, Iowa, during the night of 9–10 June 1912. The victims were Josiah Moore, 43; Sarah Moore, 39; Herman Moore, 11; Mary Katherine Moore, 10; Arthur Boyd Moore, 7; Paul Vernon Moore, 5; Lena Stillinger, 12; and Ina Stillinger, 8. The family had attended a Children’s Day programme at the Presbyterian church that evening, and the Stillinger sisters stayed the night. The family’s own axe was the weapon. The Reverend George Kelly was the only person tried for the murders; he signed a confession in 1917, recanted it, and was acquitted after two trials. No one has ever been convicted.
Not established: The identity of the killer. The theory that Frank F. Jones hired the killer was never supported by evidence presented in court. The theory that Henry Lee Moore committed the murders, and the wider theory of a travelling serial killer advanced in The Man from the Train, are both unproven. Some sources give Ina Stillinger’s age as 9 rather than 8; the age of 8 is the one most commonly cited. Claims of forensic DNA testing on the axe handle in 2016–2017 appear in some secondary accounts but could not be confirmed in the sources consulted for this article and should be treated as unverified.