The Burger Chef Murders

Reading Time: 5 minutes ·

On the night of Friday, 17 November 1978, four young employees were working the closing shift at a Burger Chef restaurant at 5725 Crawfordsville Road in Speedway, Indiana, a small town just west of Indianapolis. The assistant manager was Jayne Friedt, aged 20. The other three were teenagers: Ruth Ellen Shelton, 17, Daniel Davis, 16, and Mark Flemmonds, 16. They were supposed to close the restaurant at 11 p.m., count the takings and go home. None of them ever came home.

When a co-worker arrived shortly after midnight and found the restaurant empty, with the back door open and the safe missing $581 in cash, the first assumption was that the four had stolen the money and run off. It was an assumption that would cost the investigation dearly. By the time anyone understood that a far worse crime had taken place, the restaurant had been cleaned and reopened, and much of the evidence that might have identified the killers was gone.

A closing shift that ended in the woods

Between 11 p.m. and midnight, the four employees disappeared from the restaurant. What happened in that hour has never been established with certainty. The leading theory of investigators has been that they were kidnapped during a botched robbery, possibly after one of the victims recognised one of the perpetrators, and driven away from the restaurant. No one has ever been able to say exactly how many attackers there were, although investigators believe there were two or more.

On Saturday morning, the restaurant manager arrived, found the safe empty and the premises in disarray, and called the police. But before detectives treated the disappearance as a serious crime, other employees who arrived that morning cleaned the restaurant, believing they were tidying up after a break-in. The premises were reopened for business. No photographs of the scene as it was found were ever taken. Speedway police officer Buddy Ellwanger, who was later assigned to the case, admitted frankly: “We screwed it up from the beginning.”

It was not until Sunday afternoon, 19 November, that the truth was found. Hikers walking through a heavily wooded property in Johnson County, more than 20 miles south of Speedway, discovered the bodies of all four young people. Daniel Davis and Ruth Ellen Shelton had been shot with a .38-calibre firearm. Jayne Friedt had been stabbed, and the handle of the knife had broken off and was never recovered. Mark Flemmonds had been bludgeoned and died after choking on his own blood. The four had been taken to a place none of them knew, and killed there. Their families, who had spent the weekend fearing the worst, received the news no family should ever have to hear.

The investigation

In the weeks and months that followed, police pursued many leads, but the compromised crime scene left them with little physical evidence. The case received national attention, but no arrests were made. The restaurant at 5725 Crawfordsville Road eventually closed, and the building stood for decades as a grim local landmark before it was finally demolished.

The case might have faded entirely if not for a dramatic development in 1984. That year, Detective Mel Willsey of the Marion County Sheriff’s Department received a call from an inmate at the Pendleton Correctional Facility named Donald Forrester, who was serving a 95-year sentence for rape. Forrester said he had been involved in the murders and was willing to confess in order to avoid a scheduled transfer to the notoriously violent Indiana State Prison at Michigan City. Willsey obtained a court order to bring Forrester to Marion County, where Forrester confessed to shooting Davis and Shelton, and named three men he claimed were responsible for killing Flemmonds and Friedt.

Forrester’s account contained details that impressed investigators. He led police to the wooded area in Johnson County and accurately described the location and position of the bodies when they were found. He knew about the broken knife handle, a detail that had not been widely publicised. His former wife told police that days after the murders, Forrester had driven with her to a wooded area, where he got out and retrieved several firearm shell casings from the ground.

A confession that collapsed

But the case against Forrester fell apart almost as quickly as it had come together. After someone inside the Sheriff’s office leaked details of Forrester’s cooperation, he suddenly recanted his confession, claiming it had been coerced. Investigators also found problems with his account: he said the attack had begun as a threat over a drug debt owed by Friedt’s brother, and some details did not match the physical evidence — for example, none of the victims had been bound, despite parts of his story suggesting otherwise. Other investigators doubted whether Forrester could have known the details he described without having been given information by police, noting that he had been left in a room where evidence was laid out and asked leading questions.

With no further cooperation from Forrester and no direct evidence proving he had committed the crime, he was never charged. He died in prison of cancer in 2006, aged 55. The son of one of the other men Forrester named later told police that his father had confided in him that he had been involved, before his own death — but that, too, was never enough to bring a prosecution.

Investigators have said they believe they have identified some or all of the perpetrators, but without physical evidence they have not been able to prosecute those who remain alive. The Indiana State Police keep the case open, and in recent years they have explored DNA techniques developed since the original investigation.

Four young lives

Nearly fifty years on, the Burger Chef murders remain one of Indiana’s most haunting unsolved crimes, not only because of the youth of the victims, but because of how ordinary their last evening was. Jayne Friedt, Ruth Ellen Shelton, Daniel Davis and Mark Flemmonds went to work on a Friday night and never came home. The case is still open. Anyone with information is asked to contact the Indiana State Police.

What Is Documented — and What Is Not

Documented: On the night of 17 November 1978, four employees — assistant manager Jayne Friedt, 20, Ruth Ellen Shelton, 17, Daniel Davis, 16, and Mark Flemmonds, 16 — disappeared from the Burger Chef at 5725 Crawfordsville Road, Speedway, Indiana, during the closing shift; $581 was missing from the safe. The restaurant was cleaned and reopened before the scene was properly examined, and no photographs of the scene as found were taken; Speedway officer Buddy Ellwanger later admitted, “We screwed it up from the beginning.” The bodies were found on the afternoon of 19 November 1978 in a wooded area of Johnson County, more than 20 miles away. Davis and Shelton had been shot with a .38-calibre firearm, Friedt had been stabbed with a knife whose handle broke off and was never recovered, and Flemmonds had been bludgeoned. In 1984, inmate Donald Forrester confessed to Detective Mel Willsey, saying he shot Davis and Shelton, led police to the scene, and knew the broken-knife-handle detail; he later recanted, claiming coercion, was never charged, and died in prison of cancer in 2006, aged 55. No one has ever been charged, and the Indiana State Police keep the case open.

Disputed or unverified: The leading theory — a botched robbery and kidnapping, possibly after a victim recognised a perpetrator — is investigators’ interpretation, not a proven fact. Forrester’s confession is contested: some details matched the evidence, but other parts conflicted with it, and investigators disagreed about whether he could have learned details from police. The number of attackers is unknown; investigators believe there were two or more.

Sources

Leave a Comment