Lyle Stevik: The Man with No Name, Identified After Seventeen Years

Reading Time: 6 minutes ·

On Friday 14 September 2001, a young man checked into the Quinault Inn, a small motel in Amanda Park, Washington, on the shore of Lake Quinault, on the Olympic Peninsula. He was alone. He had no luggage. He paid in cash. He registered under the name “Lyle Stevik”, and he gave a false address. He was, by the account of the motel staff, a quiet, polite man, in his twenties, who had recently lost a great deal of weight. He asked for a room, and he went to it, and he did not come out again.

Two days later, on 16 September 2001, he was found dead in the room. He had died by suicide, by hanging. He had left a short note, and $160 in cash, to pay for the room he had not used. He had left nothing else. No wallet. No identification. No telephone numbers. No photographs. No one came forward to claim him, and no one reported him missing. The police took his fingerprints, his DNA, and his dental records, and they entered them into every database they had. Nothing matched. The man in Room 5 of the Quinault Inn was, for all practical purposes, no one.

For seventeen years, he was known only as “Lyle Stevik”. It was not his name. It was a name he had chosen, or borrowed, from a book: “Lyle Stevick” is a character in Joyce Carol Oates’s 1987 novel You Must Remember This, a young man who, in the novel, contemplates suicide. The man in the motel had changed the spelling by one letter, and he had taken the name as his own. It was the only clue he left behind, and it was a clue that led nowhere. The police did not know who he was, where he had come from, or why he had come to Amanda Park, a small town on a lake in the rainforest, to die.

A case that would not close

The Grays Harbor County Sheriff’s Office kept the case open, but for years there was nothing to work with. The man’s fingerprints were in the system, and his DNA was in the system, and his dental records were in the system, and none of them matched anyone. The police believed, from the DNA, that he was at least one-quarter Native American and at least one-quarter Hispanic or Spanish in ancestry, and that he was probably in his twenties, but that was all they knew. He was buried, in 2001, in Fern Hill Cemetery in Aberdeen, Washington, under the name “Lyle Stevik”, a name that was not his, in a grave that no one visited.

The case might have stayed cold forever, if not for a new science. In the 2010s, a technique called forensic genetic genealogy began to solve cases that had been unsolvable for decades. The technique is simple in principle and painstaking in practice: a DNA sample from an unidentified person is uploaded to a public genealogy database, such as GEDmatch, and the database returns a list of people who share DNA with the sample — distant cousins, second cousins, third cousins. A genealogist then builds a family tree, working backwards from those cousins, until the tree narrows to a single person, or a single family, who fits the facts of the case. It is the same technique that identified the Golden State Killer in 2018, and it has since identified hundreds of John and Jane Does across America.

In January 2018, the Grays Harbor County Sheriff’s Office asked the DNA Doe Project, a non-profit organisation of volunteer genealogists, to take on the Lyle Stevik case. The Project, which had been founded in 2017, took the case as its first “Doe-Nate” funded case, raising $1,800 from the public to pay for the DNA testing. A sample of Stevik’s DNA was sent to a laboratory, and on 22 March 2018, his genetic profile was uploaded to GEDmatch. The volunteers who worked on the case included Colleen Fitzpatrick, the forensic genealogist who had identified Lori Erica Ruff, and Margaret Press, a co-founder of the DNA Doe Project.

The family in New Mexico

The results came quickly. Within weeks, the genealogists had found a cluster of relatives in New Mexico, two or three generations removed from the man in the motel, and they had traced the family tree to a young man, aged 25, from Alameda County, California, who had disappeared in 2001 and whose family had believed, for seventeen years, that he had chosen to cut himself off from them. The family had not reported him missing, because they believed he was alive, and living his own life, somewhere, and that he did not want to be found. They had been wrong. He had been dead for seventeen years, buried under a false name, in a cemetery in Aberdeen, Washington.

On 8 May 2018, the Grays Harbor County Sheriff’s Office announced that “Lyle Stevik” had been identified. The man’s real name was not released, at the request of his family, who asked for privacy, and who asked that their son’s name not be made public. The sheriff’s office confirmed only that he had been 25 years old, that he had come from Alameda County, California, and that his family had verified his identity by comparing his childhood fingerprints with the fingerprints taken from the body in 2001. His remains were returned to his family, and he was reburied, under his real name, in a place his family chose.

The identification of Lyle Stevik was, in the history of forensic genetic genealogy, a landmark. It was one of the first cases in which the technique had been used to identify a John Doe, and it was one of the first cases in which a family that had believed their son was alive, and had chosen to leave them, learned that he had been dead for seventeen years, and that he had died alone, in a motel room, under a name from a novel. The case showed, more clearly than any other, what the new science could do, and what it could cost.

What remains

The man known as Lyle Stevik is still, in a sense, a mystery. We know his age, and we know where he came from, and we know that his family believed he had chosen to leave them. We do not know why he went to Amanda Park, or why he chose the name he did, or why he took his own life. We do not know what had happened in his life, in the months before he checked into the Quinault Inn, that led him to a motel room on a lake in the rainforest, with no luggage, and $160 in cash, and a note. His family has asked for privacy, and they have not spoken publicly about him, and their silence is, in its own way, a part of the story.

What we do know is that for seventeen years, a man was buried under a name that was not his, in a grave that no one visited, in a town he had no connection to, and that a group of volunteers, working with a new science and a public database, found his family, and gave him his name back. The DNA Doe Project has since identified hundreds of people, and it has given hundreds of families the answer to a question they had been asking for years. The case of Lyle Stevik was one of the first, and it remains one of the most poignant, because it is a case about a man who wanted to disappear, and who did disappear, and who was found anyway, not by the police, and not by his family, but by strangers, who believed that no one should be buried under a name that is not theirs.

The Quinault Inn is still there, in Amanda Park, on the shore of Lake Quinault, in the rainforest of the Olympic Peninsula. The room is still there. And the lake is still there, and the forest is still there, and the town is still there, small and quiet, as it was in September 2001, when a young man checked in, under a name from a novel, and never checked out.

What is documented — and what is not

Documented: On 14 September 2001, a young man checked into the Quinault Inn (also called the Lake Quinault Inn) in Amanda Park, Washington, registering as “Lyle Stevik” with a false address, paying cash, with no luggage. He was found dead in the room on 16 September 2001, having died by suicide by hanging, leaving a short note and $160 in cash for the unused stay. His fingerprints, DNA and dental records matched no one. The name “Lyle Stevik” is a slight misspelling of “Lyle Stevick”, a character in Joyce Carol Oates’s 1987 novel You Must Remember This. DNA analysis indicated he was at least one-quarter Native American and at least one-quarter Hispanic or Spanish. In January 2018 the Grays Harbor County Sheriff’s Office asked the DNA Doe Project to take the case; his profile was uploaded to GEDmatch on 22 March 2018, and genealogists including Colleen Fitzpatrick and Margaret Press traced a cluster of relatives in New Mexico to a 25-year-old from Alameda County, California. On 8 May 2018 the Sheriff’s Office announced he had been identified; his family verified the identification with childhood fingerprints and asked that his real name not be released publicly. He was buried as “Lyle Stevik” in Fern Hill Cemetery, Aberdeen, until May 2018, when his remains were returned to his family.

Unverified or unproven: The exact date his body was found is reported differently — Wikipedia records his death and the discovery of the body as 16 September 2001, while the DNA Doe Project records the discovery as 17 September; this article uses 16 September for his death and describes the discovery as two days after check-in. Why he travelled to Amanda Park, why he chose the name “Lyle Stevik”, and what led him to take his own life are unknown; his family has not spoken publicly, and no note explaining his reasons has been published.

Sources

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lyle_Stevik
https://dnadoeproject.org/case/lyle_stevik/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DNA_Doe_Project
https://www.graysharbor.us/news/lyle-stevik-identified/

Leave a Comment