Billy the Kid: Henry McCarty, the Lincoln County War, and the Death at Fort Sumner

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

Billy the Kid lived for about twenty-one years, and most of what is known about him comes from a few crowded years in New Mexico Territory. He was born Henry McCarty, most likely in New York City in 1859, to an Irish immigrant family. His mother died when he was a teenager, leaving him orphaned at about fourteen. Within a few years he was working as a ranch hand in New Mexico, and within a few more he was one of the most wanted men in the territory. The popular image of the Kid — a smiling gunfighter who killed twenty-one men, one for each year of his life — is legend. The documented record is smaller and messier.

A Short Life Before New Mexico

Little is reliably documented about McCarty’s childhood. He was probably born in 1859, though even the year is uncertain, and the exact date is unknown. His family moved from New York to Indiana and then to Kansas, and after his mother’s death he drifted west. He used several names in his short life: Henry McCarty, Henry Antrim (after his mother’s second husband), and William H. Bonney, the alias under which he became famous.

His first recorded trouble came in 1875, when he was accused of stealing clothes and a gun in Silver City, New Mexico. He was jailed briefly and escaped. In 1877, in Arizona, he killed a man named Francis Cahill during a dispute, an event usually described as his first killing; the details are disputed. Afterwards McCarty was a fugitive, and he made his way back to New Mexico, where he found work with the rancher John Tunstall.

The Lincoln County War

The Lincoln County War of 1878 was not a simple contest between outlaws and lawmen. It was a commercial and political feud between two rival business factions in Lincoln County, New Mexico. On one side stood Lawrence Murphy and James Dolan, who controlled the main store and held contracts to supply the local army post. On the other stood John Tunstall, Alexander McSween, and the cattle rancher John Chisum, who were trying to break that control. The conflict was over trade, contracts, and political influence, and it drew in ranch hands, lawyers, and law officers on both sides.

McCarty worked for Tunstall. In February 1878 Tunstall was shot dead by a posse acting for the Murphy-Dolan side. McCarty and other Tunstall men formed a group calling itself the Regulators, ostensibly to bring Tunstall’s killers to justice, and began a campaign of retaliation. In April 1878 they ambushed and killed Sheriff William Brady, who was aligned with the Murphy-Dolan faction, along with one of his deputies. The Regulators were then themselves pursued as outlaws.

The war reached its climax in July 1878 in a five-day fight in the town of Lincoln, after which the Regulators scattered. The territorial governor eventually offered an amnesty to most participants, but McCarty was excluded because of the Brady killing. He remained wanted, and he continued to rustle cattle and evade arrest.

Capture, Conviction, and Escape

In December 1880 the new Lincoln County sheriff, Pat Garrett, tracked McCarty to a cabin at Stinking Springs, New Mexico, and forced his surrender. Garrett had known McCarty before becoming sheriff, a fact that has added to the legend of their relationship, though how close they were is not documented.

In April 1881 McCarty was tried at Mesilla, New Mexico, convicted of the murder of Sheriff Brady, and sentenced to hang. He was held in the courthouse at Lincoln to await execution. On the evening of 28 April 1881 he escaped. Left briefly with a single guard while other staff were away, he slipped a hand from his handcuffs, overpowered the guard, and shot him. He then armed himself and shot a second guard who was crossing the street. He cut through his leg shackles, stole a horse, and fled. The escape is one of the best-documented episodes of his life, and it made his reputation as a man who could not be held.

The Death at Fort Sumner

McCarty remained free for less than three months. On the night of 14 July 1881 Garrett, acting on information that McCarty might be staying with friends in Fort Sumner, New Mexico, went to the home of rancher Pete Maxwell to question him. McCarty entered Maxwell’s darkened bedroom, apparently not expecting Garrett to be there. According to Garrett’s account, McCarty asked in Spanish who was there, and Garrett, recognising his voice, fired twice. One shot struck McCarty in the chest, and he died at once.

A coroner’s jury examined the body the next day and found that the killing was justifiable homicide. McCarty was buried at Fort Sumner. He was about twenty-one years old. Garrett published his own account the following year, in The Authentic Life of Billy the Kid, a book that shaped the legend but must be read with care, since Garrett was writing about a man he had killed.

How Many Did He Kill?

The figure most often repeated about Billy the Kid is that he killed twenty-one men. That number has no basis in the record. Historians generally credit him with involvement in the deaths of about nine men between 1877 and 1881, and with killing about four of them himself. He was charged with the murder of three men during the Lincoln County War, including Sheriff Brady, and he was convicted of Brady’s murder. The larger numbers come from dime novels, newspaper exaggeration, and later films, which turned a young man involved in a local feud into a national folk figure.

Claims that McCarty survived Fort Sumner have circulated for more than a century, most famously in the case of a man called Brushy Bill Roberts, who in the 1940s and 1950s claimed to be Billy the Kid. No documentary evidence supports those claims, and the coroner’s jury, Garrett’s account, and contemporary newspaper reports all agree that McCarty died on 14 July 1881.

What the record shows

Documented: Henry McCarty was most likely born in New York in 1859, orphaned in his teens, and later known as William H. Bonney. He worked for John Tunstall and joined the Regulators after Tunstall’s killing in February 1878. He took part in the killing of Sheriff William Brady in April 1878. He was captured by Sheriff Pat Garrett at Stinking Springs in December 1880, convicted of Brady’s murder at Mesilla in April 1881, and sentenced to hang. He escaped from the Lincoln courthouse on 28 April 1881, killing two guards. Garrett shot and killed him at Fort Sumner on 14 July 1881, and a coroner’s jury ruled the killing justifiable homicide.

Disputed or unverified: McCarty’s exact birth date and place; the details of his first killing, of Francis Cahill in 1877; the popular claim that he killed twenty-one men, which the record does not support; the closeness of his earlier relationship with Pat Garrett; and all claims that he survived 1881, including those made by Brushy Bill Roberts. Garrett’s 1882 biography is a primary source but a self-interested one.

Sources

Leave a Comment