Two days before Christmas in 1974, three girls left home in Fort Worth, Texas, to finish their holiday shopping. They were expected back by mid-afternoon. They never returned. Their car was found where they had parked it, locked, with no sign of a struggle. More than fifty years later, no one knows what happened to them, no remains have been identified as theirs, and no one has ever been charged in connection with their disappearance. It remains one of the most haunting missing-persons cases in Texas history.
The Three Girls
Mary Rachel Trlica, who went by her middle name, Rachel, was 17. A student at Southwest High School in Fort Worth, she was married to 21-year-old Thomas Trlica, known as Tommy. She was the oldest of the three and the driver that day.
Lisa Renee Wilson, known as Renee, was 14. She was Rachel’s friend and was about 5 feet 2 inches tall. Her boyfriend was Terry Moseley, who had recently given her a promise ring.
Julie Ann Moseley was 9, the younger sister of Terry Moseley. At about 4 feet 3 inches tall, she was the youngest of the three by several years. The three girls set out together on the morning of 23 December 1974.
A Morning at the Mall
The girls left home at around noon. Their first stop was an Army and Navy surplus store, where Renee planned to collect a pair of jeans she had on layaway. From there they drove to the Seminary South Shopping Center, a busy mall crowded with families doing last-minute Christmas shopping. They parked Rachel’s 1972 Oldsmobile 98 in the upper parking area near the Sears store.
That is the last confirmed detail investigators have. The girls had told their families they would be home by 4 p.m. When they did not return, their families began to worry, and by the evening they had contacted the police. At about 6 p.m., Rachel’s Oldsmobile was found in the mall car park, locked, with a present on the back-seat floor. There were no signs of a struggle in or around the vehicle, and no confirmed witness has ever established where the girls went after reaching the shopping centre.
The case was handed to the Youth Division of the Fort Worth Police Department’s Missing Persons Bureau. In the early stages, police treated the disappearance as a possible runaway case, a classification the families disputed. That early assumption meant the investigation was not pursued as thoroughly as it should have been in its first year, according to later accounts of the case.
The Letter
On the morning of 24 December, the day after the disappearance, Tommy Trlica received a letter in the mail that appeared to have been written by Rachel. It said, in effect, that the girls had decided to leave for Houston. The letter was addressed to “Thomas A. Trlica” rather than “Tommy”, the name Rachel normally used, and it was written on a sheet of paper wider than the envelope it arrived in. The handwriting was described as a childish scrawl.
The letter became the only piece of physical evidence investigators have in the case, and it has never been resolved. Handwriting examinations, including analysis by the FBI, have not been able to prove or disprove that Rachel wrote it. The stamp on the envelope had been cancelled on the morning it arrived, and the postmark carried no city name, only a blurred postal number. Whether the letter was genuine, written under pressure, or forged by someone else remains unknown.
The Search, and the Years After
Thousands of leads were followed, dozens of searches were carried out, and hundreds of people were interviewed. In 1975, frustrated with the police investigation, the families hired private investigator Jon Swaim. Swaim pursued the case for four years. In 1979 he died of a drug overdose, in a death ruled a suicide — a loss that was a major setback for the investigation.
Other leads came to nothing. In 1976, three skeletons found in a field in Brazoria County, Texas, were examined as a possible match, but dental records showed they were not the missing girls. In January 2001, the case was formally reopened and assigned to homicide detective Tom Boetcher, who has said he believes the girls left the mall with someone they trusted. In 2018, investigators recovered two vehicles from Benbrook Lake because of a possible connection to the case; that lead also went nowhere.
The case has never left the public eye in Fort Worth. In 2022, an anonymous donor offered a $50,000 reward for information leading to the arrest and conviction of the person or people responsible for the girls’ disappearance. In 2023, billboards were erected across northern Texas showing age-progressed images of the three girls, in an effort supported by the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children (NCMEC) and Clear Channel to mark National Missing Persons’ Day. NCMEC continues to list all three girls as missing.
What Happened to Their Families
The disappearance devastated the families. Rachel’s father died of stage 4 melanoma just six months after his daughter vanished. Her mother later remarried. Tommy Trlica left Fort Worth, remarried, and went on to work as a supervisor at a Texas-based water company. Terry Moseley, Renee’s boyfriend and Julie’s brother, has remained involved in keeping the case in the public eye, including the 2023 billboard campaign.
The Seminary South Shopping Center itself is gone; the site is now known as La Gran Plaza. But for the families, and for Fort Worth, the questions are unchanged: who did the girls meet at the mall that day, and where did they go?
What Is Documented — and What Is Not
Documented: Rachel Trlica (17), Renee Wilson (14) and Julie Moseley (9) went to the Seminary South Shopping Center on 23 December 1974; Rachel’s car was found locked in the car park that evening with no sign of a struggle; a letter purporting to be from Rachel arrived the next morning; the FBI and other examiners could not prove or disprove that Rachel wrote it; the case was reopened in 2001; two vehicles were recovered from Benbrook Lake in 2018 with no result; NCMEC still lists all three as missing.
Not established: What happened to the girls after they reached the mall, who — if anyone — they left with, whether they are alive or dead, and who wrote the letter. Reports that the girls were seen with an unidentified person at the mall are witness accounts that have never been confirmed. No suspect has been named in a charge, and no theory about their fate has been proven. The claim that the girls left with someone they trusted is Detective Boetcher’s stated belief, not an established fact.
Sources
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fort_Worth_Missing_Trio
- https://storiesoftheunsolved.com/2021/07/06/fort-worth-missing-trio/
- https://www.forfoxs.com/2026/09/the-fort-worth-missing-trio-three-girls.html
- https://factworld.online/the-fort-worth-missing-trio-three-girls-who-never-came-home/
- https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Fort_Worth_skyline_in_2011.jpg