On the afternoon of 28 November 1969, the day after Thanksgiving, the Pennsylvania State University campus at University Park was quiet. Most students were still away for the holiday break. Twenty-two-year-old graduate student Betsy Aardsma walked to the Pattee Library to work on an English paper. She never came home. Within the hour she had been killed in the library stacks, in a place full of books and, that afternoon, almost empty of people. Her murder remains officially unsolved more than half a century later.
A Bright Student, Eight Weeks Into Graduate School
Elizabeth Ruth Aardsma — known to everyone as Betsy — was born on 11 July 1947 in Holland, Michigan, the second of four children of Esther and Richard Aardsma. She grew up in a middle-class, religious household in Holland and graduated fifth in her high school class, with honours.
Betsy first enrolled at Hope College in Holland, where she had intended to study medicine, before transferring to the University of Michigan in the fall of 1967 to study art and English. She graduated from Michigan with honours in the summer of 1969. She had hoped to join the Peace Corps and travel to Africa, but she changed her plans to stay close to her boyfriend, David Wright, a medical student at Penn State Hershey. She enrolled in Penn State’s graduate English programme in early October 1969 and moved into Atherton Hall, sharing a room with Sharon Brandt.
She had been a Penn State student for only eight weeks when she died. By the Thanksgiving break she was already feeling the pressure of her coursework, including a demanding English class, and she was behind on a paper. That was why she went to the library on the Friday afternoon after Thanksgiving.
The Afternoon in the Pattee Library
Betsy and Sharon Brandt left Atherton Hall together and walked to the Pattee Library. Betsy went down to the Level 2 core stacks, the dimly lit rows of shelving in the library’s Stack Building, to find research material. Brandt went elsewhere in the building.
Betsy was last seen alive a few minutes after 4:30 p.m. Between 4:45 and 4:55 p.m., she was stabbed a single time in the chest while standing between rows 50 and 51 of the stacks. The wound severed her pulmonary artery and pierced her heart, according to the autopsy conducted by Dr. Thomas Magnani. She collapsed, pulling books from the shelves as she fell.
Because the wound caused little visible bleeding at first, and because there had been no scream and no sign of a struggle, people nearby at first thought she had fainted or suffered a seizure. A man was seen running from the library, and help was summoned. Student paramedics reached her, and she was taken to the university health centre. She was pronounced dead that evening. She was 22 years old.
Betsy was buried in the Aardsma family plot at Pilgrim Home Cemetery in Holland, Michigan, on 3 December 1969.
The Investigation
The Pennsylvania State Police took charge of the investigation, sending dozens of troopers — contemporary reports put the number at around 35 to 40 — to interview students and staff on campus for weeks. A reward of $25,000 was offered for information leading to an arrest. Despite the scale of the effort, investigators had very little to work with: no murder weapon was recovered, there were no defensive wounds on Betsy’s body, and no witness could describe the attacker clearly. Only one witness recalled seeing a man running away shortly after the attack.
Investigators considered whether Betsy had known her killer. The single, precise wound and the absence of a struggle suggested to some that she may have been facing someone she did not fear, or that the attack happened too quickly for her to react. That remains an interpretation of the evidence, not a proven fact.
Over the years, several men were examined as possible suspects. The most prominent was Richard Haefner, a 25-year-old doctoral geology student at Penn State at the time. Journalist David DeKok, in his 2014 book Murder in the Stacks: Penn State, Betsy Aardsma, and the Killer Who Got Away, argued that testimony and circumstantial evidence pointed to Haefner. According to DeKok, Haefner behaved strangely at a professor’s home on the night of the murder, and a state trooper assigned to the cold case at one point told the Aardsma family the case had been solved. Haefner was never charged with the murder, and he died in 2002. The evidence against him is circumstantial, and his guilt has never been established in a court of law.
Two other men were also named by investigators and writers over the years: William Spencer, a sculptor who, according to reports, claimed at a gathering in late 1969 that he had killed the girl in the library, and Larry Maurer, another student. Neither was ever charged. A theory linking the murder to serial killer Ted Bundy was examined and discounted by law enforcement; Bundy was not connected to the case.
Why the Case Still Matters
Betsy Aardsma’s murder became one of Pennsylvania’s most discussed unsolved crimes, and it has stayed in public memory partly because of where it happened. A library is supposed to be one of the safest places on a campus, and the idea that a student could be killed there, in the middle of the afternoon, with no one able to say who did it, has unsettled generations of Penn State students since.
What is certain is the loss at the centre of it. Betsy Aardsma was a gifted student — a poet and artist who had graduated with honours and was beginning graduate study — whose life ended eight weeks into a new chapter. Her family waited decades for an answer that never came.
What Is Documented — and What Is Not
Documented: Betsy Aardsma, 22, was killed by a single stab wound in the Pattee Library stacks on 28 November 1969, between 4:45 and 4:55 p.m.; she had enrolled at Penn State in early October 1969; dozens of state troopers investigated; a $25,000 reward was offered; no one has ever been charged; she was buried in Holland, Michigan, on 3 December 1969.
Not established: The identity of the killer. The claim that Richard Haefner was responsible rests on circumstantial evidence and the reporting of journalists and authors; he was never charged and died in 2002, so the claim has never been tested in court and must not be presented as a conviction. The suggestion that Betsy knew her attacker is an inference from the nature of the wound, not a proven fact. The Ted Bundy theory has been discounted by law enforcement. Reports differ on the exact time Betsy was pronounced dead, so this article does not state a precise time.
Sources
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Betsy_Aardsma
- https://www.nbcnews.com/dateline/cold-case-spotlight/unsolved-murder-penn-state-student-betsy-aardsma-haunts-community-52-n1284867
- https://onwardstate.com/2025/09/19/penn-state-history-lesson-murder-in-the-stacks/
- https://www.psucollegian.com/news/campus/article_b6280ed6-1a18-11ea-a966-2b1ac6ebcdcb.html
- https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Pattee_Library_PSU.jpg