The Guildford Four: Fifteen Years in Prison for the Guildford Pub Bombings

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

On the evening of 5 October 1974, two bombs exploded in pubs in Guildford, Surrey, killing five people and injuring at least 65. The pubs were popular with British Army personnel from the nearby Pirbright barracks, and the attacks were attributed to the Provisional Irish Republican Army. A year later, four young people were convicted of the bombings and sentenced to life imprisonment. Fifteen years later, the Court of Appeal quashed their convictions. The four — Gerry Conlon, Paul Hill, Patrick Armstrong and Carole Richardson — had not planted the bombs. The case, like that of the Birmingham Six, is now recognised as one of the gravest miscarriages of justice in modern British history.

The bombings

The first bomb exploded at about 8.30 p.m. in the Horse and Groom pub on North Street, Guildford. It killed four soldiers and one civilian: Paul Craig, a plasterer, Guardsmen William Forsyth and John Hunter of the Scots Guards, and Privates Ann Hamilton and Caroline Slater of the Women’s Royal Army Corps. The second bomb exploded at about 9 p.m. in the Seven Stars pub in Swan Lane. The Seven Stars had largely been evacuated after the first blast, and there were no deaths there, although people were injured. In total, five people were killed and 65 were wounded.

The pubs were targeted, the record shows, because they were frequented by soldiers. The bombs were each made from about six pounds of gelignite, fitted with timing devices. The attack was one of a series of Provisional IRA attacks on the British mainland during the Troubles, and it produced the same public and political pressure for arrests that followed the Birmingham pub bombings six weeks later.

The arrests and the trial

In December 1974, police arrested a group of people, mostly young Irish men and women who had been living in London. Four of them — Gerry Conlon, Paul Hill, Patrick Armstrong and Carole Richardson — became known as the Guildford Four. Conlon and Hill were 21 at the time of the trial; Richardson was 17. A second group, the Maguire Seven, was arrested in connection with the same investigation and later convicted of handling explosives said to have been passed to the IRA.

The prosecution case against the Four rested principally on confessions made during police questioning. The Four said the confessions had been obtained by coercion and threats, and that they were false. The defence also argued that the Four had alibis for the evening of the bombings, and that material supporting those alibis had not been disclosed. The jury at the Old Bailey was not persuaded. On 22 October 1975 the Four were convicted of murder and other offences and sentenced to life imprisonment, the mandatory sentence for adults convicted of murder. Hill and Armstrong were also convicted in connection with the Woolwich pub bombing of 7 November 1974.

The evidence unravels

The Four appealed, and their convictions were initially upheld. The campaign for their release continued for fourteen years, led by their families, by their solicitor Gareth Peirce, and by journalists and campaigners who examined the case files. The breakthrough came in 1989, when detectives from Avon and Somerset Constabulary, investigating the handling of the case, found typed notes of Patrick Armstrong’s police interviews that had been heavily edited. Deletions and additions had been made, and the notes had been rearranged.

That discovery was decisive. The edited notes undermined the confessions, and evidence supporting the Four’s alibis had not been disclosed to the defence. In January 1989 the Home Secretary referred the case to the Court of Appeal. The Crown concluded that it could no longer support the convictions as safe, and invited the court to quash them.

Release and reckoning

On 19 October 1989, the Court of Appeal quashed the convictions of the Guildford Four. Lord Lane, the Lord Chief Justice, described the convictions as unsafe and unsatisfactory, and is reported to have concluded that the officers involved “must have lied”. The Four walked free that day, after fifteen years in prison. Paul Hill was returned to Northern Ireland to continue serving a separate life sentence for murder, imposed in Belfast in 1975; that conviction, for the murder of British soldier Brian Shaw, was itself quashed by the Court of Appeal in Belfast in 1994.

The reckoning did not end with the release. In October 1989 the government appointed Sir John May, an Appeal Court judge, to conduct a judicial inquiry into the convictions of the Guildford Four and the Maguire Seven. His interim report, published in July 1990, criticised the trial judge and found improprieties in the handling of scientific evidence, declared the convictions unsound, and recommended referral back to the Court of Appeal. The Maguire Seven’s convictions were quashed in 1991. Giuseppe Conlon, Gerry Conlon’s father and one of the Maguire Seven, had died in prison in 1980, in the third year of his sentence.

In June 2000, Prime Minister Tony Blair became the first person in authority to apologise for the miscarriage of justice, twenty-five years after the wrongful convictions. The apology could not restore the fifteen years the Four had lost, nor bring back Giuseppe Conlon. It did, however, mark a formal acknowledgement by the state that a grave wrong had been done.

An unsolved crime

The quashing of the Guildford Four’s convictions did not solve the Guildford pub bombings. No one has been convicted of planting the bombs. In 1977, four IRA men known as the Balcombe Street Gang told police they were responsible for the Guildford and Woolwich bombings, among other attacks. Their statements were not accepted at the time, and no charges followed on the basis of them. Whether those statements were true is a matter that has been debated ever since; they were not tested in a court, and they should be reported as claims rather than as established fact.

What the record shows

Documented: On 5 October 1974 bombs exploded in the Horse and Groom and the Seven Stars in Guildford, killing five people and injuring 65; the Guildford Four were convicted on 22 October 1975 and sentenced to life imprisonment; their convictions were quashed on 19 October 1989 as unsafe and unsatisfactory; the Maguire Seven’s convictions were quashed in 1991; Paul Hill’s separate Belfast conviction was quashed in 1994; Tony Blair apologised in June 2000.

Disputed or unverified: No one has been convicted of the Guildford pub bombings. The Balcombe Street Gang’s 1977 statements claiming responsibility were never tested in court and are reported here as claims, not proven fact. The victims’ ages vary slightly between sources, so only names are given here.

Sources

Leave a Comment