Whitey Bulger: The Boston Mob Boss Who Had the FBI on His Side

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

James Joseph Bulger Jr. was born on 3 September 1929 in Dorchester, Massachusetts, and grew up in a South Boston housing project. He earned the nickname “Whitey” as a boy, for his pale blond hair. He died on 30 October 2018, aged eighty-nine, in a federal prison in West Virginia, hours after being transferred there. Between those dates he became the most powerful organised crime figure in Boston, spent sixteen years as one of the FBI’s most wanted fugitives, and was convicted in 2013 of racketeering and involvement in eleven murders.

Bulger’s story is not only about a gangster. It is about the failure of the institutions meant to stop him — above all, the FBI office in Boston, which protected him for years in exchange for information about his rivals.

An early career in crime

Bulger was in trouble from his teens, arrested several times on charges ranging from forgery to assault. In 1948 he enlisted in the United States Air Force and was discharged four years later. In 1956 he was convicted of a string of bank robberies committed in three states and sentenced to twenty years in federal prison, serving time at Leavenworth and Alcatraz before being paroled in 1965.

Back in Boston, Bulger became an enforcer, first for mob figure Donald Killeen and then, in the early 1970s, for the Winter Hill Gang — a predominantly Irish-American crime syndicate based in Somerville, just outside Boston, and led by Howie Winter.

The informant deal

In 1975 Bulger agreed to work with the FBI as a “Top Echelon Informant.” His handler was Special Agent John J. Connolly, a fellow son of South Boston who had grown up admiring Bulger. Bulger’s job, in theory, was to provide information about the Patriarca crime family, the Italian-American Mafia that was the Winter Hill Gang’s rival.

The arrangement quickly turned corrupt, and it later became known as the worst informant scandal in FBI history. Instead of the FBI controlling Bulger, Bulger manipulated his handler and other agents. Connolly tipped him off about investigations, helped him avoid indictment, and turned a blind eye to the gang’s crimes, including murder.

In 1979, Winter and several associates were indicted for fixing horse races at tracks up and down the East Coast. Bulger avoided being named in the indictment, and Winter was convicted. The resulting power vacuum allowed Bulger to take over leadership of the Winter Hill Gang, with fellow FBI informant Stephen Flemmi as his top lieutenant.

Bulger always denied that he was an FBI informant. The FBI’s position, supported by extensive documentation, is that he served as an informant from 1975, and the weight of the evidence, including testimony from his own former associates, supports the FBI’s account.

The victims

The human cost of Bulger’s leadership is documented in the charges brought against him. Federal prosecutors indicted him in connection with nineteen murders, based largely on testimony from former associates including Kevin Weeks. Among them was Roger Wheeler, a businessman killed in Oklahoma in 1981 in a dispute over a jai alai company, and Deborah Hussey, a young woman connected to Flemmi.

At his trial, the jury found Bulger guilty of involvement in eleven of the nineteen murders charged. The distinction matters: he was not convicted of all nineteen. But even on the jury’s findings, eleven people lost their lives in connection with his organisation’s activities, and their families waited decades for a trial.

Bulger’s victims also included the communities he extorted. Witnesses were intimidated, investigations were compromised, and for years the people of South Boston lived with the knowledge that the city’s most powerful gangster appeared to be untouchable.

Flight and sixteen years on the run

By the early 1990s, the FBI’s compromised relationship with Bulger had become apparent to local and state police, who, along with the Drug Enforcement Administration, launched a new investigation. In January 1995 Bulger, Flemmi and several others were formally charged with racketeering and extortion. Tipped off in advance by Connolly, Bulger fled before the indictment was unsealed.

He remained at large for sixteen years. In 1999 he was added to the FBI’s Ten Most Wanted Fugitives list, where for years he ranked second only to Osama bin Laden, with a reward of $2 million on his head.

Bulger and his long-time girlfriend, Catherine Greig, eventually settled in Santa Monica, California, where they lived quietly under the assumed names Charles and Carol Gasko. In mid-June 2011 the FBI launched a publicity campaign focused on Greig, circulating her photograph on daytime television and on billboards. A tip generated by that campaign led agents to the apartment building, and on 22 June 2011, Bulger, then eighty-one, was arrested without incident, along with Greig. Greig pleaded guilty in June 2012 to conspiracy to harbour a fugitive and identity fraud, and was sentenced to eight years in prison.

Trial and conviction

Bulger was returned to Boston to face thirty-two counts, including racketeering, extortion, money laundering and weapons charges, and charges in connection with nineteen murders.

The trial began in June 2013 and lasted about two months. On 12 August 2013, the jury found Bulger guilty on thirty-one counts, including both racketeering charges, and found that he had been involved in eleven murders. On 14 November 2013, Judge Denise J. Casper sentenced him to two consecutive life sentences plus five years. He was also ordered to forfeit $25.2 million and pay $19.8 million in restitution.

Connolly, his former handler, had already been convicted in 2002 of federal racketeering and obstruction of justice charges arising from his relationship with Bulger.

Death in prison

Bulger was held at the United States Penitentiary Coleman II in Florida, and was transferred between facilities in October 2018. On 29 October he arrived at the United States Penitentiary, Hazelton, near Bruceton Mills, West Virginia. The following day, 30 October 2018, he was killed by other inmates in his cell, within hours of his arrival. He was eighty-nine and used a wheelchair. The cause of death was blunt force trauma.

In 2022, three men — Fotios Geas, Paul DeCologero and Sean McKinnon — were charged with conspiracy to commit first-degree murder in connection with Bulger’s death. Those are charges, not convictions, and no finding of guilt should be assumed from them.

What the record shows

Whitey Bulger’s career exposes two failures. The first was his own: decades of extortion, racketeering and murder, for which a jury held him responsible. The second was institutional. For years, the FBI’s Boston office treated Bulger as an asset to be protected rather than a criminal to be prosecuted, and that protection allowed him to commit crimes — including murders — that might otherwise have been prevented or punished far sooner.

The victims of that arrangement were not only the eleven people whose murders the jury attributed to his organisation. They included the families who waited sixteen years for a trial, the witnesses who were too frightened to speak, and the public’s trust in federal law enforcement in Boston. Bulger died in prison, as his sentence intended. The questions his case raised about how informants are handled have outlived him.

Sources

Leave a Comment