In the early hours of Christmas morning in 1945, a fire destroyed the home of George and Jennie Sodder in Fayetteville, West Virginia. Six members of the family escaped. Five children — Maurice, Martha, Louis, Jennie and Betty — did not come out of the house, and no trace of them was ever found in the ruins. The state fire marshal ruled that they had died in the fire. Their parents spent the rest of their lives convinced that the children had survived it.
Eighty years on, the case remains one of America’s most painful unsolved mysteries, not because of any single dramatic clue, but because the official account and the family’s account have never been reconciled.
A family in Fayetteville
George Sodder, born Giorgio Soddu, had emigrated from Sardinia as a boy and built a trucking business in Fayetteville, a coal-mining town in Fayette County. He and his wife Jennie, also an Italian immigrant, raised ten children. On the night of 24 December 1945, nine of the ten were at home. The eldest son, Joe, was away serving in the Army.
The five children who would not be seen again were Maurice, aged 14; Martha Lee, aged 12; Louis, aged 9; Jennie Irene, aged 8; and Betty Dolly, aged 5. Some records list Louis as 10; the family’s own accounts and most later reporting give his age as 9. The six who escaped were George and Jennie themselves, their sons John, 23, and George Jr., 16, their daughter Marion, 17, and their youngest daughter Sylvia, then aged 2 or 3.
The evening had been an ordinary Christmas Eve. The children had stayed up late, and the five youngest had gone to sleep upstairs. At about 1:00 a.m. on 25 December, Jennie woke to a noise on the roof and then to smoke. The house was already burning. The staircase to the upper floor was impassable by the time the family reached it. George and his sons tried to reach the children from outside, but the ladder that was normally kept against the house was missing, and the family’s trucks would not start. The house burned to the ground in roughly 45 minutes. The fire department did not arrive until hours later, after a neighbour raised the alarm.
The official account
The West Virginia State Fire Marshal’s office investigated and ruled the cause faulty wiring. On 30 December 1945, less than a week after the fire, death certificates were issued for all five children, recording that they had died in the fire. The local fire chief told the family that the blaze had been hot enough to consume the children’s bodies entirely, leaving nothing behind.
George Sodder disputed that finding from the start, and his objections were specific. He said the house had recently been rewired and the work inspected and approved. He also pointed out that the string of Christmas lights on the house had stayed lit as the fire spread — something he argued would not have happened if the wiring itself had shorted and started the blaze. These are the family’s claims, recorded in their own accounts and in later reporting; the fire marshal’s finding of faulty wiring was never formally withdrawn.
Other details troubled the family and later writers. The family’s ladder was eventually found thrown down an embankment some distance from the house. The telephone line had been cut — a fact that required someone to climb a utility pole to reach it. Neither fact proves arson, and neither was explained by the official investigation, which did not treat the fire as a crime scene in its early stages.
The search for remains
When the ashes cooled, George sifted through them for days. He found no bones, no teeth, and no personal effects belonging to the children. Jennie later spoke to a crematorium worker, who told her that bones survive even after bodies are burned at very high temperatures for two hours — far longer than the Sodder house had burned.
In 1949, the family hired a pathologist from Washington, D.C., Dr. Oscar B. Hunter, to supervise a fresh excavation of the site. The dig produced a small number of bone fragments. They were sent to the Smithsonian Institution, where anthropologist Marshall T. Newman examined them. His report, dated 28 September 1949, concluded that the fragments were the lumbar vertebrae of a single person aged about 16 to 22 — older than Maurice, the eldest missing child, who had been 14. The bones also showed no sign of exposure to fire. Newman concluded that they had most likely arrived at the site in the fill dirt George had used to cover the basement when creating a memorial. The Smithsonian returned the fragments in September 1949; their current location is unknown.
No remains identifiable as any of the five children have ever been recovered.
The billboard and the later claims
In 1952, George and Jennie erected a large billboard along Route 16 near Fayetteville, carrying photographs of the five children and the question: “What was their fate: kidnapped, murdered or are they still alive?” They offered a reward of $5,000, later raised to $10,000. The billboard stayed up for nearly four decades, maintained until Jennie’s death in 1989 — some accounts say it was taken down in the early 1990s.
Over the years, the family received reports of sightings and tips from across the country, and hired private investigators. None led to any of the children. In 1968, the family received a photograph in the post of a young man they believed to be Louis, grown up. That identification was never verified by any authority, and the photograph’s origin was never established. It remains a family claim, not a documented fact. The family also suspected the fire had been set deliberately, possibly in retaliation for George’s outspoken criticism of the fascist government of his native Italy. That suspicion — sometimes described in later writing as a Mafia theory — was never supported by evidence, and no person was ever charged in connection with the fire or the children’s disappearance. The FBI declined to take jurisdiction in 1947, in the absence of a state-level request.
George Sodder died in 1969, Jennie in 1989. Neither ever accepted that their children had died in the fire. Sylvia Sodder Paxton, the last surviving member of the original family, died in 2021. The family never rebuilt the house; the site became a memorial garden.
What the record shows
The documented facts are these: a fire destroyed the Sodder home in the early hours of 25 December 1945; six people escaped and five children were never seen again; the state fire marshal attributed the fire to faulty wiring and death certificates were issued on 30 December 1945; no remains identifiable as the five children were ever found; and a 1949 Smithsonian examination of bone fragments from the site found them to belong to a single older person, with no sign of fire exposure.
Disputed or unproven are the central questions: whether the fire was accidental or deliberately set, whether the children died in it, and what happened to them if they did not. The ladder, the cut telephone line, the trucks that would not start, and the Christmas lights that stayed on are all part of the record as reported observations and family claims. None of them has ever been shown to prove what happened that night. The five Sodder children remain missing, and the case remains unresolved.