On the evening of Friday 24 February 1978, five young men from Yuba City, California, drove about fifty miles north to Chico to watch a college basketball game. They were friends, teammates on a recreational basketball team, and regulars at the Gateway Projects, a community programme for adults with developmental disabilities. They never came home.
Their car was found days later, abandoned on a remote mountain road in the Plumas National Forest, far from any route they could have taken home. Four of the five men were found dead in June, after the snow melted. The fifth, Gary Mathias, has never been found. The case is often called the “American Dyatlov Pass”, after the 1959 Soviet incident in which nine hikers died in freezing conditions — a comparison made by journalists and writers, not by investigators.
The five men
The five were Jack Madruga, 30, the driver; Bill Sterling, 29; Ted Weiher, 32; Jackie Huett, 24; and Gary Mathias, 25. All five had mild intellectual disabilities or psychiatric conditions that affected how they handled unfamiliar and stressful situations. Four of them knew one another through the Gateway Projects programme in Yuba City and played together on its basketball team, the Gateway Gators, who had a tournament game the next day.
Mathias was the only one of the five with a diagnosis of schizophrenia. He had been discharged from the Army on psychiatric grounds and was being treated as an outpatient. Those who knew him described his treatment as successful at the time.
The men lived semi-independently and were known in their community as “the boys”, though all five were grown men in their twenties and thirties. Their families were close to them and reported them missing promptly when they did not return.
The night of 24 February 1978
On the evening of 24 February, the five drove in Madruga’s 1969 Mercury Montego to the California State University, Chico gymnasium to watch a basketball game between UC Davis and Chico State. They left the game at about 9:50 p.m. Their last confirmed sighting was at about 10:00 p.m. at a convenience store in Chico, where they bought snacks and drinks.
The drive from Chico to Yuba City is a flat, straightforward hour south on Highway 99. The men never made it. When they had not returned home by the following morning, their families contacted the police.
The abandoned car
On 28 February, four days after the men were last seen, Madruga’s Montego was found on a Forest Service logging road in the Plumas National Forest, near Rogers Cow Camp, at an elevation of about 4,400 feet. The car was far from the men’s route home — reports differ on the distance, with some putting it about forty miles off their route and others about seventy miles — and deep in snow-covered mountain country the men had no reason to visit.
The car itself presented a puzzle. It was undamaged and stuck in snow, but not badly stuck; police believed five men could have pushed it out. The keys were in the ignition, according to most accounts — although at least one later account says the keys were gone, a discrepancy the record does not resolve. Reports also differ on the fuel level, describing it as between a quarter and a half tank. When police started the car, it ran at once, with no sign of mechanical failure. Snow drifts four to six feet high surrounded it. There was no sign of a struggle and no indication of where the men had gone.
How five men who knew only the flat valley roads around Yuba City ended up on a mountain logging road in winter has never been established. The most widely supported explanation is a wrong turn in darkness or fog, followed by a decision to abandon the car and walk on. That is an inference drawn from the circumstances, not a documented fact.
The search and the discovery
Searches of the forest in February and March 1978 found nothing. The snow was deep and the Plumas National Forest covers more than a million acres.
On 4 June 1978, after the snow had melted, a group of motorcyclists came upon a United States Forest Service trailer at Rogers Cow Camp, about nineteen to twenty miles from where the car had been left. Inside, on a bed, wrapped in sheets, was the body of Ted Weiher. He had lost nearly half his body weight. From the growth of his beard, investigators estimated that he had lived for roughly eight to thirteen weeks after the men were last seen — surviving, in other words, for as long as three months.
What made Weiher’s death so difficult to understand was what surrounded him. The trailer and a nearby locker held enough dehydrated food to feed all five men for months, along with matches, firewood, heavy forestry clothing and a butane heater with fuel. None of it had been used. Weiher died of starvation and hypothermia, in a shelter stocked with the means to survive. Why he did not use them has never been explained. Modern forensic reassessments have suggested that hypothermia, confusion and the men’s cognitive difficulties together may explain decisions that look inexplicable from the outside. That remains an interpretation, not a proven account.
Over the following days, the remains of the other three men were found. Bill Sterling and Jack Madruga were found on opposite sides of the road about eleven miles from the car, and Jackie Huett’s remains were found in the woods about two miles from the trailer. Only bones remained, as a result of scavenging animals. All three were found to have died of hypothermia and exposure.
Gary Mathias was never found. Only his shoes were found, near the trailer. No remains, no belongings and no confirmed trace of him have ever been recovered.
What the record shows
The documented record is this: on 24 February 1978, five men from Yuba County — Gary Mathias, 25; Ted Weiher, 32; Jack Madruga, 30; Bill Sterling, 29; and Jackie Huett, 24 — drove to a basketball game in Chico and did not return. Their car, Madruga’s 1969 Mercury Montego, was found on 28 February on a remote road in the Plumas National Forest, undamaged, with no sign of mechanical failure. On 4 June 1978, Weiher’s body was found in a Forest Service trailer about twenty miles from the car; he had survived for weeks and died of starvation and hypothermia despite food, fuel and clothing being available and unused. The remains of Madruga, Sterling and Huett were found nearby in the following days; all three had died of hypothermia. Gary Mathias has never been found.
No foul play has been established in the case, and the deaths were attributed to hypothermia and exposure. The central questions — why the men drove into the mountains, why they left a working car, why Weiher did not use the supplies in the trailer, and what happened to Gary Mathias — remain unanswered. The case is formally closed except for the ongoing search for Mathias, and the Yuba County and Butte County sheriff’s offices still list him as missing.