In the spring of 1946, the twin cities of Texarkana — one in Texas, one in Arkansas, divided by a state line running down the middle of State Line Avenue — were living through the first hopeful months after the Second World War. Servicemen were coming home, and young people were going out again on Friday and Saturday nights. Then, over ten weeks, an attacker struck four times, always after dark, always against couples in quiet places. Five people were killed and three were wounded. The attacker was never identified.
The press called the crimes the Moonlight Murders and the attacker the Phantom Killer. The name stuck, helped by the 1976 film The Town That Dreaded Sundown. The record underneath is smaller and sadder: eight named people, four attacks, no murder charge.
The first attack: February 22, 1946
Shortly before midnight on Friday, February 22, 1946, Jimmy Hollis, 25, and Mary Jeanne Larey, 19, parked on a secluded road just outside Texarkana, Texas, after seeing a film together. A man wearing a white cloth mask — described as resembling a pillowcase with eyeholes cut out — appeared at the driver’s window and ordered them out of the car at gunpoint.
Hollis was struck on the head with the firearm and suffered multiple skull fractures. Larey was also struck, then assaulted, before she escaped on foot and ran about half a mile to a nearby house to call the police. Hollis regained consciousness and flagged down a passing motorist. Both survived. Larey was treated overnight for a minor head wound; Hollis spent several days in hospital.
The two gave investigators differing descriptions of the attacker. Both agreed he was about six feet tall. Larey said she could see beneath the mask and described him as a light-skinned Black man; Hollis, blinded by a flashlight, described a tanned white man of about thirty. Police repeatedly challenged Larey’s account and, at times, suggested the couple knew their attacker and were protecting him — a claim for which no evidence was ever produced.
The first double murder: March 24
A month later, on the morning of Sunday, March 24, a passing motorist found a parked car on a lovers’ lane about 100 yards south of US Highway 67 West in Bowie County, Texas. Inside were Richard Griffin, 29, a Navy veteran recently returned from the war, and his girlfriend of about six weeks, Polly Ann Moore, 17. Both had been shot in the back of the head with a .32-caliber pistol. Their pockets had been turned inside out, and blood on the ground near the car suggested they had been killed outside it and placed back inside. No pathologist’s examination of either body is recorded, and a rumour that Moore had been assaulted is refuted in modern accounts.
The second double murder: April 14
In the early hours of Sunday, April 14, Paul Martin, 16, picked up Betty Jo Booker, 15, after a musical performance at a VFW club in Texarkana. Martin played saxophone in the school orchestra. The two were driving home when they were attacked.
Martin’s body was found at about 6:30 that morning beside North Park Road, shot four times. Booker’s body was found by a search party at about 11:30 a.m., nearly two miles away behind a tree, shot twice. Martin’s car was found parked outside Spring Lake Park, about three miles from Booker’s body, with the keys still in the ignition. The weapon was the same .32 semi-automatic Colt pistol used in the Griffin-Moore murders. Investigators said both teenagers had put up a struggle.
The farmhouse attack: May 3
The final attack broke the pattern. On the evening of Friday, May 3, Virgil Starks, 37, was sitting in an armchair reading the newspaper in his farmhouse on a 500-acre farm off Highway 67 East, about ten miles northeast of Texarkana, in Miller County, Arkansas. His wife Katie, 36, was in another room. The attacker fired twice through a closed double window, striking Virgil in the back of the head and killing him. Katie, hearing the glass break, came to the room and was shot twice in the face from the same window.
Wounded and blinded by her own blood, Katie fled barefoot to a neighbour’s home, where she collapsed after gasping that her husband was dead. She survived. The weapon in this attack was a .22-caliber firearm, not the .32 used in the two double murders, and the victims were a married couple at home rather than young people parked on a country road. Whether the Starks attack was committed by the same person as the earlier ones has been debated by investigators and writers ever since; it is counted among the Phantom’s crimes, but the link is not certain.
A town in panic
The attacks, reported nationally, threw Texarkana into fear. Residents armed themselves and locked their doors at dusk. Shops sold out of guns, ammunition and locks. Police patrolled in force, and the investigation drew in city and county officers, the Texas Rangers, the Arkansas State Police and the FBI. Texas Ranger Captain Manuel T. Gonzaullas became the public face of the inquiry, at one point using teenagers as decoys in parked cars. More than 200 people were questioned and a similar number of false leads checked. None of it produced a murder charge.
The one major suspect was Youell Swinney, a career criminal with a record of car theft, counterfeiting, burglary and assault. He was arrested in July 1946, and his wife at first gave statements implicating him. She then refused to testify, and prosecutors decided against pursuing murder charges. Swinney was instead convicted of car theft and, as a repeat offender, sentenced to life imprisonment in 1947. Two lead investigators believed him guilty, and a 2014 book by James Presley, nephew of Sheriff Bill Presley, concluded Swinney was the killer. That remains an argument, not a verdict. Swinney died in 1994, never charged with any of the murders.
What the record shows
What is documented is this: between February 22 and May 3, 1946, eight people were attacked in four incidents around Texarkana, and five of them died — Richard Griffin, Polly Ann Moore, Paul Martin, Betty Jo Booker and Virgil Starks. Three survived: Jimmy Hollis, Mary Jeanne Larey and Katie Starks. The first three attacks targeted couples in parked cars on quiet roads; the fourth targeted a married couple inside their farmhouse. A .32-caliber pistol linked the two double murders; the Starks attack involved a .22-caliber firearm.
Disputed or unresolved: whether all four attacks were the work of one person, since the Starks attack differs in victim type, location and weapon; the attacker’s appearance, on which the two surviving witnesses of the first attack disagreed and were themselves doubted by police; and the guilt of Youell Swinney, the prime suspect, who was never charged with the murders and whose wife’s statements were withdrawn. The case remains officially open and unsolved. What endures is not a masked figure from a film, but the five names of the dead and the three survivors who lived with what happened on those spring nights.
Sources
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texarkana_Moonlight_Murders
- http://encyclopediaofarkansas.net/encyclopedia/entry-detail.aspx?entryID=4478&type=Time+Period&item=World+War+II+through+the+Faubus+Era+%281941+-+1967%29&parent&grandparent
- https://crimesolverscentral.com/serialkillers/1540
- https://listverse.com/2015/09/02/10-unsolved-lovers-lane-murders/