In the summer of 1987, a courtroom in Lyon hosted one of the most closely watched trials in French history. The defendant was Klaus Barbie, a former Gestapo chief who had terrorised the city during the Second World War. He was 73 years old, frail, and bald, a long way from the feared officer the people of Lyon remembered. For eight weeks, survivors took the stand to describe what he had done to them four decades earlier. On 4 July 1987, the jury found him guilty of crimes against humanity, and the judge sentenced him to life in prison. It was the first conviction of its kind in France.
The Butcher of Lyon
Niklaus Barbie was born in Bad Godesberg, Germany, on 25 October 1913. He joined the SS in 1935 and, by the time Germany occupied France, he was an officer of the Sicherheitsdienst, the SS intelligence service. In November 1942, after German forces moved into the previously unoccupied south of France, Barbie was posted to Lyon as head of the local Gestapo. He set up his headquarters at the Hôtel Terminus, where prisoners were brought for interrogation.
Lyon was a centre of the French Resistance, and Barbie made it his business to break it. He personally took part in the torture of prisoners, earning the nickname the “Butcher of Lyon”. Among his captives was Jean Moulin, a leading Resistance figure. Moulin was arrested in Caluire, outside Lyon, on 21 June 1943, and died after days of torture without betraying his comrades.
The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum estimates that Barbie was responsible for the execution or murder of more than 4,000 people and the deportation of some 7,500 Jews from the Lyon region, most of them to their deaths at Auschwitz. His most notorious single act came on 6 April 1944, when he led a raid on a children’s home at Izieu, a village east of Lyon, where 44 Jewish children and seven adults were hiding. All of them were deported. The children were sent to Auschwitz and murdered on arrival. In August 1944, weeks before Lyon was liberated, Barbie arranged a final deportation convoy of more than 600 Jews and Resistance fighters.
The long road to the dock
Barbie had already been tried in his absence. French courts convicted him of war crimes in 1952 and again in 1954, sentencing him to death both times. But he was not in France. After the war, he had worked for the United States Army Counterintelligence Corps in Germany, and in 1951 he fled to South America with the help of American intelligence contacts. He settled in Bolivia under the name Klaus Altmann, became a businessman, and lived openly for decades.
It took a campaign by Nazi hunters, above all Serge and Beate Klarsfeld, to bring him back. Barbie was arrested in La Paz in January 1983, and the Bolivian government expelled him to France the following month. He arrived in Lyon in chains, forty years after he had left it as a conqueror.
The prosecution faced a problem. Under French law, ordinary war crimes were subject to a statute of limitations, and Barbie’s 1950s convictions could not simply be revived. The case therefore had to be built on crimes against humanity, a category with no time limit. The charges were drawn from three episodes: the roundup of Jews at the Lyon offices of the Union Générale des Israélites de France in February 1943, the deportation of the children of Izieu, and the final deportation convoy of August 1944. Controversially, Barbie was not charged over Jean Moulin’s arrest and torture, because those acts were classified as war crimes, and the time limit had expired.
The trial
The trial opened on 11 May 1987 in the historic Palais de Justice in Lyon, before Judge André Cerdini. The chief prosecutor was Pierre Truche. Barbie’s defence was led by Jacques Vergès, a lawyer famous for defending unpopular causes, who argued that France itself had committed crimes in its colonies and had no right to judge his client. Barbie himself said little. In his final statement he insisted, “I never committed the roundup in Izieu,” and added that he had fought the Resistance “with toughness, but that was war, and the war is over.”
The heart of the trial was the testimony of the survivors. Lea Feldblum, a caretaker at the Izieu home and the only one of those deported from it to survive, described the morning of the raid. Sabine Zlatin, who had founded the home, was 80 years old when she testified. A woman tortured by Barbie at 13 told the court how he had tried to force her to reveal where her family was hiding. In total, more than a hundred witnesses and civil parties took part, and the trial was televised — the first in French history to be filmed in full for the record.
The verdict and what it meant
After eight weeks, the jury deliberated through the night. Shortly after midnight on 4 July 1987, it returned its verdict: guilty. Judge Cerdini sentenced Barbie to life imprisonment, the maximum penalty under French law. There was applause in the courtroom and cheering outside.
Barbie died in his prison cell in Lyon on 25 September 1991, aged 77, of leukaemia and prostate cancer. He had served four years of his sentence.
The trial mattered beyond the fate of one man. It established in French law that crimes against humanity have no statute of limitations, and it forced France to confront, in public and on television, the details of the occupation and the deportations. For the survivors who testified, it was the first time a French court had heard their stories in full and believed them. The courtroom in Lyon where Barbie was tried now carries a plaque marking the first conviction for crimes against humanity in France.
What is documented — and what is not
Documented: Klaus Barbie headed the Gestapo in Lyon from November 1942 to 1944, with headquarters at the Hôtel Terminus. He ordered the raid on the children’s home at Izieu on 6 April 1944, in which 44 children and seven adults were seized and deported; the children were murdered at Auschwitz. He was convicted in absentia in 1952 and 1954, lived in Bolivia as Klaus Altmann, was extradited to France in 1983, and was tried in Lyon from 11 May to 4 July 1987. He was found guilty of crimes against humanity and sentenced to life imprisonment. He died in prison in Lyon on 25 September 1991.
Unverified or unproven: The precise number of people Barbie was personally responsible for killing — estimates of more than 4,000 murders and 7,500 deportations are the figures used by historians and the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, but no exact count exists. Whether Barbie was personally present at every roundup attributed to him — the trial convicted him on the charges brought, which covered three specific episodes, not his entire record in Lyon. Claims that he acted on orders from Berlin in the Izieu raid — no written order has been found.
Sources
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Klaus_Barbie
- http://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/nikolaus-klaus-barbie-the-butcher-of-lyon
- https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/history/barbie-tried-nazi-war-crimes
- https://www.encyclopedia.com/religion/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/barbie-nikolaus-klaus-trial