Gary Ray Bowles, the I-95 Killer

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

In the spring and autumn of 1994, six men were killed in four states along America’s east coast. The victims had little in common except this: each had shown kindness to a drifter named Gary Ray Bowles, offering him a place to stay, a meal, or work. Bowles repaid that kindness with murder, then stole his victims’ cars and credit cards and drove on to the next state. Because so many of the killings happened near Interstate 95, the press called him the I-95 Killer. He was caught within three days of being placed on the FBI’s Ten Most Wanted list, confessed to all six murders, and spent 23 years on death row before his execution in 2019.

Bowles was born on 25 January 1962. By his early thirties he had already served two prison terms: six years after a 1982 conviction for beating and sexually assaulting a girlfriend, and four more years for stealing an elderly woman’s purse. Released from prison in early 1994, he drifted along the east coast, living rough and taking casual work. The men he met and killed were, in several cases, gay men who had offered him temporary shelter. That pattern — trust offered, then betrayed — is what tied the separate cases together.

Six Murders in Eight Months

The first known victim was John Hardy Roberts, 59, an insurance adjuster in Daytona Beach, Florida, who had offered Bowles a temporary place to live. On 15 March 1994 Bowles attacked Roberts inside his home, striking him with a lamp, strangling and gagging him. He then stole Roberts’ car, money, wallet and credit cards and drove north. A friend who went to check on Roberts found his body. Inside the house, investigators found a probation report bearing Bowles’ name — the first break in the case.

A month later, on 14 April 1994, David Jarman was found dead in his basement apartment in Wheaton, Maryland, beaten and strangled. His car and financial cards were gone. In Savannah, Georgia, 72-year-old Milton Bradley, a disabled Second World War veteran, was reported missing by his family and found dead on a golf course on 5 May 1994, beaten and strangled, with leaves and dirt stuffed into his mouth. Days later, in Atlanta, 47-year-old Alverson Carter Jr. was found stabbed to death in his home, dead for several days before he was discovered.

The fifth victim was Albert Morris, 37, a convenience store owner in Hilliard, Florida, killed on 18 May 1994 inside his home. His parents found his body the following day. Then, for six months, the killings stopped. Bowles had moved on, and the cases in four separate jurisdictions were only slowly being connected.

The Last Murder and the Arrest

The final known victim was Walter Jamelle “Jay” Hinton, a florist in Jacksonville Beach, Florida, who had agreed to help Bowles move from Georgia to a new home. On 16 November 1994 Bowles attacked Hinton as he slept, striking him with a 40-pound concrete stepping stone, then strangling him and forcing a rag into his airway. Hinton’s death brought the case to a head: by then investigators had linked the killings, and on 19 November 1994 Bowles was placed on the FBI’s Ten Most Wanted Fugitives list as the 438th person to be so listed.

His time on the list lasted three days. On 22 November 1994, officers in Jacksonville Beach found him at a day-labour employment office, working under the assumed name Timothy Whitfield. He first claimed to be Whitfield, then admitted his real identity — and confessed to all six murders.

Conviction and Execution

Bowles was tried in Florida. In 1996 he was convicted of Hinton’s murder and sentenced to death. He was also convicted of the murders of John Hardy Roberts in Volusia County and Albert Morris in Nassau County, receiving life sentences for those killings. His appeals ran for more than two decades, and his death sentence was upheld.

On 22 August 2019, Bowles was executed by lethal injection at Florida State Prison near Raiford, aged 57. He was pronounced dead at 10:58 p.m. He was the last person executed in Florida until February 2023. He never admitted to any murder beyond the six, and no other killing has been formally linked to him.

What Is Documented — and What Is Not

Documented: Gary Ray Bowles was born on 25 January 1962. He killed six men between March and November 1994: John Hardy Roberts, 59, in Daytona Beach on 15 March 1994; David Jarman in Wheaton, Maryland, on 14 April 1994; Milton Bradley, 72, in Savannah, Georgia, found on 5 May 1994; Alverson Carter Jr., 47, in Atlanta, found on 13 May 1994; Albert Morris, 37, in Hilliard, Florida, on 18 May 1994; and Walter “Jay” Hinton in Jacksonville Beach on 16 November 1994. In each case Bowles stole the victim’s car, money or cards. He was placed on the FBI’s Ten Most Wanted list on 19 November 1994 and arrested on 22 November 1994 in Jacksonville Beach, where he was working under the name Timothy Whitfield. He confessed to all six murders. He was convicted of Hinton’s murder in 1996 and sentenced to death, and convicted of the Roberts and Morris murders, receiving life sentences. He was executed by lethal injection on 22 August 2019 at Florida State Prison, aged 57. He had served two earlier prison terms, including six years for a 1982 assault conviction.

Not documented / unverified: Sources differ on some details of the victims’ ages and dates. Jarman is given as 38 or 39, Morris as 37 or 38, and Hinton as 42 or 47. Some reports date Roberts’ murder to 14 March rather than 15 March, and Jarman’s body as found on 13 April rather than 14 April. Reports also differ on whether Morris was shot as well as beaten and strangled. The Wikipedia victim list gives the total as “6+”, and some accounts suggest Bowles may have killed others, but no additional murder has been proven or charged, and Bowles confessed to six. The nickname “I-95 Killer” reflects that most victims lived near the highway, not that every killing happened beside it.

Sources

Leave a Comment