The fall of a Hollywood king
For thirty years, Harvey Weinstein was one of the most powerful men in Hollywood. As the co-founder of Miramax and then the Weinstein Company, he produced films that won dozens of Academy Awards, and his approval could make or break a career. Actresses, assistants and employees who crossed him knew the price. In October 2017, two long investigations — one in The New York Times, one in The New Yorker — published the accounts of dozens of women who said Weinstein had harassed or assaulted them over decades. Within days he was fired from his own company, expelled from the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, and the phrase “#MeToo” became a global movement.
But the movement was not a trial. The question that followed the headlines was a harder one: could a court convict him? The answer came in two trials, five years apart, in the same Manhattan courthouse — and the second trial nearly ended the same way the first one had begun, with nothing at all.
The first trial
Weinstein was arrested in May 2018 and charged in New York with rape and sexual assault. The case rested on two women: Miriam Haley, a former production assistant on the television show Project Runway, who said Weinstein had assaulted her in his Manhattan apartment in 2006, and Jessica Mann, an aspiring actress, who said Weinstein had raped her in a hotel room in 2013. A third woman, the actress Annabella Sciorra, testified about an alleged assault in the early 1990s, though the charge connected to her was too old to prosecute on its own.
The trial opened in January 2020 in Manhattan Supreme Court, before Justice James Burke. The defence argued that the encounters were consensual, and pointed to friendly emails and meetings between Weinstein and the women after the alleged assaults. The prosecution argued that the pattern — a powerful producer summoning young women to hotel rooms and apartments, then using his position to overpower them — was the crime itself.
On 24 February 2020, the jury found Weinstein guilty of a criminal sexual act against Haley and of third-degree rape against Mann. He was acquitted of the two most serious counts, predatory sexual assault, which would have carried a potential life sentence. On 11 March 2020, Justice Burke sentenced him to 23 years in prison. Weinstein, then 67 and using a walker after back surgery, was taken into custody. The verdict was widely described as a landmark for the #MeToo movement: one of the most powerful men in the film industry had been convicted by a jury of his peers.
A conviction overturned
The verdict did not hold. In April 2024, New York’s highest court, the Court of Appeals, overturned the conviction by a vote of four to three. The majority held that Justice Burke had made a serious error: he had allowed several women to testify about alleged assaults that were not part of the charges — the so-called “prior bad acts” witnesses, including Annabella Sciorra — and that this testimony had unfairly prejudiced the jury against Weinstein. The court did not say Weinstein was innocent. It said he had not received a fair trial, and ordered a new one.
The ruling stunned the women who had testified, and it reopened the central question of the case. Prosecutors in Manhattan announced that they would try Weinstein again. But the retrial would be a different case: the rules on what the jury could hear had changed, and the prosecution would have to prove its case without the witnesses whose testimony had helped convict him the first time.
The retrial
The retrial opened in April 2025, again in Manhattan, this time before Justice Curtis Farber. The charges were similar but not identical. The prosecution again charged Weinstein over Haley and Mann, and added a new complainant: Kaja Sokola, a former model who said Weinstein had assaulted her in 2002, when she was sixteen. Weinstein pleaded not guilty to all charges.
The trial lasted about six weeks. Haley testified again, describing the 2006 assault in detail. Mann testified again. Sokola testified for the first time. The defence again argued that the encounters were consensual, and again pointed to the women’s continued contact with Weinstein afterwards. The jury deliberated for days. At one point, the foreperson told the judge that one juror had refused to continue deliberating, and the judge replaced him. On 11 June 2025, the jury returned its verdicts: guilty of a first-degree criminal sexual act against Haley; not guilty of a criminal sexual act against Sokola; and no verdict on the third-degree rape charge against Mann — the jury could not agree.
The result was narrower than the first trial, but it was still a conviction. Prosecutors tried the Mann charge a third time in 2026, but that jury also deadlocked, in May 2026, and prosecutors then dropped the charge after Mann said she could not endure testifying again. On 23 September 2026, Justice Farber sentenced Weinstein to 15 years in prison for the Haley conviction, with five years of supervised release. Prosecutors had asked for twenty years; the defence had asked for far less, citing his age and poor health. Weinstein, now 74, has said he will appeal.
The California case
New York was only half of Weinstein’s legal trouble. In December 2022, a Los Angeles jury convicted him of rape and sexual assault against a woman identified in court as Jane Doe 1, an actress and model who said Weinstein had attacked her in a Beverly Hills hotel room in 2013. He was acquitted on one count and the jury deadlocked on three others. In February 2023, a Los Angeles judge sentenced him to 16 years in prison, to run after his New York sentence.
That California conviction has also been through the appeals courts. In June 2026, a California appeals court upheld the conviction but vacated the 16-year sentence, ordering a resentencing. Whatever the final numbers, Weinstein — who has denied raping or sexually assaulting anyone — will spend the rest of his life in prison unless an appeal succeeds.
What the case changed
The Weinstein trials matter for reasons that go beyond one man. The first trial showed that a jury could convict a powerful figure on the testimony of the women he was accused of assaulting, even when there was no physical evidence and the encounters had happened years earlier. The overturning of that conviction showed the limits of that approach: when a court allows testimony about conduct that is not charged, an appeals court may throw the whole verdict out. The retrial showed that the case could still be won on narrower ground — one count, one woman, proved beyond reasonable doubt.
For the women who testified, the process was gruelling. Haley testified at two trials, six years apart. Mann testified at two trials and was prepared for a third before prosecutors dropped the charge. Their persistence is the reason the case ended in a conviction at all. And for the law, the case has become a case study in how courts handle sexual assault prosecutions in the age of #MeToo: how much of a defendant’s history a jury should hear, and what happens when it hears too much.
The reporting that started it
The case against Weinstein began not with the police, but with journalism. On 5 October 2017, The New York Times published an investigation by Jodi Kantor and Megan Twohey, reporting that Weinstein had reached settlements with at least eight women over harassment claims, some dating back decades. Five days later, The New Yorker published Ronan Farrow’s investigation, in which thirteen women accused Weinstein of sexual harassment or assault, including three who said he had raped them. Within days, more than eighty women had come forward publicly.
The response was immediate. On 8 October 2017, the Weinstein Company fired him. On 14 October, the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences expelled him — only the second person ever expelled, after the actor Carmine Caridi. The hashtag #MeToo, coined years earlier by the activist Tarana Burke, became a global rallying cry, and the allegations against Weinstein became the defining case of a movement that toppled powerful men in Hollywood, media, politics and business.
The criminal case that followed was, in a sense, narrower than the public story. Prosecutors could charge only a small number of the allegations — those within the statute of limitations, with identifiable complainants willing to testify. The gap between the public record and the courtroom record is the reason the trial mattered so much: it was the test of whether the movement’s most famous target could actually be convicted in a court of law.
What is documented — and what is not
Documented: Harvey Weinstein was convicted in New York in February 2020 of a criminal sexual act against Miriam Haley and third-degree rape against Jessica Mann, and sentenced to 23 years in prison. In April 2024, the New York Court of Appeals overturned the conviction, ruling that testimony about uncharged allegations had unfairly prejudiced the trial. At a 2025 retrial, a jury convicted Weinstein of a first-degree criminal sexual act against Haley, acquitted him on a charge involving Kaja Sokola, and deadlocked on the rape charge involving Mann; a further trial on that charge in 2026 also deadlocked, and prosecutors dropped it. On 23 September 2026, Weinstein was sentenced to 15 years in prison. In California, he was convicted in December 2022 of rape and sexual assault and sentenced to 16 years; in June 2026 an appeals court upheld the conviction but vacated the sentence, ordering resentencing. Weinstein has denied the charges and has said he will appeal.
Unverified or unproven: The full number of women who say Weinstein assaulted or harassed them — dozens have spoken publicly, but only a small number of allegations were ever charged or tested in court. Claims about what Weinstein’s company knew about his conduct rest on reporting and civil litigation, not on criminal findings. Whether the California resentencing will change the length of his sentence has not yet been decided.
Sources
https://www.usatoday.com/story/entertainment/celebrities/2026/09/23/harvey-weinstein-sentenced-to-15-years-sexual-assault-retrial/86600123007/
https://www.lawcommentary.com/articles/harvey-weinstein-15-year-new-york-sentence-california-resentencing
https://www.justjared.com/2026/09/23/harvey-weinstein-sentenced-15-years-prison-new-york-sexual-assault/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harvey_Weinstein_sexual_abuse_cases