On the afternoon of Sunday 6 December 2009, Susan Powell had a meal of pancakes and eggs with a friend at her home in West Valley City, Utah. She was 28 years old, a mother of two small boys, and by every account a devoted parent who would never have walked out on her children. She put the boys to bed that evening. It was the last time anyone outside her own family saw her alive.
By the next morning, Susan was gone. Her husband said she had stayed behind while he took the boys on a spontaneous camping trip in the middle of a freezing desert night. The police did not believe him. Nobody who knew Susan believed him either. Yet more than sixteen years later, no one has ever been charged in her disappearance, and her body has never been found. What happened instead was a second tragedy, two years later, that took the lives of both her sons and destroyed any chance of learning the truth from the one man who knew it.
A Sunday in December
Susan Marie Cox was born on 16 October 1981 in Alamogordo, New Mexico, and raised in Puyallup, Washington. She met Joshua Powell at church, and the couple married in April 2001. They settled in West Valley City, a suburb of Salt Lake City, where Susan worked as a stockbroker. Their sons, Charles and Braden, were born in 2005 and 2007.
Friends and family later described a marriage under strain. Susan had written in a journal and told friends that she was unhappy, and that she feared for her safety if the marriage ended. She had also begun making quiet plans, putting money aside and talking to a lawyer about divorce. None of that was public knowledge in December 2009. To the outside world, the Powells were an ordinary young family.
On 6 December, Susan took the boys to church in the morning while Josh was at work. She came home in the late afternoon, cooked dinner, and shared a meal with a friend who visited the house. The friend left in the late afternoon. That was the last confirmed sighting of Susan Powell by anyone other than her husband and children.
The camping trip that made no sense
When the boys were not dropped off at daycare the next morning, and neither Susan nor Josh turned up at work or answered their phones, relatives called the police. Later that day, Josh Powell returned home with the two boys, then aged four and two. He told police a story that investigators would pick apart for years.
He said he had woken up around midnight, argued with Susan about money, and decided on the spur of the moment to take the boys camping in the desert west of Salt Lake City. The boys were still in their pyjamas. The temperature that night was well below freezing, and snow lay on the ground. Josh said Susan had stayed at home. He could not explain why he would take two small children into the desert in the middle of the night, in winter, without telling anyone.
The police searched the area he named, around Simpson Springs in Tooele County, and found nothing. They searched the Powell home and found traces of Susan’s blood. They found her mobile phone in Josh’s car. They noted that a couch and a fan were missing from the house, and that the home had been cleaned in a way that suggested someone had tried to remove evidence. Within a week, on 14 December, Josh Powell was named a person of interest in his wife’s disappearance. He was never charged.
The boys, meanwhile, began saying things that troubled their grandparents. Charlie, the older boy, told them that his mother had gone with them on the camping trip, and that she had been in the boot of the car. A child’s account, offered in fragments, is not evidence a court can easily use. But it was one more reason investigators believed Susan had not stayed at home that night.
A husband under suspicion
Josh Powell was, by the police’s own account, less than cooperative. He hired a lawyer, refused a polygraph, and gave inconsistent accounts of the night. Investigators also began looking at his family. His father, Steven Powell, lived nearby in Washington State, and a search of Steven’s home in 2011 uncovered voyeuristic recordings of Susan and other women. Steven was arrested in September 2011 on voyeurism and child pornography charges, and convicted in May 2012.
Investigators also focused on Josh’s brother, Michael Powell. Shortly after Susan vanished, Michael had abandoned a car at a wrecking yard in Oregon, and police suspected he had helped his brother dispose of Susan’s body. Michael was never charged with anything connected to the case.
In September 2011, a judge granted temporary custody of the two boys to Susan’s parents, Charles and Judy Cox. The boys moved to Washington to live with their grandparents. Josh was allowed supervised visits, and the court set conditions for him to regain custody, including a psychosexual evaluation and a polygraph test, ordered on 1 February 2012.
February 5, 2012
On Sunday 5 February 2012, social worker Elizabeth Griffin drove Charlie, now seven, and Braden, now five, to their father’s rented house in Graham, Washington, for a supervised visit. Josh met them at the door, took the boys inside, and locked the social worker out. Within minutes, he had attacked the children with a hatchet, doused the house in petrol, and set it alight. The house exploded. All three died.
Investigators later determined that Josh had planned the killings in advance. He had given away boxes of the children’s toys to charity over the preceding weekend, and minutes before the fire he had emailed his pastor and family members with instructions about his final affairs. None of the emails mentioned Susan. The official cause of death for Josh and the boys was carbon monoxide poisoning, though the coroner also noted that both children had suffered serious chopping injuries to the head and neck.
The deaths destroyed the last living witness who could have said what happened to Susan. They also destroyed the custody case, and with it the legal pressure that had been building on Josh Powell for more than two years.
What remains
A year later, on 11 February 2013, Michael Powell died by suicide in Minneapolis, jumping from the roof of a parking garage. Three months after that, on 21 May 2013, West Valley City police announced that they were closing their active investigation into Susan Powell’s disappearance. They stated their belief that Josh Powell had murdered his wife on the night of 6 December 2009, and that his brother Michael had helped him conceal her body. Despite extensive searches of the Utah desert, her remains have never been found.
Susan’s parents have continued to press for answers, and for the legal recognition of what happened to their daughter. Attempts to have her legally declared dead have continued. In July 2020, the state of Washington awarded the Cox family 98 million dollars in a negligence case arising from the deaths of their grandsons, finding that the state agency supervising the visit had failed to follow its own safety procedures.
The case has become one of the most closely followed missing-person cases in American history, and one of the most painful. It is a case about a woman who vanished from her own home, a husband whose story never made sense, and two small boys who became the centre of a custody battle that ended in fire. The police believe they know what happened to Susan Powell. What they do not have is her body, a charge, or a trial. And now the only people who could have told them are all dead.
What is documented — and what is not
Documented: Susan Marie Powell, 28, was last seen alive on the afternoon of 6 December 2009 at her home in West Valley City, Utah. Her husband, Joshua Powell, was named a person of interest on 14 December 2009 and was never charged. Police found traces of Susan’s blood in the home and her phone in Josh’s car. On 5 February 2012, Josh Powell killed his sons Charles, 7, and Braden, 5, and himself in a house fire during a supervised visit in Graham, Washington, after locking out the social worker. His brother Michael Powell died by suicide on 11 February 2013. On 21 May 2013, West Valley City police closed their active investigation, stating their belief that Josh Powell had murdered Susan and that Michael had helped conceal her body. Susan’s remains have never been found. In July 2020, Washington State awarded Susan’s parents 98 million dollars in a negligence case over the deaths of their grandchildren.
Unverified or unproven: That Josh Powell killed Susan on the night of 6 December 2009 is the police’s stated belief, not a finding of any court. No body has ever been found, so there is no confirmed cause or manner of death, and no confirmed location where she died. That Michael Powell helped dispose of her body is a police suspicion, never tested in court. The children’s reported statements about their mother being with them on the camping trip were made by very young children and were never corroborated. Theories about where her body was taken, including searches of the Utah desert, have produced no evidence.