The Trial of Bruno Hauptmann

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

On the night of 1 March 1932, twenty-month-old Charles Augustus Lindbergh Jr., the son of the aviator Charles Lindbergh and his wife Anne Morrow Lindbergh, was taken from his crib in the second-floor nursery of the family’s home, Highfields, in East Amwell Township, New Jersey, near Hopewell. A ransom note demanding $50,000 was left on the windowsill, and a homemade ladder was found outside the house. The child was the son of the most famous man in America — Lindbergh had flown solo across the Atlantic five years earlier — and the crime became known, in the newspapers’ phrase, as the crime of the century.

The baby was never returned alive. On 12 May 1932, a truck driver found the body of a small child in a wooded area about four and a half miles from the Lindbergh home. The body was identified as Charles Lindbergh Jr., and a medical examination found that he had died of a massive skull fracture, apparently suffered during or shortly after the kidnapping. For more than two years, the investigation produced no suspect. Then a single marked banknote changed everything, and led to a trial that was as much a public spectacle as a legal proceeding.

The Crime and the Ransom

Over the following weeks, further ransom notes arrived, and a go-between was appointed: Dr John F. Condon, a retired school principal from the Bronx, who called himself “Jafsie” in the correspondence. Condon met a man who claimed to represent the kidnappers and, on 2 April 1932, handed over $50,000 in gold certificates whose serial numbers had been carefully recorded by the authorities. The child was not returned. The money, the notes, and the ladder became the three pillars of the case that would eventually be built against Bruno Hauptmann.

The Arrest

For two years, the recorded ransom money barely moved. Gold certificates were becoming rare — the United States had gone off the gold standard in 1933 — and banks were instructed to watch for them. On 15 September 1934, a man paid for petrol at a service station in the Bronx with a $10 gold certificate from the ransom payment. The attendant, suspicious, wrote down the car’s licence plate. It was traced to Bruno Richard Hauptmann, a German immigrant carpenter living in the Bronx.

Hauptmann was arrested on 19 September 1934. A search of his home and garage found more than $14,000 of the ransom money hidden in his garage, along with Condon’s telephone number written on a closet wall. Hauptmann said the money had been left with him by a friend, Isidor Fisch, who had returned to Germany in December 1933 and died there in March 1934. Fisch could not be questioned, and the claim could not be tested.

Hauptmann was indicted in the Bronx on 24 September 1934 for extorting the $50,000 ransom, and on 8 October 1934 he was indicted in New Jersey for the murder of Charles Augustus Lindbergh Jr. He was transferred to New Jersey and held in the Hunterdon County Jail in Flemington. He pleaded not guilty to all charges.

The Trial at Flemington

The trial, formally the State of New Jersey v. Bruno Richard Hauptmann, opened on 2 January 1935 at the Hunterdon County Courthouse in Flemington, New Jersey, before Judge Thomas W. Trenchard. The prosecution was led by New Jersey Attorney General David T. Wilentz. The defence was led by Edward J. Reilly, whose fees were paid under an arrangement involving the New York Daily Mirror.

The prosecution’s case was entirely circumstantial. No witness placed Hauptmann at the Lindbergh home on the night of the kidnapping, and no fingerprints of his were found on the ladder, the ransom notes, or in the nursery. Instead, the state built its case on three strands of evidence. First, the money: the ransom bills found in Hauptmann’s garage and on his person, which the prosecution said could only have come from the kidnapping. Second, handwriting: experts testified that Hauptmann’s handwriting matched the writing on the ransom notes. Third, wood: Arthur Koehler, a federal wood expert, testified that the wood of the homemade ladder found at the Lindbergh home matched lumber from Hauptmann’s attic — including a distinctive piece that appeared to have been cut from a floorboard in his home.

The trial lasted six weeks. On 13 February 1935, after about eleven hours of deliberation, the jury found Hauptmann guilty of first-degree murder. Judge Trenchard sentenced him to death by electrocution immediately. Outside the courthouse, a crowd of about ten thousand people cheered the verdict.

Appeals and Execution

On 3 April 1936, at 8:44 p.m., Bruno Richard Hauptmann was executed in the electric chair at the New Jersey State Prison in Trenton. He maintained his innocence to the end.

The Doubts That Remain

Hauptmann’s guilt has been debated ever since. Supporters of the verdict point to the ransom money in his garage — the strongest single piece of evidence — together with the handwriting and wood evidence, as a coherent case that no innocent explanation fits. Critics argue that the trial was compromised by publicity, that the handwriting and voice-identification evidence was unreliable, that the wood evidence was overstated, and that the police may have mishandled or even manufactured evidence. Some have argued that Hauptmann may have been involved in the extortion without being the kidnapper or the killer, or that others were involved and never identified.

What Is Documented, and What Is Not

Documented facts: Charles Augustus Lindbergh Jr., aged 20 months, was abducted from his home in East Amwell, New Jersey, on the night of 1 March 1932; a ransom note demanding $50,000 was left behind. A $50,000 ransom was paid on 2 April 1932 through go-between John F. Condon, but the child was not returned. The child’s body was found on 12 May 1932 about four and a half miles from the home, and the cause of death was determined to be a massive skull fracture. Bruno Richard Hauptmann was arrested on 19 September 1934 after a ransom bill was traced to him, and more than $14,000 in ransom money was found in his garage. His trial in Flemington ran from 2 January to 13 February 1935; the jury found him guilty of first-degree murder and he was sentenced to death. He was executed by electric chair at Trenton on 3 April 1936 at 8:44 p.m. The Federal Kidnapping Act was passed on 22 June 1932.

Unverified or unestablished claims: Hauptmann’s claim that the ransom money was left with him by Isidor Fisch, who died in Germany in March 1934, was never proved or disproved — Fisch could not be questioned. The reliability of the voice identification by Charles Lindbergh and the handwriting evidence was contested at trial and remains disputed by critics. Claims that police manufactured evidence, or that other people were involved in the kidnapping, are theories advanced in later books and articles, not findings of any court. The question of whether Hauptmann acted alone has never been resolved.

Sources

  • https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lindbergh_kidnapping
  • https://www.britannica.com/event/Lindbergh-baby-kidnapping
  • https://www.encyclopedia.com/people/social-sciences-and-law/crime-and-law-enforcement-biographies/bruno-richard-hauptmann
  • https://WWW.SMITHSONIANMAG.COM/smart-news/the-trial-of-bruno-richard-hauptmann-accused-murderer-of-the-lindbergh-baby-began-in-new-jersey-on-this-day-in-1935-180985694/
  • https://historicfortsnelling.org/lindbergh/learn/kidnapping

Leave a Comment