The Nuremberg Trials: Justice for the Crimes of a Regime

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

In November 1945, six months after the end of the Second World War in Europe, the leaders of the defeated Nazi regime were brought into a courtroom in Nuremberg, Germany, to answer for what they had done. It was an event without precedent. Never before had the leaders of a state been tried by an international court for waging aggressive war, for war crimes and for crimes against humanity.

The trials lasted almost a year. Twenty-four men were indicted. Twelve were sentenced to death. The proceedings created a body of law that still shapes international justice today — and they left a set of arguments about victors’ justice that have never fully gone away.

Why Nuremberg

As the war ended, the Allies — the United States, Britain, France and the Soviet Union — had to decide what to do with the surviving leaders of Nazi Germany. Some argued for summary execution. Others, above all the Americans, argued for a trial. The decision was to create an International Military Tribunal under a charter agreed in London on 8 August 1945.

Nuremberg was chosen for practical and symbolic reasons. Its Palace of Justice was one of the few large court buildings in Germany still largely intact, and it had space for a prison. Symbolically, Nuremberg was the city of the Nazi Party rallies and the place where the Nuremberg Laws of 1935 had stripped German Jews of their citizenship. Trying the regime’s leaders there was a deliberate choice.

The indictment charged the defendants with four counts: conspiracy to wage aggressive war, crimes against peace, war crimes, and crimes against humanity. The last of these — crimes against humanity, including the systematic murder of millions of Jews and others in the Holocaust — was a new concept in international law.

The trial

The trial opened on 20 November 1945, before judges from all four Allied powers, presided over by the British judge Sir Geoffrey Lawrence. The chief prosecutor for the United States was Robert H. Jackson, a justice of the US Supreme Court. The prosecution’s case rested heavily on the Nazis’ own documents — thousands of pages of orders, minutes and reports captured by the Allies — and on film footage of the concentration camps.

Twenty-four men were indicted, but only 22 stood trial. Robert Ley, the head of the German Labour Front, killed himself in prison before the trial began. Gustav Krupp, the industrialist, was declared mentally and physically unfit to stand trial. Martin Bormann, Hitler’s deputy, had disappeared and was tried in his absence.

The defendants included Hermann Göring, the most senior surviving Nazi after Hitler; Rudolf Hess, Hitler’s former deputy; Joachim von Ribbentrop, the foreign minister; Wilhelm Keitel, head of the armed forces; and Albert Speer, the armaments minister. The trial ran for 216 court sessions over ten months, hearing evidence from witnesses and examining thousands of documents.

The defence made two arguments that would be heard again at every war crimes trial since. First, that the defendants were only following orders. Second, that the court had no right to try them, because the crimes had not existed in law when they were committed. The tribunal rejected both. Following orders could reduce a sentence, the judges said, but it was not a defence. And the London Charter had created the law under which they were tried.

The verdicts

Judgment was delivered on 30 September and 1 October 1946. Of the 22 men tried, 19 were convicted and three were acquitted.

Twelve were sentenced to death: Göring, Ribbentrop, Keitel, Ernst Kaltenbrunner, Alfred Rosenberg, Hans Frank, Wilhelm Frick, Julius Streicher, Fritz Sauckel, Alfred Jodl, Arthur Seyss-Inquart and Bormann, in his absence. Three received life sentences: Hess, Walther Funk and Erich Raeder. Four received prison terms of ten to twenty years: Karl Dönitz, Baldur von Schirach, Albert Speer and Konstantin von Neurath. Three were acquitted on all counts: Hjalmar Schacht, Franz von Papen and Hans Fritzsche.

Ten of the condemned men were hanged on 16 October 1946, in the prison gymnasium at Nuremberg. Göring cheated the executioner, killing himself with a cyanide capsule in his cell the night before. Bormann was never found; he was later confirmed to have died in Berlin in May 1945.

What Nuremberg left behind

The main trial was only the beginning. Twelve further trials were held at Nuremberg between 1946 and 1949, trying doctors, judges, industrialists, generals and SS officers for their part in the regime’s crimes. In total, the Nuremberg process tried nearly 200 people.

The legacy of the trials is still argued over. Critics at the time — and since — have called them victors’ justice, pointing out that the Allies were never tried for their own actions, including the bombing of civilian targets. Supporters answer that the trials established a principle that had not existed before: that individuals, not just states, can be held responsible under international law, and that “I was only following orders” is not an excuse.

That principle is now part of the foundations of international law. It runs through the Geneva Conventions, the tribunals for Yugoslavia and Rwanda, and the International Criminal Court, founded in 2002. Whatever its flaws, Nuremberg was the first time the world tried to answer a regime’s crimes with law instead of revenge — and the first time a court said that crimes against humanity were crimes at all.

What the record shows

  • The International Military Tribunal at Nuremberg was created under the London Charter of 8 August 1945. The trial opened on 20 November 1945 at the Palace of Justice in Nuremberg and ran for 216 sessions.
  • Twenty-four men were indicted on four counts: conspiracy, crimes against peace, war crimes and crimes against humanity. Twenty-two stood trial; Robert Ley died by suicide before it began and Gustav Krupp was declared unfit.
  • Verdicts were delivered on 30 September and 1 October 1946: 12 sentenced to death, three to life imprisonment, four to prison terms of 10 to 20 years, and three acquitted (Schacht, von Papen and Fritzsche).
  • Ten men were hanged on 16 October 1946. Hermann Göring killed himself the night before his execution. Martin Bormann was sentenced to death in his absence.
  • Twelve further trials were held at Nuremberg between 1946 and 1949, trying nearly 200 more defendants.
  • Disputed/unverified: Whether the trials were “victors’ justice” remains a matter of historical and legal debate. The fate of Martin Bormann was uncertain for decades until his remains were identified in Berlin in 1972 and confirmed by DNA testing in 1998.
  • Unresolved: None of the central verdicts has been overturned, but historians continue to debate the fairness of trying defendants under laws created after the acts in question.

Sources

Leave a Comment