The Murder of Thelma Todd

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

Thelma Todd had everything a Hollywood career was supposed to bring. She was a gifted comedian — Hal Roach’s female answer to Laurel and Hardy, a co-star of the Marx Brothers, Buster Keaton, and Laurel and Hardy themselves — and in 1934 she had opened her own restaurant on the Pacific Coast Highway, Thelma Todd’s Sidewalk Cafe, which drew the film colony’s brightest names. On the morning of Monday, 16 December 1935, she was found dead in her car, parked in a garage a block from the café. She was 29.

Her death was officially ruled accidental. But the circumstances — a locked door, a running car, a garage door raised a few inches, and a circle of powerful men with reasons to want her quiet — have made her death one of Hollywood’s lasting mysteries.

The Ice Cream Blonde

Thelma Alice Todd was born on 29 July 1906 in Lawrence, Massachusetts. A bright student who had intended to become a schoolteacher, she won beauty pageants as a teenager — Miss Lawrence and Miss Massachusetts in 1925 — and was spotted by a Hollywood talent scout. She arrived at Hal Roach Studios in 1929 and found her gift: comedy. Roach teamed her with ZaSu Pitts for seventeen slapstick shorts, then with Patsy Kelly for twenty-one more, casting Todd as the level-headed working girl holding her poise while chaos erupted around her. She appeared in about 120 feature films and shorts between 1926 and 1935, including Monkey Business and Horse Feathers with the Marx Brothers, and the original 1931 version of The Maltese Falcon.

In August 1934, Todd opened Thelma Todd’s Sidewalk Cafe at 17575 Pacific Coast Highway in Castellammare, Pacific Palisades, in partnership with the director Roland West and his wife, actress Jewel Carmen. The ground floor held the restaurant; Todd and West lived in adjoining apartments upstairs, and the top floor held a dance floor and bandstand. The café attracted Hollywood celebrities and tourists alike, and it made Todd a businesswoman as well as a star.

The last weekend

On Saturday night, 14 December 1935, Todd attended a party at the Trocadero, the popular Hollywood restaurant, hosted by the entertainer Stanley Lupino and his actress daughter Ida. She had a brief but unpleasant exchange there with her ex-husband, Pat DiCicco — a man with reported mob ties, whose marriage to Todd had been volatile and abusive, and whom she had divorced, leaving him one dollar in her will. Her friends said she was in good spirits, and nothing in her behaviour suggested she intended to harm herself. Her chauffeur, Ernest O. Peters, drove her home in the early hours of 15 December.

On the morning of Monday, 16 December, Todd’s maid arrived at the garage on Posetano — the garage at the home of Jewel Carmen, about a block from the café — to fetch Todd’s car, as she usually did. She found Todd inside her chocolate-coloured 1934 Lincoln Phaeton convertible, slumped behind the wheel, still wearing the mauve and silver gown, mink wrap, and expensive jewellery from Saturday night. Her death was determined to have been caused by carbon monoxide poisoning, though the garage door was raised roughly three to four inches.

The investigation

West was quoted in a contemporary newspaper account as having locked Todd out — which may have caused her to seek refuge and warmth in the car. Todd had a heart condition that made climbing the stairs to the garage difficult, and she normally sent her maid to fetch the car. West had locked her out before, and she had broken a window to get in.

The autopsy surgeon, A. P. Wagner, testified that there were “no marks of violence anywhere upon or within the body,” with only a “superficial contusion on the lower lip.” The coroner’s inquest, held on 18 December, returned a verdict that the death appeared accidental, but recommended “further investigation to be made into the case, by proper authorities.” A grand jury probe followed: after four weeks of testimony, it concluded with no evidence of foul play. The Homicide Bureau closed the case, declaring the death “accidental with possible suicide tendencies” — although investigators found no motive for suicide, and Todd left no note.

The theories

Three explanations have competed ever since. The first is the official one: that Todd, locked out and cold, got into her car to keep warm or to drive it, and was overcome by the fumes. The second is suicide — a finding some contemporary reports favoured — but no motive and no note were ever found. The third is murder, and it has taken several forms: that gangsters who wanted to turn her café into a gambling establishment killed her when she refused to sell; that Roland West killed her in a quarrel; or that her ex-husband DiCicco was involved.

The murder theories rest on claims rather than evidence. Years later, both Hal Roach and the actor Chester Morris claimed that West had killed Todd; one account says West confessed to Morris on his deathbed in 1952. Those claims were made decades after the fact and have never been corroborated. West continued to run the café after Todd’s death, renaming it Chez Roland, and died in 1952.

Todd’s memorial service drew large crowds to view the open casket at Pierce Brothers Mortuary in Los Angeles. She was cremated, and after her mother’s death in 1969, her remains were placed in her mother’s casket and buried in Bellevue Cemetery in her hometown of Lawrence, Massachusetts. She has a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame at 6262 Hollywood Boulevard.

What is documented — and what is not

Documented: Thelma Todd (29 July 1906 – 16 December 1935) appeared in about 120 films and shorts and co-owned Thelma Todd’s Sidewalk Cafe at 17575 Pacific Coast Highway, Pacific Palisades, opened in August 1934 with Roland West and Jewel Carmen. On the morning of 16 December 1935 she was found dead in her 1934 Lincoln Phaeton in the garage at Jewel Carmen’s home, of carbon monoxide poisoning, with the garage door raised three to four inches. She had spent the night of 14 December at a party at the Trocadero. The coroner’s jury ruled the death appeared accidental but recommended further investigation; a grand jury found no evidence of foul play; the Homicide Bureau declared the death “accidental with possible suicide tendencies.” The autopsy found no marks of violence except a superficial contusion on the lower lip. Todd’s ex-husband Pat DiCicco was abusive and she had left him one dollar in her will.

Unverified or unproven: That Todd was murdered — no evidence of foul play was found by the grand jury, and no one was ever charged. That gangsters killed her over the café — a widely repeated story with no supporting evidence. That Roland West killed her, or confessed to doing so on his deathbed — claims made decades later by Roach and Morris, never corroborated. That Todd intended suicide — no motive and no note were found. The official finding remains accidental, with the coroner’s own jury calling for further investigation that produced nothing.

Sources

Leave a Comment