Between 1981 and 1986, four young girls disappeared from streets, fairgrounds and country lanes across Britain and Northern Ireland. Jennifer Cardy was nine. Susan Maxwell was eleven. Caroline Hogg was five. Sarah Harper was ten. For years their cases were treated as separate tragedies in different police areas. The man who killed them was Robert Black, a delivery driver whose job took him the length of the country — and whose van, his employer’s records and his own fuel receipts eventually gave him away. He was caught in 1990 with a six-year-old girl in the back of his van, convicted of three murders in 1994 and a fourth in 2011, and died in prison in 2016. He never admitted to any of the killings.
Black was born on 21 April 1947 in Scotland. As an adult he worked as a delivery driver for a London firm that supplied posters, driving a van to towns across Britain and to Northern Ireland. The job gave him a reason to be anywhere, and a vehicle in which to take a child without being noticed. He had already been convicted of sexual offences against children before the murders began, a history that the police did not connect to the missing girls until much later.
Four Girls, Five Years
The first victim was Jennifer Cardy, nine years old, who disappeared on 12 August 1981 while cycling to a friend’s house in Ballinderry, County Antrim. Her body was found six days later in a dam near Hillsborough, about ten miles away. A year later, in July 1982, eleven-year-old Susan Maxwell vanished from Cornhill-on-Tweed, on the Scottish border. In July 1983, five-year-old Caroline Hogg disappeared from a fairground near her home in Edinburgh. And on 26 March 1986, ten-year-old Sarah Harper was snatched on her way back from a corner shop near her home in Morley, near Leeds. Each girl was abducted in daylight, in a place she knew, and each was found dead far from where she had been taken.
For years the cases were investigated separately. The breakthrough came not from a single clue but from the slow accumulation of evidence: delivery records and fuel receipts that placed Black’s van in the right places at the right times, and a pattern — girls taken from public places in the daytime, in towns along his routes — that finally looked like the work of one man.
Caught at Stow
On 14 July 1990, in the Scottish village of Stow, police stopped Black’s van and found a six-year-old girl inside, bound, gagged and hidden in a sleeping bag. She was barely alive. Black pleaded guilty to kidnapping and sexually assaulting her, and was jailed. It was the first time he had been caught in the act, and it gave investigators the opening they needed. Police linked him to the three unsolved murders and to an attempted abduction in Nottingham in 1988, and charged him.
At Newcastle Crown Court in 1994, Black was convicted on 19 May of the kidnapping and murder of Susan Maxwell, Caroline Hogg and Sarah Harper, and of the attempted kidnapping in Nottingham. The case against him was circumstantial — it rested on his employer’s records, his fuel receipts, and the similarities between the cases — but the jury was convinced. He was sentenced to life imprisonment, with a recommendation that he serve a minimum of 35 years.
The Fourth Conviction
Jennifer Cardy’s case had remained unsolved for thirty years. In 2011, Black was tried at Armagh Crown Court for her murder. The prosecution argued that the striking similarities between her abduction and the three murders for which he had already been convicted proved his guilt. On 27 October 2011, the jury found him guilty of her kidnapping and murder, and he received a further life sentence, with a 25-year minimum term. His appeal was dismissed in 2013.
Black died on 12 January 2016 at HMP Maghaberry in Northern Ireland, aged 68, after suffering a heart attack. At the time of his death he was still regarded as the prime suspect in the 1978 disappearance of 13-year-old Genette Tate in Devon, but he was never charged in that case, and it remains unsolved. The four families whose daughters he was convicted of killing waited between eight and thirty years for a verdict. The girl he was caught with at Stow survived, and her rescue is the reason the other cases were solved at all.
What Is Documented — and What Is Not
Documented: Robert Black was born on 21 April 1947. He was convicted of the kidnap, rape and murder of four girls: Jennifer Cardy, 9, abducted in Ballinderry, County Antrim, on 12 August 1981; Susan Maxwell, 11, abducted in Cornhill-on-Tweed in July 1982; Caroline Hogg, 5, abducted in Edinburgh in July 1983; and Sarah Harper, 10, abducted in Morley, near Leeds, on 26 March 1986. On 14 July 1990 he was caught at Stow, in the Scottish Borders, with a six-year-old girl in his van, and pleaded guilty to her abduction and sexual assault. On 19 May 1994, at Newcastle Crown Court, he was convicted of the murders of Maxwell, Hogg and Harper and of an attempted abduction in Nottingham in 1988, and sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 35 years. In October 2011 he was convicted at Armagh Crown Court of Jennifer Cardy’s murder and given a further life sentence with a 25-year minimum; his appeal was dismissed in 2013. He died on 12 January 2016 at HMP Maghaberry, aged 68. He never admitted any of the four killings.
Not documented / unverified: Some press reports date the Cardy conviction to 2012 rather than 2011; the trial and verdict were in October 2011. The 1988 Nottingham offence is described in different sources as an attempted kidnapping or as false imprisonment. Black was the prime suspect in the disappearance of Genette Tate in 1978, but he was never charged, and the suggestion that he was responsible remains unproven. The exact dates of the Maxwell and Hogg abductions are given as July 1982 and July 1983 in most accounts, without precise days. The number of other children Black may have attacked is unknown; he was convicted of the offences listed above and suspected of more, but no further murder has been proven against him.