The Murder of Elizabeth Barraza: The Doorbell Video That Solved Nothing

Reading Time: 7 minutes ·

On the morning of Friday, 25 January 2019, Elizabeth “Liz” Barraza woke early in her home on Cedar Walk Drive in Tomball, Texas, and began setting up a garage sale in her driveway. She was 29, married for almost five years, and looking forward to a holiday: two days later, she and her husband Sergio were due to fly to Orlando, Florida, for their fifth wedding anniversary, and the sale was meant to raise a little extra spending money.

Within minutes of her husband leaving for work, a dark pickup truck pulled up outside the house. A figure got out, walked up the driveway, and shot Liz four times at close range. The attack lasted seconds, and it was recorded — by her own doorbell camera and by a neighbour’s security camera. More than seven years later, no one has been arrested, and no one has been charged.

Liz Barraza

Elizabeth Marie Nuelle was born on 26 June 1989 in Elk Grove Village, Illinois, the youngest child of Bob and Rosemary Nuelle. She grew up in Texas, met Sergio Barraza when they were young, and married him on 1 February 2014. By 2019 they lived in the Princeton Place subdivision of Tomball, a city in Harris County, northwest of Houston. They had no children.

Liz worked as a data reporter for a pipeline inspection company and had taken the day off for the sale. Outside work, she belonged to the 501st Legion, a Star Wars costuming group whose members volunteer at charity events, and she regularly visited sick children at Memorial Hermann Hospital in costume. She would later die at that same hospital.

A last-minute garage sale

The sale was a last-minute idea. On Thursday, 24 January, Liz decided to hold it that Friday and Saturday to raise money for the Florida trip. That evening, she and Sergio put up two signs in the neighbourhood. They did not advertise it on social media or in a local paper, and according to Sergio, only a handful of people knew about it: a few of Liz’s co-workers and their parents.

That detail made investigators suspicious: a stranger passing by would have had no reason to know a garage sale was happening on Cedar Walk Drive at dawn on a Friday. Whoever came that morning knew about the sale in advance, or knew Liz’s routine well enough to know she would be outside, alone, at that hour.

Liz and Sergio were up early on Friday. At 6:08 a.m., Liz stopped at a nearby Starbucks, and back home the couple set up tables in the driveway together. Sergio left for work at 6:48 a.m. He kissed his wife goodbye. It was the last time he would see her alive.

The morning of 25 January 2019

What happened next is known almost minute by minute, because so much of it was captured on camera. At around 2:00 a.m., neighbourhood cameras recorded a dark pickup truck driving slowly past the Barraza home; it was seen circling the area again before dawn. Minutes later, Sergio passed by on his way to work, and the truck made its way to Cedar Walk Drive.

At 6:52 a.m., the truck pulled up outside the house, turned around, and stopped. A figure climbed out and walked up the driveway toward Liz. Her Google Nest doorbell camera recorded the encounter in poor-quality audio: Liz can be heard greeting the person — “Good morning” — apparently expecting her first customer. The two spoke for a few seconds. Nobody knows exactly what was said; the recording is too unclear to tell.

Then the figure raised a gun and fired. Three shots came in quick succession. Liz fell to the driveway. The shooter stood over her for a moment, then fired a fourth shot, turned, and sprinted back to the truck. The entire attack lasted about eighteen seconds. The truck pulled away, drove past the house once more about two minutes later, as if the driver were checking the scene, and left the subdivision.

Neighbours heard the shots. Candy Ellis, who lived nearby, heard all four and called 911 immediately; another neighbour, Cynthia Greist, called Sergio. Paramedics found Liz alive but critically injured in her driveway, and she was flown by helicopter to Memorial Hermann Hospital in The Woodlands, arriving at about 7:21 a.m. Sergio turned back from work and drove to the hospital after seeing police tape on his own home through the Nest camera feed.

Liz was placed on life support. Just after 1:40 p.m. on Saturday, 26 January 2019, she died from her injuries, with her husband and family beside her. She was 29 years old.

What the cameras recorded

For investigators, the footage should have been a gift: very few murders are filmed from two angles in the victim’s own driveway. Yet it has proved almost useless for identifying the killer.

The neighbour’s camera captured the whole incident — the truck arriving, the figure walking up the driveway, the shooting, and the escape. But the image is grainy, the light was poor at 6:52 a.m. in January, and the shooter was disguised: a loose robe or long coat, long hair, face obscured. Investigators cannot even be certain whether the shooter was a man or a woman.

The truck is the clearest lead. Police identified it as a dark-coloured Nissan Frontier Pro-4X crew cab, model year 2013 or newer, with a PRO-4X sticker on the rear. It was seen circling the neighbourhood hours before the murder, suggesting the driver had scouted the area and the timing. But no licence plate was readable, and the truck has never been traced to an owner. The weapon is believed to have been a revolver: no shell casings were found at the scene.

In January 2021, police released the doorbell footage to the public, hoping a fresh audience might recognise something. It brought new tips, but no arrest.

The investigation

The Harris County Sheriff’s Office led the investigation, with help from the Texas Rangers and the FBI. Detectives canvassed the neighbourhood, collected every piece of security footage they could find, and looked into everyone connected to Liz’s life. They found no enemies — by every account, Liz was well liked, with no debts, no criminal involvement, and no secret life.

Nothing was stolen. The killer took nothing and left nothing behind except the video — ruling out a robbery gone wrong, and leaving the harder question: why would anyone want Liz Barraza dead?

Sergio Barraza was, as husbands almost always are in such cases, the first person detectives looked at. He was detained and questioned on the day of the murder, cooperated, and voluntarily took a polygraph test, which he passed. Detectives examined the couple’s finances and marriage and found no evidence of trouble — no infidelity, no money problems, no arguments anyone could point to. The Harris County Sheriff’s Office, the Texas Rangers and the FBI have all investigated the case and found no evidence against him, and Sergio has consistently denied any involvement. He did not collect on a $500,000 life insurance policy Liz had taken out; as of May 2025, it had still not been paid out.

Even so, the question of Sergio has never quite gone away. In a television programme about the case in 2026, Harris County detective Sergeant Michael Ritchie said he had still not ruled Sergio out, because in his words everybody remained a suspect. That is a long way from an accusation, but it shows how little certainty the investigation has been able to offer.

Other lines of inquiry — the 501st Legion, her workplace, mistaken identity, a killer who wanted Sergio rather than Liz — have produced nothing.

One theory has been raised repeatedly by Liz’s father, Bob Nuelle: that his daughter was the victim of a murder-for-hire plot. He told Houston television station ABC13 in January 2024 that he believed someone had paid to have Liz killed. No evidence of a contract killing has been made public, and no one has been charged. But the truck circling beforehand, the timing — minutes after Sergio left — and the calm way the shooter walked away all suggest someone who knew where Liz would be and when she would be alone.

Seven years on

Liz’s family set up a website, WhoKilledLizBarraza.com, and have campaigned for answers ever since. Crime Stoppers of Houston offers $50,000 for information leading to an arrest and conviction (HCSO case 1901-07970); anyone with information is asked to call (713) 222-TIPS.

The story has been retold on On the Case with Paula Zahn (2022), the Crime Junkie podcast (January 2025), and Somebody Knows Something on Freeform and ABC (2026). Each telling brings fresh tips — and so far, no breakthrough.

In 2025, a memorial bench for Liz was placed in Burroughs Park, near Tomball. Bob Nuelle, who had spent six years fighting for justice for his daughter, died in May 2026 and was honoured at a service at the bench. He did not live to see his daughter’s killer identified.

Liz Barraza’s murder is the most frustrating kind of cold case: not one with no evidence, but one with evidence that stops just short of an answer — a truck without a readable plate, a face hidden by disguise and darkness, a voice too distorted to recognise, and a motive nobody can find.

What is documented — and what is not

Documented: Elizabeth “Liz” Barraza, 29, was shot four times in her driveway in Tomball, Texas, on 25 January 2019 while setting up a garage sale, and died at Memorial Hermann Hospital at about 1:40 p.m. on 26 January 2019. Sergio left for work at 6:48 a.m.; the shooting took place at about 6:52 a.m. A dark Nissan Frontier Pro-4X crew cab (2013 or newer) was recorded circling the area beforehand and fleeing afterwards. Her doorbell camera recorded poor-quality audio of a brief exchange before the shots; a neighbour’s camera recorded the attack and the truck. The weapon is believed to have been a revolver; no shell casings were found, and nothing was stolen. The Harris County Sheriff’s Office, the Texas Rangers and the FBI found no evidence against Sergio Barraza; he passed a polygraph and has denied involvement. A $50,000 reward is offered through Crime Stoppers of Houston (HCSO case 1901-07970).

Unverified or unproven: That Liz was four months pregnant when she was killed — this claim appears in some briefs about the case, but no reliable published source consulted for this article confirms it, so it is not stated here as fact. That the murder was a murder-for-hire plot — her father’s belief, stated publicly, but no evidence of a contract killing has been made public. That Sergio Barraza was involved — investigators found no evidence against him, and he has denied it. The identity and sex of the shooter, and the motive — the footage is too poor to identify the figure, and no motive has been established. What was said in the seconds before the shots — the doorbell audio is too unclear to transcribe.

Sources

Leave a Comment