The Great Gold Robbery of 1855: The Victorian Train Heist That Fooled Two Nations

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

On the night of 15 May 1855, a shipment of gold travelled by train from London toward Paris. When the boxes reached their destination, the gold was gone — replaced by lead shot, weighed to match. No lock had been forced and no seal appeared broken, and for weeks nobody could say in which country the theft had taken place. It was a crime of patience, inside knowledge, and keys copied in wax.

Gold on the Boat Train

In 1855 the South Eastern Railway ran a boat train between London Bridge station and Folkestone, on the Kent coast, connecting by steamer to Boulogne and by train to Paris. Gold bullion moved along this route regularly, carried for London dealers to their counterparts in Paris.

On 15 May 1855, three wooden boxes of gold bullion and coins were delivered to London Bridge for the dealers Abell & Co, Adam Spielmann & Co, and Messrs Bult & Co. Bound with iron hoops and sealed with wax, they were placed in the guard’s van of the 8:30 pm mail train to Folkestone. The gold weighed 224 pounds (102 kilograms) and was valued at £12,000 — roughly £1.1 million in 2025 terms. It travelled inside three Chubb steel safes, each fitted with two locks whose keys were held separately, so no single person held both.

The Four Men

The robbery was the work of four men. James Burgess was a guard on the Folkestone line, often in charge of trains carrying bullion. William Tester, assistant to the superintendent in the traffic department at London Bridge, knew about valuable shipments and controlled the guards’ rota.

The other two planned the crime. William Pierce, aged 37, was a former railway employee dismissed after it was found that he was a gambler; he now worked in a betting shop and drank in the pubs around London Bridge where railwaymen gathered, picking up details of the gold shipments. Edward Agar, just under 40, was a career criminal and skilled safe-cracker. Pierce concluded that a theft would only be possible with copies of the safe keys, and Agar agreed the scheme was impossible without an impression of them. Together they recruited Burgess, who could travel in the guard’s van, and Tester, who knew when shipments were due and could arrange the rota.

A Year of Preparation

The preparation took more than a year. In May 1854, Pierce and Agar travelled to Folkestone to watch where the keys were kept. When a Folkestone key was lost that July, the safes were sent back to Chubb for new locks and keys. Tester, who handled the correspondence with Chubb, smuggled the new keys out briefly so Agar could take an impression of one of them in green wax.

The gang still lacked one key. Agar learned where the Folkestone superintendent kept the safe key, and on a later visit, while railway staff left the office to meet an arriving boat, Pierce slipped inside, took the key to Agar waiting at the door, and Agar made a wax impression before the key was returned. Over the following months the two men made rough keys from the impressions, and in April and May 1855 Agar travelled the Folkestone route seven or eight times when Burgess was on duty, refining the keys until they worked smoothly. They also bought two hundredweight of lead shot from the Shot Tower at Lambeth, and Tester altered the staff rosters so Burgess was working on the evening mail service. A signal was arranged: if a shipment was being made, Burgess would walk out of London Bridge station and wipe his face with a white handkerchief.

The Night of 15 May 1855

On 15 May 1855, Burgess gave the signal. Agar hid in the guard’s van as the 8:30 pm train left London Bridge. During the journey he opened the safes with the copied keys, removed the gold, and replaced it with lead shot of matching weight, resealing the boxes so they appeared untouched. Tester took one bag of gold from Agar at Redhill, the train’s first stop, and returned to London.

The train continued to Folkestone, where the boxes were loaded onto the steamer for Boulogne as usual. At Boulogne the boxes were weighed: one was 40 pounds lighter than it should have been. The discrepancy did not stop the onward journey, and only when the boxes were opened in Paris was the substitution discovered. The English authorities insisted the robbery must have taken place in France; the French argued it must have happened in England. With the boxes apparently sealed and the safes apparently locked throughout, neither side could explain how it had been done.

How the Crime Came to Light

The police had no clues at first, and the investigation stalled. The break came months later, from within the gang’s own circle. In August 1855, Agar was arrested for passing a false cheque. He asked Pierce to provide funds for his former partner, Fanny Kay, and their child; Pierce agreed, then failed to do so. In need of money, Kay went to the governor of Newgate Prison and told him who had carried out the robbery.

Agar was questioned, admitted his guilt, and testified as a witness for the prosecution. Pierce, Tester, and Burgess were arrested, tried at the Old Bailey, and found guilty. Pierce received two years’ hard labour; Tester and Burgess were each sentenced to 14 years’ penal transportation. A fifth man, James Townshend Saward — a barrister known as “Jem the Penman” — was linked in the record to the disposal of the stolen gold through his forgery network. The gold was melted down and sold, and most of it was never recovered.

The case entered popular culture when Michael Crichton published his novel The Great Train Robbery in 1975 and adapted it into the 1978 film The First Great Train Robbery, with Sean Connery portraying Pierce. Its lasting effect was practical: it exposed how far insider knowledge could defeat even the best locks of the day. The safes had been opened without force, by men the system trusted — and that was the part no lock could prevent.

What Is Documented — and What Is Not

Documented: the date (15 May 1855); the route, the three dealers, the gold’s weight (224 pounds) and value (£12,000); the Chubb safes and two-key system; the four men’s roles; the wax impressions, lead shot, and handkerchief signal; the discovery in Paris; Agar’s arrest, Kay’s disclosure, and Agar’s testimony; the convictions and sentences; and Crichton’s 1975 novel and the 1978 film.

Unverified or disputed: the exact division of the proceeds is not firmly established — some accounts give Burgess £700 and others £600. The claim that Agar was set up by a rival when arrested for the false cheque appears in some retellings but is not established in the core record. How much gold Tester carried off at Redhill varies between accounts. No quotation from any participant is reproduced here, as the record does not reliably preserve their words.

Sources

Leave a Comment